Elm Hill Pizza
$ • Pizza, Italian, Gluten-FreeAbout Elm Hill Pizza
Customers' Favorites
2 Items Medium with Chicken
Medium Pizza Half Meatball
Elm Hill Special Pizza
Small Vegetable Pizza
Elm Hill Special
Kielbasa Grinder
Hawaiian Special
Pepperoni Pizza
Eggplant Grinder
Pepperoni Half
Elm Hill Pizza Reviews
223 ratings
Share your opinion about Elm Hill Pizza
Elm Hill Pizza is the best!! I grew up in Newington and now live in Texas. I’ve never found pizza that even comes close to their quality and every Connecticut visit includes Elm Hill Pizza.
Everything they make is amazing. we order all our pizzas and grinders from them on take out nights. So I didn't even have to question who I was going to order from and had sheet pizzas for my daughters graduation party like always they were amazing and a big hit. thank you.. I highly recommend you
Love this place, been going here for over 25 years. Always stop by when I am in town, puts my local NYC shops to shame
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 9PM |
Elm Hill Pizza has been a beloved spot in Newington for many years, known for serving high-quality food with fresh salads and perfect dressings. The restaurant offers enormous calzones and truly amazing pizza, with grinders that are large and well-made, along with well-done chicken tenders and fries. While grilled chicken can sometimes be overcooked, the overall quality of the food remains very good. The restaurant is small and perfect for takeout, making it a convenient choice for many customers. The staff is friendly and attentive, remembering regular customers and caring about the community. This family-owned place has a long history, with customers growing up eating there and still enjoying the same great flavors today. Popular menu items include pepperoni and buffalo chicken pizza, with the latter praised for its great buffalo flavor and breaded chicken. The restaurant offers customizable vegetarian options and plenty of surrounding parking, making it very kid-friendly as well. Elm Hill Pizza continues to be a favorite for locals and visitors alike, offering a classic experience in Newington. Recently, customers have praised the freshness and flavor of the Hawaiian pizza, the homemade blue cheese dressing on the chef salad, and the warm, welcoming atmosphere. The staff’s kindness and understanding, especially during difficult times, have made it a special place for the community, with the pizza always being delicious.