Cool Cookie Creamery
Ice CreamAbout Cool Cookie Creamery
Customers' Favorites
Ice Cream Sandwich
Cool Cookie Creamery Reviews
23 ratings
Share your opinion about Cool Cookie Creamery
The lady working Saturday and Friday in the afternoon was an absolute angel! She was so kind and so diligent. Definitely great service. Simple and efficient
We normally visit Mint Fox but I saw this online and wanted to try it! My husband got a cup full of cookie ice cream, heath cookie, and brownie (we bought the brownie separate). I got a scoop of coffee caramel with fudge flakes.
The descriptions of the ice cream seem epic. We sampled a decent amount but the samples were so small we couldn’t get the full experience. (Ex: one was swirled with buttercream but didn’t taste).
The heath cookie was just okay. Didn’t...read full review
The descriptions of the ice cream seem epic. We sampled a decent amount but the samples were so small we couldn’t get the full experience. (Ex: one was swirled with buttercream but didn’t taste).
The heath cookie was just okay. Didn’t...read full review
This is the best ice cream and sorbet on the island. We are here daily. The island joy and triple berry was our favorite. Yummy!
Hours
| Monday | 12 - 9PM |
| Tuesday | 12 - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 12 - 9PM |
| Thursday | 12 - 9PM |
| Friday | 12 - 9PM |
| Saturday | 12 - 9PM |
| Sunday | 12 - 9PM |
Cool Cookie Creamery is a charming ice cream shop that offers a delightful array of homemade ice creams, cookies, and brownies. Visitors have noted the deliciousness of the ice cream, with creamy textures and a variety of flavors that make it hard to choose a favorite. Signature offerings like the Feeling Peachy Sorbet, made from fresh Georgia peaches, have received particular praise for their refreshing taste.
While some flavors may lack intensity, many guests appreciate the overall quality and uniqueness of the menu. The brownie, in particular, has been described as “FIRE” and comes highly recommended. The friendly and attentive staff contribute to a welcoming atmosphere, providing helpful suggestions and making the experience enjoyable.
The shop's location could benefit from better signage to attract more customers, as many discover it by chance. Some reviews suggest a rewards program to enhance customer loyalty and value. Overall, Cool Cookie Creamery is considered a fantastic stop for a sweet treat, with a cozy vibe and reasonably priced options that cater to all ice cream lovers.