20 Best American Restaurants in Islamorada

“The food is outstanding. The vibe and the atmosphere are both wonderful. Our waiter Ron was a fabulous server and a fun guy to spend our time with here. We will be back for everything!“

“The Tiki Bar at Three Waters Resort & Marina ended up being one of the biggest surprises of our trip. The atmosphere is exactly what you picture when you think of the Florida Keys — open-air waterfront seating, tropical drinks, palm trees, tiki decor, and a relaxed marina vibe.

What really stood out though was the food. The blackened fish sandwich was phenomenal. Perfectly seasoned with a flavorful crust, fresh toppings, and cooked spot on. Honestly much better than you’d expect from a casual tiki bar. The fries were excellent too.

Great spot to grab a drink after fishing or just relax and watch the marina activity. Easygoing, fun atmosphere with surprisingly great food. We’ll definitely be back next time we’re in Islamorada.“

“We went almost everyday! Bagels are delicious! Great to have my kids know what a real bagel is. Don’t be deterred by a long line, they go quick plus it’s fun listening to all the accents. Highly recommend the Nova with the works!“

“We were on our way back to Jax and stopped at our favorite breakfast/lunch spot! Once again a winner for all of us! Great food and great service!“

“Great local foods- we had the shrimp rice bowl and fish and chips. All very tasty. Good service. Prices were a little higher than similar restaurants. The key lime pic was fantastic, but it should be at $14 a slice. We enjoyed outdoor dining. Lots of locals come here it seems. Would definitely come back to dine here again.“

“Best Cracked Conch & Grouper Sandwich in the keys. Fabulous Service 🫶🏻🏖️ Great View! Cannot wait to check out your sister location in Key Largo - the Lazy Lobster 🫶🏻 See you again soon 🦞🦞🦞🦞“

“This place is just not a pretty face. Ok, well it is but, the food is as tasty as the sunsets are dramatic.“

“It was good but not worth the wait, they will sit you outside with infested mosquitos. The wait was ridiculous. Server hardly even checked on us. Will not visit again!“

“Amazing food and service! Beautiful crisp wedge salad with grilled shrimp, NY strip and Ribeye. All prepared to perfection. Attentive service and care. 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟“

“We loved this restaurant! Super laid back atmosphere, delicious food, great music, fair pricing, great view of the ocean! Definitely recommend!!“

“We stopped by here on a whim for a couple drinks. Our bartender was Jeff “Brewer” and he was the best bartender we’ve ever had. He was very personable & knowledgeable about his craft. He surprised us with unique drinks (not on the drink list) complete with the back story/history of each one. We absolutely loved our experience!“

“We stayed at this resort while diving next-door at the sister resort love this place. It was very clean. Food was amazing. Beach was clean and the pool and tiki bar was a plus will definitely come back.“

“First night in Islamorada,too tired from the days traveling,so we ordered a Turtle Inn salad with grilled chicken to split. Super fresh produce,homemade dressing. It brought us back for a second visit.“

“Love this restaurant! 10/10. We had the fish and chip-best I have ever had! We also had the key lime pie because you have to when you are in the Keys! Soooo good! Then there is the atmosphere-tarpons swimming by, pelicans floating, and the view-wow! To add to that there was great music from a singer (didn’t catch his name) and a wonderful waitress! Definitely will be back!“

“They kept the charm of the old Marker 88 in little details like keep the 2 GREEN covered table and benches almost in the same location as before... a iconic scene was shot in one of them on a episode of BLOODLINE. Food is as good if not better than before if that is possible.... service is excellent too. Friendly staff including hostess/host and waitresses/waiters very impressed with the new dock and WOW EVERY table has a GREAT view to take in LOTS of selfies were being taken during my visit, I celebrated my 78th Birthday 1 day before and had Fresh Mahi Mahi Tacos for Lunch. So happy they did a complete do over after the destruction from the hurricane that so much damage to the beautiful Keys. Welcome Back Marker 88! Happy to see you there....“

“Louis was charmingly entertaining! Will definitely stop in again. What's up with not having Zane Grey merchandise? I think you're missing a huge opportunity.“

“Best bbq I’ve had in years!!!!! Worth the visit 100%“

“Einfach Wunderbar 🌴💚 I'm freien sitzen und auf das Meer schauen, essen lecker, leider alles in Plastik serviert“

“Marker 88 is an absolute gem in Islamorada! The atmosphere is relaxed and beautiful, with unbeatable waterfront views, but the highlight of my visit was the blackened hogfish with Tabasco butter sauce. Perfectly seasoned, cooked just right, and the sauce was incredible — rich, flavorful, and with just the right amount of kick. It’s one of those dishes you’ll be thinking about long after the meal. The service was friendly and attentive, making the whole experience even better. If you’re in the Keys, Marker 88 is a must-visit for both the food and the setting. Highly recommend!“

“Awesome place, great bartenders, fantastic owners, and the coldest Busch Light in the keys! This historic bar is a must stop with phenomenal pizza and full menu. I strongly recommend a visit to the Whistle Stop.“