Poindexter Coffee
1151 Chapel St, New Haven
(475) 207-7070
Menu
Photos
+14 photos
+13 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Tucked in the back of the beautiful Graduate Hotel, Poindexter Coffee has become my go-to spot. The lobby’s cool furniture and big communal tables make it feel stylish but relaxed, and the space itself is great, high ceilings, tons of natural light, and plenty of room to spread out. The coffee is consistent. The staff is genuinely kind, especially to pets; my dog is always welcomed with smiles and a treat. Between the pet-friendly vibe (hotel included), friendly service, and...
Nice place to sit. I bought a coffee and just threw it out. But coffee is mediocre. Seems as though all the coffee in New Haven is mediocre, though. Surprising given the proximity to a reputable university. I'm trying not to generalize to broadly but, I guess, failing.
This is a more silent focused cafe in a hotel, the vibe is vintage and I would say “manly”. This is a great place to do work, there’s a decent amount of seating that gets wildly occupied during school (Yale) season— be mindful of this if you are going here. There is a room with a curtain and a couple booths, providing a private place to do work. The drink options here flavor wise are somewhat limited but they do have seasonal drinks which is nice. I have never tried their...
You May Also Like
Three Sons Pizza - 1151 Chapel St
![]()
Pizza, Pop-up Shops, Bar
Old Heidelberg - 1151 Chapel St
![]()
Bar, Pretzels, Beer Bar, Cocktail Bar
Tandoor New Haven - 1226 Chapel St
![]()
Indian, Vegetarian