38 Best American Restaurants near Tavernier

Friday Farmers Market (seasonal) American • $
90055 Old Highway, Tavernier

“Great little Market with beautiful crafts, clothing and foods and fruits & veggies. Take a break from all the stores with the same merchandise and check out the Farmers Market!“

4.7 Superb13 Reviews
Island Grille at Ocean Pointe American • $$
500 Burton Drive, Tavernier

“Not sure why listed as hotel as property is a condo rental. It exceeded our expectations and had ocean view small balcony, late pool, small grill and bar by pool, with restaurant overlooking ocean but only open on weekends. Large 2 bedroom, 2 bathroom condo. No onsite “hotel services “. Towels, toilet paper etc available with phone call. Very quiet property.“

4 Good17 Reviews
Capt Craig's Restaurant Seafood • $$
90154 Overseas Highway, Tavernier

Customers` Favorites

Famous Fish Sandwich Blackened
World Famous Fish Sandwich
Chicken Tender with Fries
Craig's Grouper Sandwich
Blackened Mahi Tacos
Stone Crab Chowder
Smoked Fish Dip
Fried Calamari
Conch Fritters
Stone Crab Soup

“Fast and friendly service, very clean, and the food was fantastic, we had the chowder, the fish tacos and the shrimp! The Key Lime pie was amazing as well 👍“

4.6 Superb451 Reviews
Harriette's Restaurant American • $
95710 Overseas Highway, Key Largo - 3.51 miles

Customers` Favorites

All Protein Breakfast with 3 Eggs Sausage and Bacon
Chicken Fried Steak \u0026 Sausage Gravy
Chicken Fried Steak & Sausage Gravy
One Egg & Silver Dollar Pancakes
Ham Steak Hash Browns and Eggs
Country Fried Steak and Eggs
Eggs Benedict or Florentine
Corned Beef Hash Breakfast
Traditional Eggs Benedict
Breakfast Burrito Supreme

“What a wonderful and tasty breakfast! Quite filling. Reasonably priced. The homemade biscuit is like a desert like biscuit. Very tasty!! Loved this restaurant.“

4.8 Superb482 Reviews
High tide restaurant American • $
99411 Overseas Highway, Key Largo - 7.2 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fra Diablo Breakfast Burrito
Key Lime Fish Sandwich
Lobster Benedict
Coconut Shrimp
Lobster Bisque
Country Skillet
Conch Fritters
Nova Benedicts
Denver Omelet
Seafood Combo

“Went with the family. Everybody was very happy with the food and service.“

4.8 Superb311 Reviews
Keys Bite American • $
99000 Overseas Highway, Key Largo - 6.85 miles

Customers` Favorites

Breakfast Burrito with Chorizo
Shrimp Basket with Fries
Hash Browns Home Fries
Island French Toast
Biscuits and Gravy
Breakfast Sandwich
Sweet Potato Fries
Island Pancakes
Mexican Skillet
Cuban Sandwich

“What a great dining experience as we’re leaving The Keys. Great service and even better vibes inside. Key Lime pie was sooo good!“

4.6 Superb438 Reviews
The Hideout Restaurant American • $
47 Shoreland Drive, Key Largo - 11.15 miles

Customers` Favorites

French Toast with Bacon Ham or Links 2 Eggs
Country Benedict Bacon or Sausage
Biscuits & Gravy with 2 Eggs
Key Largo Fish Sandwich
Lobster Eggs Benedict
All You Can Eat Fish
Biscuits and Gravy
Lobster Omelette
Lobster Benedict
Key Lime Pie

“Like its name implies, THE HIDEOUT is certainly hidden and a treasure to find!! Food is fresh and cooked to perfection! Other food items were fresh and healthy! This is the place you will never forget and will even end up writing a story about… Unforgettable and always on my must go-to list.!!“

