6 Best Bakeries near Greeley

“Greeley Crumbl's cookies are massive and delicious, perfect for sharing! The rotating menu keeps things interesting, but they can be a bit pricey. Still worth it! The service is quick and friendly. while the store is inviting and clean.“

“We regularly use The Bakery in Greeley for listing neighbor gifts, and they never miss. Their cake drops are absolutely delicious — people always rave about them and ask where they came from.

Kat is a dream to work with. Communication is clear, timely, and easy, which makes the entire process seamless from start to finish. As a small business owner, that level of reliability matters so much.

If you’re looking for a local Greeley bakery that delivers incredible treats and even better service, I can’t recommend The Bakery enough. We’re proud to support them and share their work with our clients and community.“

“Eileen's Colossal Cookies- Greeley, CO Is under new ownership.They are also now shipping cookie orders! This place is so awesome! They know how much these cookies/business means to me, they reached out and are sending a dozen cookies for my upcoming birthday. This warmed my heart.. Fun story about this particular Eileen's Colossal Cookies - Greeley Co, Eileen’s has helped carry on a tradition in my family and warmed my heart beyond belief. I grew up in Hastings Ne, and would rob my mom’s change and ride my bike all the way downtown as fast as I could to snag a cookie from Eileen’s before my mom noticed I wasn’t in hearing distance. Much later in life, my daughter turned 10, and I wanted her birthday to be extra special; because she was turning double digits! I moved away from Hastings many years ago. The closest Eileen’s was 2+ hrs away. I called all around to different Eileen’s and no one would ship, they didn’t offer it back then. Then I got to Greeley’s Eileen’s and took a deep breath, picked up the phone, and asked them if they could please ship me my daughter’s first cookie for her 10th birthday. They really didn’t care to, but they said they would try. Well, it made it!! She fell in love!! It’s a thing now. She is now 19 and still has to have Eileen’s when ever she is near one. She even passed it on to the other side of her family. I’m so glad that they offer shipping now! Under this new ownership, the same love for their customers has continued. Greely Co Eileen’s realized how much this store and cookies mean to me and are sending me a dozen cookies. I know they know how much I love these cookies. But, I also think they know it’s not just about the cookie, but the frosting, the experience, and well…my childhood. Now on to my daughter to pass the love of these cookies to the next generation.. Thank you Greely Eileen’s, you have touched my heart. I look forward to ordering many cookies from you 🥰 holidays and birthdays are right around the corner 🤗“

“Great and fresh food. nice people. clean establishment. good prices.“

“That was an outstanding snickerdoodle! Aside from wanting a protein rich snack- it is a phenomenal cookie to boot. Folks, you have got to try these, I bought mine at Double Diamond CrossFit / Foundations Nutrition. Support & Shop local!“