16 Best Italian Restaurants in Pueblo

“My Wife and I went for our 30th Wedding Anniversary. Brittney was our server. She did an amazing job! Made excellent recommendations that help make it a wonderful experience! When she found out it was our Anniversary, she made the meal very special! The food was truly amazing, the whole staff did a great job! And the prices were more than fair! Will definitely be back!“

“Best food we have ordered only 2 entrees they are more than sufficient for 4 adults and 1kid and they will give free salads soups and bread sticks which are unlimited and they will provide first before food arrives and you might be pretty 30-40% full with them. Over all a good place to eat and which is best Italian food.“

“Pass keys it the heart of Pueblo. I heard for many years how great it was. Last year tried it the first time and man was it amazing. So amazing every time we leave the lake it’s a must have. 2 locations both great food. Last two weeks March 29th and April 4th 2025 we visited again. Thank you for serving great food and having great respect for your customers and the hospitality is on point. Till next time. Honestly once you’ve tried it you can’t even think on the place or you’ll be wanting it.“

“The Pueblo Riverwalk is pristine & beautiful ….. when I walk it in the early morning about 8 am….. many of all ages are out walking, and there is a man out cleaning ….. the place is gorgeous ‼️ No trash, even the duck poo gets picked up. It is such a clean and safe place to walk.“

“Booking Pasta Cottage to cater our wedding was one of the best decisions we made! The food was absolutely incredible, fresh, flavorful, and loved by all of our guests! Everything was ready right on time for dinner service, and we did not have to worry about a thing. Tammi and her team were not only professional and efficient but also incredibly warm and easy to work with. We are so grateful for the outstanding experience they provided on our special day!“

“Absolutely fabulous all around. Friendly service from folks that like being there. Food that is superb and comforting. Great atmosphere if you wanna grab a booth or they’ll well pack it if you wanna take it and bounce. I’ve tried every part of the menu and it’s all amazing. Wanna a surprise slap in the kisser: try the spaghetti sauce.“

“Great variety on the menu. Breakfast lunch happy hour it is a treat to go there!“

“Great value, large portions, fast service. They literally have the best spaghetti and meatballs I have ever had... Not to mention the freshly baked roll that comes with! I've never had a reason not to come back.

Thank you, Collette's Catering!“

“Best pizza in Pueblo, by far! Plus amazing customer service!“

“Family friendly restaurant with quick and friendly server. The food is delicious! Any time we go to the Musso farmers market, we stop by the restaurant for an Italian sandwich. Highly recommend this restaurant.“

“Got to Gus' Place an hour early, tuff to gauge it just right when you drive 11+ hrs to get here?! History is made right here...thanks Pueblo & Gus' Place!“

“just ordered a door dash order through them. made it a meal for an extra 5$ and all I got was a drink did not not receive my pizza. rip off to get food here“

“Excellent!! Best pizza and great atmosphere. We’ll be back for sure!“

“My husband and I stopped in for lunch and it was amazing the customer service was great and extremely child friendly would definitely recommend this place and will be returning“

“If I could give more than five stars, I absolutely would! Toni and Joe’s Pizzeria is hands down one of the most fun and welcoming spots we’ve visited in a long time. From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with a warm smile and top-tier service. Every staff member we interacted with was friendly, quick, and genuinely seemed to enjoy making our visit the best it could be.

Let’s talk drinks—because wow! The drink selection here is seriously impressive. Whether you're into craft beers, signature cocktails, or a perfect glass of wine, they've got you covered. The bartender was not only knowledgeable but also incredibly attentive. My drink was mixed to perfection, and the flavors were balanced in a way that showed real skill behind the bar.

The arcade was a blast! It's not just an afterthought like in some places—this one is fully decked out and packed with both classic favorites and newer games that kept us entertained for hours. It was such a fun, nostalgic touch that added a whole other layer of excitement to our night out.

And here's the cherry on top: we heard that Toni and Joe's is about to unveil a huge new landscaping project with artificial turf coming next week! We’re so excited for this addition because it sounds like it’s going to turn the outdoor area into an even more fun and inviting space. I can already imagine hanging out there with friends, enjoying our drinks, playing games, and soaking in the vibes. It’s going to bring a ton of extra fun and make this place even more of a must-visit destination.

All in all, Toni and Joe’s is more than just a pizzeria—it’s a full experience. Amazing service, unbeatable drinks, an epic arcade, and exciting new developments on the way. We’ll definitely be back—again and again after our boat days with family! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Me and my husband went to grab some lunch. We both were wanting different things to eat, so we came to mauro’s since they offer something for everyone. They have American and Mexican food. From pastas, pizza, to tacos and enchiladas. Literally many options. I got the enchiladas tejanas with chorizo. It also came with beans and potatoes. I was so hungry I cleaned up all my plate and forgot to snap a picture. I wish I would have because not only was it all delicious, it was very appealing to the eye. Nice big portion size as well. Customer service was also great. Very friendly and clean atmosphere.“