4.5 Superb446 Reviews
Marathon Bagel Co Islamorada American • $
86701 Overseas Highway, Islamorada - 5.21 miles

Customers` Favorites

Whitefish Salad
Chicken Salad
Egg Sandwich
Italian Sub
Egg & Onion
Tuna Salad
Bagel

“We went almost everyday! Bagels are delicious! Great to have my kids know what a real bagel is. Don’t be deterred by a long line, they go quick plus it’s fun listening to all the accents. Highly recommend the Nova with the works!“

4.7 Superb131 Reviews
Tiki Bar Tiki Bar • $$
84001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada - 7.49 miles

Customers` Favorites

Lobster Bites Those Big Ones Grouper Cheeks
Sticky Grilled Beef Skewers
Islamorada Fish Sandwich
The Original Rum Runner
Passion Por Mi Amor
Chicken Quesadilla
Mahi Fish Tacos
Conch Fritters
Coconut Shrimp
Chips

“Very accommodating of Celiac and gluten free options. We ordered a caesar salad and the food came out with several options on the side explained to us and the things they took of were listed and explained to us why.
Drinks were delicious! I had The Starwberry Letter.“

4.3 Superb155 Reviews
Alfredo's Cookhouse Steak House • $$
102250 Overseas Highway Suite 102250, Key Largo - 9.99 miles

Customers` Favorites

Blackened Seafood Combo
Hibachi Fried Rice
Breakfast Burrito
Huevos Rancheros
Seafood Alfredo
Chicken Alfredo
Fried Ice Cream
Fried Calamari
Grande Burrito
Churrasco Steak

“Great place, great service, very clean, the best restaurant in the keys ! We love it everything about it“

4.7 Superb576 Reviews
Snappers Oceanfront Restaurant & Bar Seafood • $$
139 Seaside Avenue, Key Largo - 2.45 miles

Customers` Favorites

Camarones Empanados
Sweet Potato Fries
Lobster Bisque
Conch Fritters
Coconut Shrimp
Fish and Chips
Fish Sandwich
Seafood Tacos
Mahi Sandwich
Conch Chowder

“Food was outstanding and great atmosphere. The waitress was fantastic. Will visit again.“

4.4 Superb933 Reviews
Mangrove Mike's Cafe • $
82200 Overseas Hwy MM 82.2, Islamorada - 9.41 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pancakes with Eggs and Sausage
Kitchen Sink Tater Tot Tower
Cinnamon Roll French Toast
Kitchen Sink Quesadilla
Craig's Hangover Helper
Gluten Free Hot Cakes
Kitchen Sink Omelette
Eggs Bacon and Potatos
French Toast Sampler
Breakfast Quesadilla

“We were on our way back to Jax and stopped at our favorite breakfast/lunch spot! Once again a winner for all of us! Great food and great service!“

4.6 Superb735 Reviews
Mrs. Mac's Kitchen (Little) Family • $
99336 Overseas Highway, Key Largo - 7.12 miles

Customers` Favorites

French Toast with Scrambled Eggs
Our Famous House Cottage Fries
Mrs Mac's Famous Key Lime Pie
Slice of Key Lime Pie
Key Lime Freeze
Conch Chowder
Conch Fritters
Shrimp Basket
Fresh Fish
Seafood

“The food was soooo good, service was exceptional.. Highly recommend!!!“

4.6 Superb706 Reviews
Sharkey’s Sharkbite Grill American • $$
522 Caribbean Drive, Key Largo - 7.7 miles

Customers` Favorites

Deep Dish Key Lime Pie
Kahuna Quesadillas
Mahi Mahi Key Largo
Baja Fish Tacos
Smoked Fish Dip
Coconut Shrimp
Conch Fritters
Chicken Wings
Fish N Chips
Shrimp Tacos

