34 Best Pizza Restaurants near Johnstown

“Wonderful experience at MOD Pizza! Great service and food was amazing!!!“

“We order from you often!! And will continue to.
Let me just say, that the pizza we ordered tonight, came perfectly!! ( Usually does!) We ordered light sauce, and, THANK YOU!! it was exactly perfectly light sauce.
Whoever you've got working tonight 10/21, did all AMAZING JOB!!! THANK YOU!“

“Awesome food and great selection of beer“

“Huge shout out to Domino’s. Saturday night my niece got married. The catering was beyond messed up. Barely enough food for 20 people when there were over 100 in attendance. One call to Domino’s, and an explanation of the situation, and we had around 40 pizzas delivered and all at an amazing price. Thank you Domino’s, you guys saved the day!“

“Stopped in on our way through the area and grabbed a couple slices and some cheesy bread to go. Food came out quickly and was fresh and delicious! The slices were large and foldable NY-style with lots of gooey cheese and that cheesy bread was nothing but gooey cheese and wonderfully crispy outside/fluffy inside crust. Highly recommend this place and wish I had gotten to try more!“

“We ordered Mama Ruth’s for my softball team. They pizza was hot, fresh and tasty. We will definitely order from them again and will stop in when we are in the area.“

“I love Pizza Vino! Such delicious food and excellent service! The atmosphere is also spot on! I would highly recommend coming here for a delicious and relaxing dinner. Great for date night or anytime! Amazing!!“

“Great food !Amazing owners! Rock Star staff members!!“

“This place is fantastic!! The best in windsor for pizza and all your favs !“

“Did the meat pizza and it is outstanding! Lots of meat and cheese! Great crust and friendly service!“

“Great Location, employees were friendly and service was fast. They have a crustless option for any of you KETO folks out there. I do miss the free cookie dough option after taking a survey though lol :)
Try the Gourmet Chicken & Garlic...you'll thank me later! Big Murphy Stuffed or the Cowboy are also solid choices.“

“This place exceeded my expectations. Service was fabulous and their food was delicious. The gal at the front was so sweet and very attentive. We were looking for a hole in the wall pizzeria and this place was exactly what we were looking for. We will be back!“

“Yes pizza good. BUT Brentwood is struggling to keep up with demand right now. Opening weekend “wiped them out”. Last night the line was long, took forever. After waiting over 30+ mins outside we were told we could not order whole pizzas, we could not order pastas etc as kitchen was slammed. Then was told only 2 slices per person so it could be fair to as many people as possible, which was nice. By the time we got to window the slices by the day, bunch ran out. Would be 15+ more mins to wait for them to make more. So we just went with something else as we had already waiting over an hours and had to feed kids to get him to bed on a school night. So yes would recommend but may be worth waiting until the initial excitement wears off, or the open the phones for phone ahead ordering, or they open the online ordering. Definitely not fun waiting on the cold for an hour. Also suggestion would be to add outdoor heaters since the inside had very limited seating. Maybe update sign outside with makeshift written sign if you decide to not offer whole pizzas, pastas or something else had been 86 from menu versus people waiting so long to find out inside.“

“Have dined here in the past with great experiences but last night was a bit weird . Nobody waited on us and finally went to the counter to order and was told that a waitress would come over. She never came so went back to counter and the nice but confused girl took our order . And then she went home🤣. So the cook took over and handled things like a professional. There was a girl manning the bar and she had her hands full. The food was great. I assume they were shorthanded so will give them a pass on the lack of service as they handled the stress professionally and with a smile .“

“Anthony's is my family's go-to spot for pizza. The pizza is delicious, and even better, it keeps well in the fridge. Beyond that, its made fresh in the resturaunt for each order; This is my only problem, since sometimes orders can take quite a long time. Beyond that, service is amazing.
One reccomendation I have however, is purchasing stronger paper plates, as the meat pizzas are extremely greasy, and eat thorugh the plate.

P.S. Shoutout to Nate for carrying the resturaunt last night.“

“Two times dining at the Hearth, two differing experiences.
First time, a group of five of us on an afternoon in July around 4:00. Busy atmosphere, but comfortable. We ordered various mocktails all of which were fabulous. We ordered and shared 5 or 6 different appetizers followed by one of every desert on the menu. All dishes well prepared, all delicious.
Service for our large-ish group was awesome, timely, knowledgeable, and friendly.
Second time dining here, I met up with one friend around 5:30 on a weekday evening in September. Busy atmosphere a bit loud for relaxing conversation. flies everywhere...on us, our food, our beverages (mocktails, which tasted wonderful to us and the flies). Not much can be done about fly invasion in a restaurant with indoor/outdoor seating. Room temp drinking water, not pleasant. We ordered salad meals which were very fresh and tasty. Service was pretty good, slow food delivery and had to request more water, but it was a busy early evening. Overall, an okay dining experience the second time. I'll certainly head back this autumn and give another go. The food and bevs are worth it.“

“Disappointed with this first time order. Pizza was just barely cooked through. Huge crust with very thin dough base. Hardly any sauce (dry) Toppings were so so. Not much flavor, probably due to lack of sauce and cheese. Sticker shock like always these days. Sticker shock is worse when prices go up and product is skimpy. It's like two price hikes.“

“The pizza is great. I had it delivered and I paid with cash. I accidentally (bills stuck together)gave the delivery guy $50 too much. He came back a minute later and asked me if I had meant to do this. This goes a long way with me and you have earned a customer for life. Thanks.“

