The Florida Key Lime Pie Company
$$ • Dessert, Ice CreamAbout The Florida Key Lime Pie Company
Customers' Favorites
Restaurant Style Deep Dish Key Lime Pie Pre-Cut 8 Slices
Homestyle Market Pie Key Lime Pie Uncut
Salted Carmel and Key Lime Ice Cream
Key Lime Pie by the Slice
Key Lime Yogurt Pretzels
Chocolate Ice Cream
Beef Jerky
Beer Cans
Recent Reviews
320 ratings
Share your opinion about The Florida Key Lime Pie Company
Always the best, freshest key lime pie in town. Also love the salt water taffy flavors and all the Florida local products!!
Loved this locally owned store. The owner was super friendly and helpful, the store is nicely set up. Variety of items, wish shipping was available :)
Family owned and loves America
Hours
| Monday | 12 - 6PM |
| Tuesday | 12 - 6PM |
| Wednesday | 12 - 6PM |
| Thursday | 12 - 6PM |
| Friday | 12 - 6PM |
| Saturday | 12 - 6PM |
| Sunday | 12 - 6PM |
The Florida Key Lime Pie Company is a must-visit destination, especially for those with a sweet tooth. Their key lime pie is a standout, boasting the perfect balance of sweet and sour flavors. The cheesecake is also a game-changer, converting even the most skeptical of customers into loyal fans. The friendly and pleasant staff create a welcoming atmosphere that's perfect for families and kids. The shop itself is wheelchair accessible and has a fun, lively vibe, complete with a pet alligator and a unique floor design. Visitors can meet Wally, the live alligator, on weekends. The shop offers a great parking, kid-friendly environment, and an extensive selection of hot sauces and local beers, catering to a wide range of preferences.
The key lime pie and macaroons are highly praised by customers, who describe them as "fantastic" and "the best thing ever." The deep dish key lime pie is also a favorite, with customers noting its perfect balance of flavors and texture. While the selection of desserts may not always meet customer expectations, the shop strives to provide a unique and enjoyable experience for all visitors.