“A party of 4, we went for breakfast at 10am. Lucy was our server. If I could give her 10 stars, I would. She was hands down one of the best waitresses we’ve ever had at any restaurant. We had a bad experience at another local restaurant the evening before and was kind of over key largo until we stumbled upon Sharkey’s/Lucy. The food was delicious too. Such an all around great experience we plan to go back for dinner.“

4.2 Good686 Reviews
Bogie's Cafe American • $
99701 Overseas Highway, Key Largo - 7.54 miles

“Bogie's is such a cool place! It is situated at the Holiday Inn in Key Largo by their fabulous pool with waterfall. It is a good-sized tiki hut with comfortable high top chairs. It is in the shade. There are tables with umbrellas and another smaller tiki hut for seating.

I want to commend the guys that work there and how they provided A+ service while we were staying there (May 7-9). They were hard workers and brought our meals to us by the pool and even picked up the plates after we were done. All with a nice smile!

The food was delicious. We had Chicken Fingers one day and the next day, Chicken & Cheese quesadillas! Both were good choices. We enjoyed Bogie's.“

4 Good24 Reviews
Wahoo's Seafood Bar and Grill Restaurant Seafood • $$
83413 Overseas Highway, Islamorada - 7.96 miles

Customers` Favorites

The Wahoo's Fried Seafood Platter
House's Signature Wahoo blt Club
Key's Local Whole Fried Snapper
Wahoo's Signature Seafood Rice
Locals Favorite Wahoo Bites
Classic Keys Fish Sandwich
Oysters on the Half Shell
Key Lime Pie in the Keys
Killer Conch Fritters
Key Lime Shrimp Bowl

“Absolute awesome food. The frutti di mare was absolutely delicious. Filled with seafood. The crab shrimp chowder awesome. I would definitely recommend this place and anyone who comes to islamorada. Our server Yoa it was awesome! I would not miss this place if you're coming towards the keys.“

4.5 Superb874 Reviews
C&C wood fire eats Pizza • $$
99201 Overseas Highway, Key Largo - 6.99 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza with Basil and Truffle Oil
Meatball \u0026 Ricotta
Prosciutto and Truffle
Truffle Pizza Sticks
Truffle Pizza Micks
Pizza with Sausage
Pizza Cheese Pizza
Charcuterie Board
Short Rib Lasagna
Meatball & Ricotta

“Best pizza I ever had. I’m 73 and I’ve had a lot to try . Best ever!“

4.6 Superb370 Reviews
Mrs. Mac's Kitchen (Big) Seafood • $$
99020 Overseas Highway, Key Largo - 6.79 miles

Customers` Favorites

Famous Key Lime Pie with Whip Cream Whole
Whole Yellowtail Snapper
Seafood Combo Basket
Key Lime Pie Slice
Alligator Bites
Beans and Rice
Fish and Chips
Coconut Shrimp
Great Seafood
Conch Chowder

“Loved: + service + food + fantastic chili Meh: - noise“

4.5 Superb701 Reviews
Doc's Diner Diner • $
99696 Overseas Highway, Key Largo - 7.52 miles

Customers` Favorites

Belgian Waffle Tropical Style with Bananas Pecans and Shredded Coconut
Italian Chocolate Chip Pancakes
The Champ with Corned Beef Hash
Daily Homemade Cinnamon Roll
Breakfast Burrito Grande
Great Breakfast Skillet
Bacon Eggs Hash Browns
Tropical French Toast
Hash Brown Casserole
Doc's Breakfast Wrap

“Best breakfast in Key Largo - wonderful specials, great prices and service - my new go to for breakfast and lunch“

4.6 Superb346 Reviews
Morada Bay American • $$
81600 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada - 10.19 miles

Customers` Favorites

Day Boat Yellowtail Snapper Sando
המבורגר עם בייקון
Thai-Style Key West Shrimp Taco
Fish and Chips Morada Style
Big Boy BBQ Beach Burger
Bahamian Conch Fritters
Day Boat Snapper Sando
Mahi-Mahi Fish Tacos
Thai Key West Tacos
Whole Fried Snapper

