New American Restaurants near Bethany Beach, DE

“Sedona is a gem in the heart of Bethany. We loved it so much that we returned for a second night! Prime rib is out of this world! Thank you Kevin and Vincent for taking such good care of us! We will definitely be back!“

“Delicious food, fabulous owners. Get an old fashioned, stay longer than you planned. It’s all worth it.“

“We had a great birthday dinner! Our server, Aidee was top notch. Managers Ricardo & Jordan were also very welcoming and informative. We love Off The Hook thus the reason I chose this restaurant for my birthday dinner. Thanks again to Aidee, Ricardo & Jordan!“

“A great place for lunch or dinner while down at the beach. Fresh, farm to table food. I recommend their bowls, salmon blt, fries, and the nachos. Sometimes they have live music. A nice, relaxing beach atmosphere and bar. Pay to park. Indoor and outdoor seating“

“Excellent food and drinks with a great atmosphere“

“The atmosphere and customer service were perfection. We highly recommend you visit this beautiful spot where the ocean and the bay meet on the East Coast at the DE State Park. Whether you’re staying in Ocean City, MD or in Delaware at Fenwick, Dewey, Bethany, or Rehoboth, it’s a must see. We hope you enjoy! 🌊💙“

“As someone who has vacationed to OC three times. We have never been to a higher end restaurant before and had no idea what to expect. The added 20 percent was a bit confusing but the food was delicious, the staff was amazing and it was a great experience for sure. I definitely didn't expect to spend what we did but it was a once in a lifetime experience for us and it was worth it for sure!“

“Sometimes there are issues with consistency, but it’s basically an irrelevant criticism because they will quickly replace and fix anything or provide that portion of a meal for free. This is our go to restaurant and we have been here probably 100 times so that should tell you everything you need to know. Oh, and they have very delicious homemade ice cream that is truly made in the restaurant. It is very creamy and delicious! 🤤“

“We dined at One Coastal over the weekend. We had four people in our party and everyone ordered a different item on the menu. Food was fantastic! I enjoyed a simple pasta dish that was the most delish meal I’ve had in years. I shared with everyone at the table and everyone loved it. My husband had the pork chop and reported that it was delicious. My daughter had the scallops and said they were perfect. Her boyfriend had the flank steak and it looked terrific. But my pasta was PERFECTION!“

“We always go to Catch 54 when at the beach. The food is amazing every single time, the service is great, and it’s just a wonderful atmosphere. I could not recommend Catch 54 enough! If there was only one restaurant that I was eating at while at the beach, it would be Catch 54!“

“Excellent breakfast sandwiches.“

“Awesome staff and yummy food!“

“Good beer and food. My wife and I went back and had lunch. We both got the fried chicken sandwich with the store made buffalo sauce and ranch. My wife got her sauce on the side. We both loved the sauce!! We asked our waitress if it was store made and yes it is. They don't bottle it, but she offered us 2 small cups for free. The waitress came back and offered a quart for 15.00, I said yes without hesitation. Thank you!! Looking forward to coming back more often.“

“Great food and a fantastic atmosphere.“

“We came on Saturday night(6/4/22) and it was very busy, but the girls working were amazing!! They were so fast and efficient and kept the line moving. I was so impressed with these two ladies and as always the ice cream was great!!!“

“We are never disappointed at Cafe Mirage!! Whether we try the daily specials or the menu staples, the food is delicious, consistent, and the portions are amazing!! You will not leave hungry or dissatisfied!! What makes this place exceptional though, is the staff and the vibe. You are going to be met with smiling faces and be treated like a local. You’d be amiss to not experience this wonderful, family friendly local spot yourself!!!“

“Where I dive into Ocean City’s finest Cioppino.“

“A must if you’re in Ocean City or in the Delmarva 🏄‍♂️“

“The Tide Room at The Shore Beach Club: A Delightful Dining Experience Last evening, we had the pleasure of dining at The Tide Room at The Shore Beach Club in Ocean City, Maryland. Our reservation was for 8:15 PM, and despite potential parking challenges, we found it surprisingly easy to find a spot. The restaurant’s recent remodel is evident as you walk up the stairs into the inviting dining area. Upon arrival, we were promptly greeted at the hostess stand and seated immediately. We appreciated the choice between indoor and outdoor seating, and the variety of seating options available, from semi-circle couches to large arrangements for bigger parties. Our server was attentive from the start, quickly providing us with water, drinks, and menus. After a brief look at the menu, we received a thorough rundown of the evening’s specials. The noise level was perfect, allowing for a pleasant conversation, and the open-air setting provided a comfortable breeze. For appetizers, we chose the crab dip and crab deviled eggs. While both were enjoyable, the crab deviled eggs stood out as the better of the two. I also tried a drink called “Lost in the South,” a refreshing blend of lemon and bourbon that became my favorite part of the evening. For the main course, I opted for the boardwalk fries with a crabcake, a dish labeled as an Eastern Shore Maryland specialty. It was served with tartar sauce and met my expectations with its classic flavors. To finish off the meal, we each selected different desserts. The restaurant’s take on the Maryland Smith Island cake, a cookies and cream version, was a delightful surprise and possibly even better than the traditional version. I highly recommend trying it if it’s available. Overall, The Tide Room offers a wonderful dining experience with excellent service, a comfortable atmosphere, and delicious food. It’s definitely worth a visit if you’re in Ocean City.“

“Best steamed shrimp in OC“

“Gorgeous Wedding Venue with panoramic views of the Ocean City Skyline and bay!“

“I was coming off the beach and wasn’t feeling well a young lady on vacation with her family stopped to help me. We got to the steps of Lennys and asked them to get me some water. The sweetest waitress helped me to the bathroom and offered to wait for me. Your guest waited at the foot of the steps and watched my belongings. I didn’t catch either of their names and other staff could have been involved I was pretty dizzy and not feeling well at all. I just want you to know how awesome your staff is and will always be thankful. I live in NC and visit my mother here every summer and will continue to visit Lennys yearly. This happened today Aug 23, 2022 3-4 pm. Thank you again to the sweetest, kindest waitress!“

“I came for dinner and ordered the fresh tuna and it was delicious, cooked perfectly. The cucumber sauce was a nice touch and the vegetables were crisp and not saturated with oils or butter. I would definitely recommend this restaurant, and I will be back.“