Bakeries near New Castle

“Cakes, cookies and sour dough are all delicious!“

“While I like most of Stoltzfus’s items, I’ve been disappointed in their chicken salad. It used to be a staple in our home but seems like they’ve changed the recipe. It’s now so runny with mayo (or whatever they use) that it plops right off our sandwiches. They’ve also seem to cut back on the celery which added a nice contrasting crunch. Please bring back the old recipe.“

“Fresh donuts and fantastic customer service. Love it!“

“Bellacakes nailed my daughter’s vision for her birthday cake. Everyone at the party commented how beautiful and delicious this confectionary masterpiece was!“

“Italian kitchen is a great one stop shop for all your catering orders. I showed up to pick up the sandwiches for our church lunch and I had put the wrong date on the order!!! They were able to accommodate me and worked like crazy to get it done. The cake I ordered was superb!!! If it had not been for the kindness of this store today, I don’t know what I would have done. The cashier, God Bless you. You went above and beyond to fix my mistake. Love you all!!!“

“I bought some cookies from Hells belles bake shop when they were at the Chase Center. They are the best cookies I have ever had. I will be using them next year for Christmas deliveries.“

“Quaker Baker are you kidding me with your deliciousness?? So far I’ve had their pizza, bagels, rolls, numerous types of pastries, Vermont crunchy bars, brookies, and even their cookie in a croissant (WOW!!). They sell coffee from a local family owned company (Rimfire roasters) that also pairs perfectly with their pastries! Very warm and friendly staff. Highly recommend stopping in!“

“From the moment we stepped inside the cute shop, we were welcomed by friendly staff who emailed me their huge list of offerings! I ended up getting a banana nut cake with peanut butter filling and whipped cream cheese icing and the cake is DELICIOUS! When I went to pick up, staff was warm and friendly and welcoming and made me feel like family. We will be coming back for sure!“

“Did the cake for my bridal shower client and it was gorgeous!!“