“This place is just not a pretty face. Ok, well it is but, the food is as tasty as the sunsets are dramatic.“

3.9 Good410 Reviews
Lazy Days Restaurant Seafood • $$
79867 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada - 11.85 miles

Customers` Favorites

Catch of the Day Lazy Days Style
Bring Your Own Catch of the Day
Oysters on the Half Shell
Broiled Seafood Platter
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail
Il Pescato Del Giorno
Ensalada de Cangrejo
Key Lime Pie Slice
Conch Fritters
Stuffed Shrimp

“Best Cracked Conch & Grouper Sandwich in the keys. Fabulous Service 🫶🏻🏖️ Great View! Cannot wait to check out your sister location in Key Largo - the Lazy Lobster 🫶🏻 See you again soon 🦞🦞🦞🦞“

4.4 Superb703 Reviews
Eco Eats Fast Food • $
99607 Overseas Highway, Key Largo - 7.39 miles

Customers` Favorites

Avocado Chicken Press
Waldorf Chicken Salad
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Smoked Turkey Wrap
Thai Chicken Wrap
Organic Tofu Pita
The Harvest Pita
Strawberry
Salads
Gyros

“The best healthier food in the Keys“

4.6 Superb164 Reviews
Ziggie & Mad Dog’s Seafood
83000 Overseas Highway, Islamorada - 8.59 miles

Customers` Favorites

Lobster Tail and White Truffle Mac & Cheese
Coach Shula's Barbeque Bacon Wrapped Shrimp
Seasoned Steak on Mashed Potatoes
Ziggie's Classic Lobster Bisque
Hot Molten Lava Birfday Cake
Garlic Salted Onion Rings
Truffle Mac \u0026 Cheese
Phyllo Encrusted Escargot
Cowboy Cut Bone-In Ribeye
Crabmeat Stuffed Snapper

“It was good but not worth the wait, they will sit you outside with infested mosquitos. The wait was ridiculous. Server hardly even checked on us. Will not visit again!“

4.2 Good543 Reviews
Green Turtle Inn Seafood • $
81219 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada - 10.45 miles

Customers` Favorites

Our Famous Turtle Sticky Bun
Captain's French Toast
Lobster Mac N Cheese
The Turtle Breakfast
Meatloaf Sandwich
Shrimp and Grits
Lobster Benedict
Turtle Chowder
Conch Fritters
Bacon Wrapped

“Amazing food and service! Beautiful crisp wedge salad with grilled shrimp, NY strip and Ribeye. All prepared to perfection. Attentive service and care. 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟“

4.4 Superb288 Reviews
Sunset Lounge Tapas Bar • $$$
80460 Overseas Hwy 3rd Floor, Islamorada - 10.95 miles

Customers` Favorites

Crispy Conch Steamed Buns
House Smoked Fish Dip
Oyster Platter
Lobster Roll
Disco Fries
Wedge Salad
Baked Brie

“We stopped by here on a whim for a couple drinks. Our bartender was Jeff “Brewer” and he was the best bartender we’ve ever had. He was very personable & knowledgeable about his craft. He surprised us with unique drinks (not on the drink list) complete with the back story/history of each one. We absolutely loved our experience!“

4.7 Superb49 Reviews
Hog Heaven Sports Bar and Grill Bar & Grill • $$
85361 Overseas Highway, Islamorada - 6.33 miles

Customers` Favorites

Panino Con Carne Di Maiale Nella Ciotola Insalata Con Salsa
Ultimate Hog Heaven BBQ Sampler
Windley Key Chicken Sandwich
Homestyle Mac N Cheese
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Brisket Deviled Eggs
Key West Street Corn
BBQ Pulled Pork
SD Pulled Pork
Smoked Brisket

“We loved this restaurant! Super laid back atmosphere, delicious food, great music, fair pricing, great view of the ocean! Definitely recommend!!“

