Firefly Pizzeria
TEMPORARILY CLOSED$ •
About Firefly Pizzeria
Firefly Pizzeria Reviews
Traditional Italian style wood fired pizza in Grand Lake, Colorado! We loved the Firefly special, the Margarita, the Carnivore, and the Funghi pizzas we ordered. The gelato was also authentic and a refreshing treat for dessert! Owner Mark Consiglio makes the dough fresh in house and his lovely wife and children work in the restaurant! This is a truly special place-don’t miss out on your next trip to Grand Lake!!
Between the fresh ingredients and the crust, this pizza is simply amazing. Hands down the best pizza I've ever had. Seating area is nice and clean as well.
We lived in Italy for three years and we’ve never found pizza in the US as good as Italy…until now!! Best we’ve ever experienced outside of Naples and the Amalfi Coast. The crust, the sauce, the ingredients—amazing!! Welcome to Grand Lake! So glad you’re here!!!
Menu
Firefly Pizzeria is a cozy restaurant known for its delicious pizza, including a highly-rated gluten-free option. The menu features a variety of specialty pizzas, with the wood-fired cooking method adding to their excellent taste. The crust is often praised for being crispy and tender, and the toppings are balanced, flavorful, and thoughtfully chosen. Visitors have enjoyed the margarita and Firefly pizza, finding them very delicious. The pizza is praised for its tasty and balanced flavor, with some mentioning that the crust is one of the best they have ever had, and the toppings do not overwhelm the crust. The restaurant offers good-sized portions, perfect for a hungry couple after activities like kayaking on Shadow Mountain. Service is quick and attentive, even during busy times when the place is full. Customers appreciate the friendly staff and the option to bring dogs on the patio, with some friendly locals holding dogs on leashes while orders are placed. The restaurant's location near a lake makes it an ideal spot for picnic provisions or a post-meal stroll. The menu also includes a Caesar salad, often requested with extra dressing. The overall atmosphere is cozy and charming, though some guests suggest improved signage for the bathroom. The pizza can be spicy if Calabrian chiles are used, so those sensitive to spice might want to choose milder options next time. Overall, Firefly Pizzeria offers quality food and a fun atmosphere, making it a highly recommended dining destination.