8 Best Bakeries near Bethany Beach

“Had the best sandwich I've ever had in my life (Prosciutto Cotto Creamy Stracchino Mambo) here while on vacation, and the pastries were great too! They offer yesterday's pastries that didn't get sold at a good discount and we got a blueberry cinnamon roll that was amazing! The place was definitely packed but we got our orders very quickly and had a seat inside the store to devour our orders. I wish I could eat here every day!!“

“Very cute cafe, loved the cold brew.“

“LOVE this place! It is our favorite lunch place. Everything is delicious. The muffins are wonderful!“

“We’ve been getting cakes and cupcakes here for more than 30 years. Even since we’ve moved away, my son doesn’t consider his birthday complete without a cake from Rita’s. Everything is amazing and it seems like they keep coming up with new deliciousness every-time we visit.“

“I ordered cake and other sweets this past weekend! picked it up Friday for a graduation gathering that we were having at the beach when I first picked up the cake, I was worried that we would have a lot of dessert left over, but they demolished every single bit of it The cake was moist, very delicious and not too sweet. The brownies were to die for and of course, my favorite was the lemon squares and the cannolis. Will definitely be using if in the area!!!“

“They had a very nice selection of delicious pastries and the staff was very friendly. Love the carrot cake muffin but that’s not what they call it. By the time I ordered and got out of the shop there was a line forming outside.“

“Amazing food! Best dessert on the Eastern Shore! Homemade desserts made in the bakery onsite. Place your order for pickup or just stop in for mouth watering goodness. The eclairs are amazing, offering three sizes small, medium and large which is pictured. You have a new normal guest. Fast and friendly staff, very welcoming.“