4.3 Superb737 Reviews
Islamorada Fish Company Seafood Markets • $$
81532 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada - 10.33 miles

Customers` Favorites

World Famous Islamorada Sandwich
Oysters on the Half Shell Dozen
Fried Seafood Combo Basket
Islamorada Fish and Chips
Whole Yellowtail Snapper
Key Lime Pie in a Cup
Stone Crab Claws
Mahi Mahi Tacos
Smoked Fish Dip
Coconut Shrimp

“Love this restaurant! 10/10. We had the fish and chip-best I have ever had! We also had the key lime pie because you have to when you are in the Keys! Soooo good! Then there is the atmosphere-tarpons swimming by, pelicans floating, and the view-wow! To add to that there was great music from a singer (didn’t catch his name) and a wonderful waitress! Definitely will be back!“

4.3 Superb498 Reviews
Green Turtle Wine & Spirits Bar • $$
81219 Overseas Highway, Islamorada - 10.47 miles

Customers` Favorites

Key Lime Pie

“First night in Islamorada,too tired from the days traveling,so we ordered a Turtle Inn salad with grilled chicken to split. Super fresh produce,homemade dressing. It brought us back for a second visit.“

4.6 Superb51 Reviews
ReelCatch Seafood • $$
80001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada - 11.68 miles

Customers` Favorites

Calamari Rings with Sweet Peppers
Chilled Pink Shrimp Cocktail
Blackened Lobster Tacos
Black & Blue Burger
Chicken Quesadilla
Ceviche De Camaron
Belgian Waffle
Key Lime Pie
Mahi Tacos

“We stayed at this resort while diving next-door at the sister resort love this place. It was very clean. Food was amazing. Beach was clean and the pool and tiki bar was a plus will definitely come back.“

4.3 Superb142 Reviews
Zane Grey Lounge Steak House • $$
Islamorada - 10.28 miles

“Louis was charmingly entertaining! Will definitely stop in again. What's up with not having Zane Grey merchandise? I think you're missing a huge opportunity.“

3.7 Good3 Reviews
Tides Beachside Bar & Grill Seafood • $
82100 Overseas Highway, Islamorada - 9.62 miles

Customers` Favorites

Mango Shrimp Tacos
Islander Burger
Conch Fritters
Key Lime Pie
Tuna Nicoise

“Einfach Wunderbar 🌴💚 I'm freien sitzen und auf das Meer schauen, essen lecker, leider alles in Plastik serviert“

4.2 Good113 Reviews
Bayside Grille & Sunset Bar Seafood • $$
99540 Overseas Highway, Key Largo - 7.23 miles

Customers` Favorites

Lobster Tail Keyribbean Style
Coconut Shrimp & Chips
Bahamian Conch Chowder
Bayside Mahi Sandwich
Guava Rum Cheesecake
Peel and Eat Shrimp
Whole Fried Snapper
Mahi Mahi Sandwich
Caribbean BBQ Ribs
Seafood Enchiladas

“Tender beef medallions were amazing“

4.2 Good605 Reviews
33

Calusa

Calusa American
97000 Overseas Highway, Key Largo - 4.68 miles

Customers` Favorites

Award-Winning Key Lime Pie
Award Winning Key Lime Pie
Seared Yellowtail Snapper
Whole Fish Ecovitch
Seared Scallops
Chocolate Cake
Lobster Benny
Surf and Turf
Tuna Tower
Duck Confit

“Calusa at Bakers Cay was one of the highlights of our trip to Key Largo. The restaurant is absolutely beautiful, and the outdoor patio, nestled above the trees, offers an incredible panoramic view of the water. I’ve been coming to the Florida Keys for years, and I can honestly say this was the most stunning sunset view I’ve experienced.

The food was excellent, but what really set this place apart was the staff. Every single person we interacted with was warm, friendly, and genuinely welcoming. You could tell they truly enjoy working there and take pride in making guests feel at home.

