Bakeries near New Castle

“Cake was absolutely stunning and delicious!“

“While I like most of Stoltzfus’s items, I’ve been disappointed in their chicken salad. It used to be a staple in our home but seems like they’ve changed the recipe. It’s now so runny with mayo (or whatever they use) that it plops right off our sandwiches. They’ve also seem to cut back on the celery which added a nice contrasting crunch. Please bring back the old recipe.“

“I bought some cookies from Hells belles bake shop when they were at the Chase Center. They are the best cookies I have ever had. I will be using them next year for Christmas deliveries.“

“Bellacakes really hit it out of the park! We ordered 2 custom cakes for my twins birthday and they were perfectly designed and themed. The attention to detail exceeded our expections and included coordinating decorations, colors, and even candles! The cakes not only looked amazing, they were also so moist and delicious! Not a crumb remained. Thank you for making this birthday so special. We will definitely be ordering again!“

“Tonight my husband and I celebrated our 2nd wedding anniversary by ordering catering from Italian Kitchen. They were our wedding caterers and we absolutely loved the food! Our favorite dish from our wedding was the mushroom ravioli and we thought it would be great to have that for dinner tonight to celebrate. When I went on the website, there wasn’t mushroom ravioli on the menu so I was worried they didn’t have it anymore. I called and the staff said they’d ask their boss if they could make it and turns out they could make it for us! We got a whole tray! My husband and I were so happy and it tasted just like it tasted two years ago! So good!!! Thank you, Italian Kitchen staff and owners for making my anniversary special and delicious!!!! 💕“

“I contacted several bakeries and Cakes by Kim was immediately responsive to my email. They were able to get us a custom cake within just a few weeks for our pastor's anniversary cake. We sent an inspiration photo and they were able to bring it to life. We did delivery service and they were amazing! Not only did all our guests enjoy the cake but they enjoyed the gorgeous design of the cake. Thank you so much! The cake was so moist and the light frosting we went with - everyone kept on talking about! If you're looking for a cheap cake, this isn't the place. If you're looking for a quality cake maker who will bring your desire to life, call them today!“

“I ordered custom cookies and they came out perfect! The owner made the ordering process quick and simple. I was surprised that they tasted so great. Normally decorated cookies never taste as good as they look but these did. Everyone loved them! I’ve also stopped in multiple times to pick up items out of the case. The bakery is super cute and the staff is always friendly.“

“Nothing Bundt Cakes never disappoints! From the bundtinis to mini bundt to the bundt cakes! Always so delish and moist! You'll think you wont finish a mini bundt due to its size but I tell you ... gone in 60 seconds!!!
Employees are also always friendly!“