“Very affordable happy hour 🍻“

“We’ve been visiting Estes Park for 9 years now, from Minnesota. Antonio’s is an absolute must and we look forward to coming here every year. Best pizza we’ve ever had, no contest. We have some favorites of course, but you really can’t go wrong with anything here. The freshness of ingredients and quality of the food are incredible. Thank you for doing what you do and continuously making amazing food, even when times get rough. You are a true gem in this area and we already can’t wait to come back for pizza next year.“

“Never had a bad pizza from PAPA Murphy’s“

“Pizza is still the best deal in food. Feed a family for $5-9 Bucks a person. I have never had an issue with this place. Lots of our young community getting their first shot at a job. We do not like the thin style here though?? Not sure why so much.“

“We called to placed an order for pickup and spoke with Coy. The customer service Coy provides is above and beyond the best I've had in a long time. We were greated by Yami and she too was pleasant and positive to work with. It's been a long time since we have eaten a Caroli from Romas but we will be back for more. Our Caroli reminded me from the 90's at the Romas off of Washington, in Thornton. Thanks for the great food! Laura“

“Pizza was good,we ordered on the phone. They gave us a time. We arrived, one pizza done and the second stick to something, hole in it. Asked if we could wait for another pizza to be made. Said yes. We did wait. Didn't even offer the messed up pizza or compensate us in any way.“

“I ate at The Sand Bar last night. It's down in the basement of the main restaurant clubhouse (upstairs on the main level is their fine dining). The booths are like golf cart seats, and the ceiling is painted blue like the sky with wraparound accent lighting behind a little shelf that's recessed in the ceiling. The cheeseburger I got was a bit too dry, and the tots could've been sprinkled with seasoning. The Key Lime Pie was good but very sweet. The standout for me was the chicken taco! They put about as much chicken and cheese as would fit in it. I certainly feel like I got my money's worth. It tasted delicious. After the dry burger, the chicken was nicely seasoned and dripping with juice.
The sink in the men's room was broken, meaning they needed to reattach the faucet to the granite sink. Water still came out and I could wash my hands. They said someone else also let them know and that they'd put in a work order to get it fixed.
But the most unpleasant thing about the whole meal last night was the obnoxiously loud guy sitting at the bar dropping frequent f-bombs. Looking over at another family table of 4, they seemed to be a bit uncomfortable and glaring over at him. Look, I get it. People get loud, rowdy, and drunk at a bar. I'm not a member here, but I have worked at a few country clubs. Stuff like that might happen out on the golf course, but never in the restaurant in front of children and more elderly members. At the very least, I don't think it unreasonable for one of the bartenders or managers to have asked the guy to speak a little quieter so that the whole restaurant didn't have to hear his many conversation topics and vulgar language.“

“Jessica Saint is always a pleasure to see whenever we order papa John’s.. I know that if she is working I will get my pizza or whatever I order fast and it will be hot and fresh.. I hope EVERYONE who orders from this papa John’s gets to meet this amazing girl she’s so nice and friendly!!“

“Really impressed with the menu here! They’ve got a little bit of everything pizzas, sandwiches, wings, and even desserts. I like that you can build your own pizza and choose from a bunch of toppings. Prices are reasonable, and the lunch deals make it even better. Definitely a place I’d come back to!“

“This location has had good customer service and good service for many years. They normally have random basic pizza ready, in case you don't like to wait. They recently have new owners, I have not noticed any changes in service, but I will keep you posted.“

“Got home after working a 14 hr day, I was starving an hangry! Tried to go to my usually place Pizza Hut(I know sorry for saying it on here) buttttttttt they were closed an it was 1030. Not happy, said heck with it I’ll order dominos. Placed order at 10:42 an at 11:05 it was at my door!!� honestly it was the best pizza I’ve had in a minute. I’ll deff be switching my business to this location. Friendly driver, very polite an the pizza was � Thanks guys“

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Great customer service and genuinely helpful staff. I accidentally ordered from the wrong location, and a gentleman went out of his way to help—he gave me the correct address and even called the other store so I didn’t have to. I was having a rough day, and even though he couldn’t have known that, his kindness and patience made a real difference. I Wish I got his name, but thank you! You deserve more than a good review 👏
You have exceptional staff who remain respectful even when mistakes happen. Their kindness genuinely makes a difference, and it shows in how they treat customers. I appreciate good people—it’s not always easy to find—so credit where it’s due.🙏👏“

“Got home after working a 14 hr day, I was starving an hangry! Tried to go to my usually place Pizza Hut(I know sorry for saying it on here) buttttttttt they were closed an it was 1030. Not happy, said heck with it I’ll order dominos. Placed order at 10:42 an at 11:05 it was at my door!!� honestly it was the best pizza I’ve had in a minute. I’ll deff be switching my business to this location. Friendly driver, very polite an the pizza was � Thanks guys“

“Cheesus crust! Best pizza any gal could ever devour!“

“For those who drive by or order delivery from this Pizza Hut, you probably should stop in. They remodeled the interior a few years ago, and frankly it is a lot nicer than before. I like to order carry-out as they have a GREAT deal if you order online. We eat pizza from a number of places around Windsor, but I'll say that since I found that deal we 'gravitate' to 'the HUT'. The staff is consistently nice and talks with me as I pay for my order...though I will say I have not been in our Pizza Hut when it is crowded and loud since like 2015. Makes for a comfortable experience enjoying a Pizza in my opinion.“

“This is my go to location for pizza. It's always a 5 star experience. I must give special thanks to one particular employee here I do believe his name is Eric. What an amazing individual who is very respectful and a pleasure to see when walking in. Knowledgeable about the menu items and helpful when ordering and making sure I get the best deal with a great price. Thank you Eric. You are a great individual and I give you 5 stars.“