Insomnia Cookies

240-242 College St, New Haven
(203) 763-4949

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Box of 6 Cookies Chocolate Chunk Cookie Double Chocolate Mint White Chocolate Macadamia
Chocolate Chip and Chocolate Cookie Sandwich
Insomnia Chocolate Cookie Butter
Triple Chocolate Chunk Cookies
Mint Chocolate Chip
Vegan Birthday Cake
Ice Cream Sandwich
Cookie Selection
Oatmeal Raisin
Salted Caramel

Menu

Classic Cookies
Chocolate Chunk
A rich, buttery vanilla cookie amped up with loads of ooey-gooey milk chocolate chunks.
Classic with M&M'S®
This colorful, candy-coated twist on our Classic cookie is packed with M&M'S® goodness.
Double Chocolate Chunk
Our dark chocolate cookie is taken to its drool-worthy peak with chunks of smooth, melty milk chocolate.
Double Chocolate Mint
Our take on a favorite flavor combo. A warm dark chocolate cookie with mint chips and chunks of milk chocolate.
Oatmeal Raisin
A treat that's like a hug for the soul. Warm cinnamon and sweet molasses layered with plenty of oatmeal and raisins.
Peanut Butter Chip
A total peanut butter stunner. Our soft, sweet peanut butter cookie filled with creamy peanut butter chips.
Snickerdoodle
Stick to a classic with our Snickerdoodle. A delightfully buttery base covered in cinnamon sugar goodness.
Sugar
Simply the best. A melt-in-your-mouth, buttery cookie with hints of vanilla.
White Chocolate Macadamia
This snack operates on island time. A coconut-y cookie with bits of macadamia nut and creamy white chocolate chips.
Vegan Birthday Cake
Sweet vanilla and all of the sprinkles make this an extra special vegan treat for an extra special day. For full information, click on Nutritional info below.
Vegan Chocolate Chunk
A vegan cookie that warms your soul with generous amounts of rich, buttery flavor and ooey-gooey (dairy-free) chocolate chunks. For full information, click on Nutritional info below.
Vegan Double Chocolate Chunk
A vegan spin on our Classic Double Chocolate cookie with the same levels of dark chocolate decadence and melty (dairy-free) chocolate chunks. For full information, click on Nutritional info below.
Gluten Free Chocolate Chip
A vegan and gluten-free spin on a classic Chocolate Chip cookie. While made without animal byproducts or ingredients containing gluten, Insomniacs with serious dietary restrictions should always play it safe. All products are prepped in the same facility, so exposure to common food allergens, while limited, is possible.

Deluxe Cookies
Confetti
A tricked-out sugar cookie filled with rainbow sprinkles and vanilla-flavored chips.
Oatmeal Chocolate Walnut
A warm, doubled-up oatmeal treat filled with chunks of walnut and milk chocolate.
Salted Caramel
Indulgent, sweet caramel and savory sea salt baked into a Deluxe-sized sugar cookie base. Please note this cookie contains toffee, which contains almonds.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup
This Deluxe treat is loaded with chunks of Reese's® peanut butter cups baked into a rich peanut butter cookie.
S'mores
A warm, decadent chocolate cookie packed with toasty marshmallow, crunchy graham cracker, and chocolate chunks.
Triple Chocolate
A super-sized, buttery cookie with a triple serving of ooey-gooey chocolate chunks.

Brownies
Chocolate Chip Brownie
Extra fudgy, ultra-rich brownie packed with milk chocolate chips. Baked to perfection and bound to make you say, "Mmm."
Chocolate Chunk Brookie
Half brownie. Half cookie. A total snack.
Chocolate Chunk Blondie
The rumors are true...Blondies have more fun. Our iconic chocolate chunk cookie recipe has been tinkered, resulting in the most irresistible treat known to mouth.
Loaded Brownie
Choose a Chocolate Chunk Brownie, Blondie, or Brookie base, topped with cream cheese or buttercream frosting, and garnished with your favorite toppings.

Boxes
6-pack
Sit back and relax with a 6-pack of your Classic cookie faves.
12-pack
Our most popular pack. Choose your own flavors to make it yours. Dig into a dozen of your warm Classic favorites, in bakeries or delivered til really really late.
Deluxe 4-pack
A 4-pack of your warm Deluxe favorites. Choose from: Deluxe cookies, Brownies, Blondies, or Brookies. Availability varies by bakery location.
Deluxe 6-pack
6 Deluxe cookies, Brownies, Blondies, or Brookies. Bake your own 6-pack of your warm Deluxe favorites. *jk - we'll do the baking, you just choose your faves!
Super 6
Five Classic cookies, plus your choice between one Deluxe cookie, Brownie, Blondie, or Brookie. The combinations are endless (and tasty).
4+4-pack
The perfect pack does exist. 4 Classics and 4 Deluxe.
Mini 12-pack
A 12-pack of Minis serving lots of Chocolate Chunks in small, snack-able bites.
Mini 24-pack
A 24-pack of Minis serving lots of Chocolate Chunks in small, snack-able bites.
Vegan 6-pack
Pick your perfect 6-pack from our warm, delicious vegan varieties. Choose from Vegan Chocolate Chunk, Vegan Double Chocolate Chunk and Vegan Birthday Cake. Made without animal products or by-products!
Gluten Free 6-pack
6 Vegan Gluten-Free Chocolate Chip cookies. *While made without animal byproducts or ingredients containing gluten, Insomniacs with serious dietary restrictions should always play it safe. All products are prepped in the same facility, so exposure to common food allergens, while limited, is possible.

