Brother Jimmy's BBQ

Barbeque, Sports Bar, American

196 Crown St, New Haven
(203) 823-9780


Tripadvisor Tripadvisor: 3.5
Google Google: 3.7
Yelp Yelp: 2.5
Facebook Facebook: 4.1
Foursquare Foursquare: 6.5


Reviews for Brother Jimmy's BBQ

Bob Ipp

Great service but mediocre food. First, the main dinner rib portIon was ridiculously small and expensive. Portion was equal to about a quarter rack for the same ($21) price one would expect for a full rack. No where was the portion noted. Supposed to be famous for barbecue but the ribs didn’t even appear to be barbecued and the dry rub was flavorless.

David N.
Let me drop this a few times, The Brisket was awesome! So, walking in at 1 on a Sunday afternoon me and my buddy were not sure they were even open. ZERO people inside. It was a hot humid day outside and there was ZERO relief inside from a struggling AC system. We opted to sit at the bar hoping for the Yankees game. TV's were all off and when the bartender tried to turn them on, we found out why. I guess corporate pays the cable bills and they forgot to pay. So no full review
Helen Garcia
We tried this restaurant for the first time this week. The food was horrible from start to finish. The “humongous nachos” were in a small skillet and had almost no cheese on them at all, it was essentially dried out bbq chicken dumped on some chips for $16. The BBQ sandwiches were dry and flavorless. The fries were so greasy they were practically inedible. The one menu item that actually had flavor and wasn’t disgusting was the side of mashed potatoes. We were one of full review

More Reviews(70)


Monday 11:30 am - 1:00 am
Tuesday 11:30 am - 1:00 am
Wednesday 11:30 am - 1:00 am
Thursday 11:30 am - 1:00 am
Friday 11:30 am - 2:00 am
Saturday 11:00 am - 2:00 am
Sunday 11:00 am - 1:00 am


#Lunch | #Starters | #Salads | #Bbq Sandwiches | #Sandwiches & Burgers | #Bbq Platters | #Family Style


Pulled Pork Wrap$10.5
Pulled pork, pickles & slaw.
Pulled Chicken Wrap$9.5
Pulled chicken, bacon & cheddar.
Brother Jimmy's Cuban$11
Sliced pork, ham, Swiss cheese, frickles & Dijon garlic butter.
Applewood bacon, lettuce & our fried green tomato w/ mayo.
Smoked Turkey Wrap$10
House smoked Turkey w avocado, tomato, lettuce & honey mustard.
BJ's Sliders$10
2 per order. Choice of: cheeseburger, buffalo chicken, pulled pork, pulled chicken, brisket, or fried green tomato w/ pimento cheese.
BBQ Lunch Special$14.95
Choice of: ribs, pulled pork, 1/4 BBQ chicken or pulled chicken. Plus choose from: house salad or cornbread. Served w/ your choice of one side dish & pickles.


Hush Puppies$8.5
View Entire Menu