8 Best American Restaurants near Big Pine Key

“Fantastic food! The owners are so nice and accommodating! Thanks for the great meals!“

“variety of Merchandise,something for everyone“

“Was a cute little spot with a different flare on American island food. We brought our fresh caught lobster in to have with our breakfast and they were willing to cook them for us. Although we weren’t impressed with the way our lobster turned out, oddly squishy with a sour flavor. We will absolutely come back to enjoy other dishes on our next trip!“

“I stopped by this restaurant late at night, not expecting much more than a quick bite—but wow, was I pleasantly surprised. From the moment I walked in, the staff made me feel incredibly welcome. Even at that hour, every person I interacted with was genuinely friendly, upbeat, and attentive. The service was beyond excellent—quick, thoughtful, and with such a positive attitude that it really stood out. It’s rare to see a team so committed to creating a great experience, especially so late in the day. The atmosphere was cozy and relaxed, perfect for winding down. And while I came in hungry, I left not just full but smiling—thanks entirely to the people who clearly love what they do. If you ever find yourself nearby late at night, do yourself a favor and stop in. It’s not just the food that’ll impress you—it’s the heart behind the service.“

“This place is the best!!! We always have to make the stop when we are in town!!“

“good food fried shrimp excellent wish i was back there. bb“

“The staff, the food, the atmosphere are all outstanding. Evan and Ian are undeniably the best bartenders EVER! We spend way too much money there but it’s worth every penny! Highly recommend the donuts if you have a sweet tooth!“

“New nighttime menu if beyond fabulous. Open Thursday,Friday, Saturday until 7:30 pm“