Ice Cream
Ice Cream in a Cup
2 scoops of refreshing ice cream for delivery or pickup. (Goes great with a 6-pack of warm cookies.)
Ice Cream on a Classic Cookie
2 scoops of ice cream on a warm Classic cookie
Ice Cream on a Deluxe Cookie
2 scoops of ice cream on a warm Deluxe cookie (double the size of our Classic cookie)
Ice Cream on a Brownie
2 scoops of ice cream on a warm Chocolate Chip Brownie. Choose up to 3 ice cream flavors.
Pint
A pint of frosty ice cream in your choice of Insomnia ice cream flavor.

Wiches
Cookie'wich
Two scoops of cold ice cream sandwiched between two warm Classic cookies. Note: Cookie'wiches are delivered unassembled.
Deluxe Cookie'wich
Three scoops of your favorite ice cream between two warm Deluxe cookies. Note: Cookie'wiches are delivered unassembled.
Big'wich
Two warm Classic cookies with a luscious icing center.
Deluxe Big'wich
Rich, creamy icing sandwiched between two warm Deluxe cookies.

Combos & Packs
Big Dipper
4 of our Classic cookies made for spreading in our decadent buttercream or cream cheese icing.
Lil' Dipper
12 of our Mini Chocolate Chunk cookies made for dunking in our decadent buttercream or cream cheese icing.
Delicious Duo
Two warm Classic cookies and an ice-cold beverage.
Deluxe Delicious Duo
Do it up with our Deluxe Combo: two warm Deluxe cookies and an ice-cold beverage.
Chillax Pack
Pack includes one pint of ice cream and a 6-pack of warm Classic cookies.
Chillax Deluxe Pack
Chill out with your choice of 6 Deluxe cookies and a 2 pints of ice cream.
ChillaxXL Pack
2 pints of ice cream and a 12-pack of our warm Classic cookies.

Sides
Buttercream Icing Side
The ultimate indulgent icing option that goes with literally everything.
Cream Cheese Icing Side
This delightfully tangy and rich icing adds an extra touch of decadence to any dessert.

Drinks
Whole Milk
Looking for whole milk and nothing but the milk? We've got you covered with an icy-cold bottle of whole milk.
Chocolate Milk
Choco-licious. Definition: Make the cookies go loco.
Strawberry Milk
Berry good with cookies.
Oatly
Plant-based babes, we would NEVER forget about you.
Oatly Chocolate Milk
Dairy? Zero. Chocolate? Chock full of it.
DASANI® Water
Here's your sign to drink more water.
Coca-Cola ®️
Classic. What else can we say?
Coca-Cola Zero Sugar ®️
Zero calories. Zero sugar. Zero problems.
Diet Coke ®️ 
This carbonated queen needs no intro.
Powerade ®️
Berry-licious & jam packed with electrolytes.
Sprite ®️
Lemon. Lime. Super fun time.
Monster Energy ®️
AKA stay up late juice. Contains caffeine, ginseng, and B vitamins.
La Colombe Cold Brew
You'll love it a latte. Contains caffeine.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: ubereats
+57 photos
Photo credit: grubhub
+56 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Tina S. and I’m convinced the S stands for Star. She really made my insomnia cookies order experience that much sweeter (pun intended) came for cookies left with great convo. One thing I noticed about Aina if she has ability to manage and maneuver a large customer base her personality is fun and exciting she is professional courteous kind she’s very informative and I feel like she genuinely cares about the people she interacts with I am a very new customer and have only been...
September 2024
Loove these cookies! Always warm and fresh out of the oven, with the option to pair with their ice cream.

I recently went there to get a birthday cookie cake for my brother and it was perfect. It was a generous size and had the option to choose three different cookie types. We got the m&m, classic chocolate chip, and double chocolate chunk. It comes with a standard happy birthday image printed on top, but they have other messages you could get printed as...
September 2024
Very nice place. I like how small it is, and their selection of cookies. My first time here and it was very good. Very nice service as well and a very nice atmosphere. Definitely will come back again.
September 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Villa Lulu - 230 College St
Italian
South Bay Mediterranean Kitchen - 228 College St
Mediterranean, Seafood, American, New American
The Luke Brasserie - 261 College St
Brasseries, Cafe, Bar, French, Modern European

Insomnia Cookies

240-242 College St, New Haven, CT 06510
(203) 763-4949