A special thank you to our waitress, Virginia, who was absolutely fantastic. She was attentive, personable, and made our evening even more enjoyable. If you’re looking for a memorable dining experience in Key Largo with amazing food, breathtaking views, and exceptional service, Calusa at Bakers Cay is a must-visit. We’ll definitely be back!“

3.7 Good283 Reviews
The Nest BBQ and Sports Bar Barbecue • $$
81219 US-1, Islamorada - 10.48 miles

Customers` Favorites

Brisket Sandwich with Fries and Collards
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Creamy Coleslaw
Mac and Cheese
Pulled Pork
Baked Beans
Cornbread
Sauce
Ribs
Wings

“Best bbq I’ve had in years!!!!! Worth the visit 100%“

4.1 Good176 Reviews
Marker 88 Seafood • $$
88000 Overseas Highway, Islamorada - 3.85 miles

Customers` Favorites

Famous Homemade Key Lime Pie
Old Man and the Sea Tacos
Islamorada Fish Sandwich
Cheeseburger in Paradise
Yellowtail Meuniere
Hot Blue Crab Dip
Key Lime Seafood
Shrimp -N- Grits
Seafood Platter
Lobster Bisque

“They kept the charm of the old Marker 88 in little details like keep the 2 GREEN covered table and benches almost in the same location as before... a iconic scene was shot in one of them on a episode of BLOODLINE. Food is as good if not better than before if that is possible.... service is excellent too. Friendly staff including hostess/host and waitresses/waiters very impressed with the new dock and WOW EVERY table has a GREAT view to take in LOTS of selfies were being taken during my visit, I celebrated my 78th Birthday 1 day before and had Fresh Mahi Mahi Tacos for Lunch. So happy they did a complete do over after the destruction from the hurricane that so much damage to the beautiful Keys. Welcome Back Marker 88! Happy to see you there....“

4.1 Good762 Reviews
Marker 88 Tiki Bar Bar • $$
88 Overseas Highway, Islamorada - 3.85 miles

Customers` Favorites

Key Lime Pie
Crab Cake

“Marker 88 is an absolute gem in Islamorada! The atmosphere is relaxed and beautiful, with unbeatable waterfront views, but the highlight of my visit was the blackened hogfish with Tabasco butter sauce. Perfectly seasoned, cooked just right, and the sauce was incredible — rich, flavorful, and with just the right amount of kick. It’s one of those dishes you’ll be thinking about long after the meal. The service was friendly and attentive, making the whole experience even better. If you’re in the Keys, Marker 88 is a must-visit for both the food and the setting. Highly recommend!“

3.9 Good140 Reviews
The Whistle Stop Pub Pubs • $$
82685 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada - 9.13 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicago Deep Dish Cheese Pizza
Large Pepperoni Pizza
Southwestern Egg Rolls
Classic Cheese Pizza
Cheeseburger Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Wings
Chicago Pizza
Liquor Store
Street Tacos

“Awesome place, great bartenders, fantastic owners, and the coldest Busch Light in the keys! This historic bar is a must stop with phenomenal pizza and full menu. I strongly recommend a visit to the Whistle Stop.“

3.9 Good162 Reviews
Waffle House Breakfast • $
100270 Overseas Highway, Key Largo - 7.96 miles

Customers` Favorites

Texas Bacon with Hashbrowns Patty Melt
Waffle with Butter and Syrup
Eggs Bacon Hashbrowns Toast
Peanut Butter Chip Waffle
Chocolate Chip Waffle
T-Bone \u0026 Eggs
Eggs and Ham Steak
Two Egg Breakfast
Bacon and Waffles
Breakfast Platter

“My kid had never been to one and this was a great experience. The waitress was fun and amazing and even let my daughter pick the playlist. 10/10“

4 Good427 Reviews

You May Also Like