Michel Angelo's Pizzeria Restaurant & Lounge

256 Main St, New Hartford
(860) 738-8585

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Robert Henige

Ruben was great, very good service. Would stop again.

Diane West

Girl on the phone was extremely rude. Decided not to order takeout because she was so rude.

Helene Murphy

Kai, our server, was amazing. The restaurant is amazing. Food was so good, prices reasonable and the food was served hot and presented with flare.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

John B

I may have reviewed them before. Until this visit they got a 4 out of 5. This visit, a 2.
Let's start with the loaded nachos - In the past it was represented (and believed) that they made the nachos fresh, each time. The lead time for them was such that we would pre-order them before arriving. The nachos were big, and indeed loaded. Peppers, onions, salsa, cheese, + meats if you want. This time was VERY different and disappointing. What we got was the bottom of a purchased bag of nachos. There was not a single whole nacho. Just a bunch of broken and crumbles, even some dust. The cheese was VERY salty and seemed like cheese-wiz. I would have returned them immediately after trying them but my wife did not want to make a scene. Very disappointing after having them a half-dozen times previously.
On to the calzone $$ - Flavor was good. Got some cartilage in the sausage. Otherwise it was okay. Nothing to write home about.
My wife had a Scallop & shrimp dish $$$$ - She said it was as good as ever.
Service was great.
Atmosphere was okay for a pizza joint.
Too bad they have changed the loaded nachos. That killed it.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 5

Damian Senerchia

First and last time eating at this place, got what was suppose to be their version of a Sicilian .. Didn’t realize I was getting a Cumberland farms pizza, it even tastes like Cumberland farms pizza ..

Food: 1

B M

The BEST food around

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jay Whitman

Lived in the area for years but never stopped in until today , got pizza and well everything was fantastic. Look forward to trying some other things from the menu soon

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Peter Cowles

Great pizza and great staff!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Damianos Black

Great trivia night on tuesday

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Amity A

I ordered online pretty late at night. The app canceled it without my knowledge. So I drove there and they still made it for me 😁 the food was INCREDIBLE! Thanks again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Benjamin Chapman

This was the best god damn pizza I have ever had in my life. 5 stars highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Paula Robins

Relaxed atmosphere, delicious Italian food, the cheesecake is a must have!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sasha Keys

Ordered the buffalo wings and they tasted old and almost like a chemical. My husband ate them and he got sick. I also got the Polo el Diablo and it was a watery mess it’s almost like they put water in the pasta and not sauce! This food was disgusting I will never order again.

Food: 1

Jennifer Washburn

Oh my God so good!
Got the brashetta and a cheeseburger grinder, the later the best ever, and the first up there with the best!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jennifer Secor

I will never ever order from Michel Angelo’s again!! We ordered 2 grinders tonight and buffalo chips and My buffalo chips were burnt .. probably from old oil ! And my steak & cheese grinder was also burnt !! I ordered through Slice and they tried to help but the Manager of this nasty place wouldn’t do anything without pictures ! Sorry we ate what we could and the rest went to the trash ! 🀬🀬

Loading...

Michel Angelo's Pizzeria Restaurant & Lounge

256 Main St, New Hartford, CT 06057
(860) 738-8585