New South Yummys - Southern Kitchen and BBQ

551 Main St, West Haven
(475) 434-0676

Recent Reviews

Sort by
James McKernon

I called in a take out yesterday for my brother and I. He wanted the Patty Melt sandwich and I wanted the Jumbo Brisket sandwich. Also some of your “Fresh hand squeezed Lemonade”. Four glasses since you didn’t have caps for the 1/2 gallon bottles which is what I wanted. (This is what I was told.?)He enjoyed the Patty Melt but my Brisket sandwich was lacking. More like stark. It was a slab of brisket on a roll (with a side of your sauce).Now I realize that there was no description of it on the menu but the assumption was that it would be like any of the other sandwiches which came with things like lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, or any combination of the like. Appearing not at all as appetizing as anything in your photo gallery. For $10.00.And your Freshly Hand Squeezed Lemonade could have come off any shelf of any grocery store. Nothing special about it at all.Now I don't mind paying a little extra for an enjoyable meal but $32.xx for that just did not sit right with me.

angelina schnaufer

I spent $38.60 on dinner here and let me tell you I'm tempted to bring all my food back and ask for my money back.. because I do still have almost every piece of food still. I ordered meatloaf and mashed potatoes and the gravy on both of them... It tasted like ground up slim Jim and water mixed together. It was barely edible tbh. I took one bite of my meatloaf and almost couldn't swallow it...it was that bad. My boyfriend got the fried chicken and mashed potatoes and a side of french fries which was misunderstood as a substitution. But that's not a big deal at all if the food was even okay at the very least. His stomach hurt himreally bad all night. Even called out of work the stomach was so bad. Eat at your own risk look I had high hopes for this restaurant I begged my boyfriend daily to bring me there!! Please fix you're restaurant. It could be really amazing!!

Joseph Poczciwinski

Good bbq at a decent price. My wife and I have had takeout there over half a dozen times are so. Our takeout serving size was good too. Surprised that there aren't more folks waiting in line to get some great smoky southern food.

Dave Britto

Amazing southern food.

NaniAholic

Not going to lie. I was hesitant about this place because of how it looked outside. But let me tell you.....omg the food was phenomenal. The friendly man at the counter was very welcoming and it was very clean and big inside. This was a cute little gem near home.

J&R FastTransport

Great food, nice old man in the front. Very clean ans comfortable place to eat.

Devon Greenleaf

We ordered for a party we had this weekend and the food was delicious. I highly recommend the ribs and chicken tenders. Plus their customer service was outstanding.

George Whetstine

Good eats and very affordable. Get the Ribs for dure

Andrew Teshoney

Their meatloaf is incredible - biscuits the size of my kids head, and whatever I order never disappoints

Eric Frieson

Everything was disgusting!

Stephanie Cabral

Friendly, clean and great comfort food!

Teresa Rivas

Amazing food, huge portions and great staff. Love their hospitality!!! Please show this local business some love and support!! We need good mom & pop places like this around!

Michele Mueller

Food is phenomenal.... Everything is fresh made... And delicious... But those taters

nora lewis

Don’t let the location or size of this place fool you! This was some of the best BBQ I’ve ever had, bar none! Everything we’ve had has been outstanding! Huge portions, freshly made!I can’t say enough good things about the food and I’m a picky foodie! Try it, you won’t be disappointed!

Patricia Rivera

Yummy is the word..chicken is delicious..deserts are fantastic..deep fried oreo,yum and brown butter pecan pie..out of this world

Loading...

New South Yummys - Southern Kitchen and BBQ

551 Main St, West Haven, CT 06516
(475) 434-0676