Poindexter Coffee
1151 Chapel St, New Haven
(475) 207-7070
Menu
Photos
+14 photos
+13 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Stopped by here today for the second time ever around 2:30pm (on a Friday). I walk up to the counter and the young barista looks at me like I have two heads saying, “um we’re closed,” But the closing time is 3:30pm. Just a weird experience overall. Been here one other time and it was great. The inside is so beautiful but I was brining a visitor from out of state to check it out and this experience just left a bad impression.
This place is such a charmer that I want it to be a go to coffee shop.
I need to eat before I have coffee and this place often has a very limited selection of what looks like days old pastries. I often need a coffee shop to eat and have coffee while i wait for my daughter 1-2 hours. This place is beautiful but lacks the food aspect. The hours are also a little short making it hard to drop in outside of the morning.
If they had better hours...
I need to eat before I have coffee and this place often has a very limited selection of what looks like days old pastries. I often need a coffee shop to eat and have coffee while i wait for my daughter 1-2 hours. This place is beautiful but lacks the food aspect. The hours are also a little short making it hard to drop in outside of the morning.
If they had better hours...
Vegetarian options: Great atmosphere and decor behind the Graduate Hotel Lobby. They nailed 1920s Yale/New Haven. Great Gatsby-ish. Large wood-paneled cozy backroom library for studying w/ coffee. Excellent chai latte, croissants, and quick oatmeal
You May Also Like
Old Heidelberg - 1151 Chapel St
![]()
Bar, Pretzels, Beer Bar, Cocktail Bar
Anaya Sushi & Ramen - 1150 Chapel St
![]()
Sushi, Sushi Bar, Ramen, Vegan