Time Square Pizza & Subs

Name: Time Square Pizza & Subs
Address: 2304 E Oakland Park Blvd, Fort Lauderdale, Florida, 33306, US
Telephone: (954) 566-7772
Price range: $
Rating: 4.3

$ • Pizza, American, New American

Hours:
2304 E Oakland Park Blvd, Fort Lauderdale
(954) 566-7772

Menu Order Online

About Time Square Pizza & Subs

Time Square Pizza & Subs is a small, authentic New York–style pizza shop known for its classic and hearty pizza slices. Despite its old-fashioned and somewhat worn appearance, with décor that hasn't changed since the late 80s, the quality of the pizza speaks for itself. The slices are large, foldable, and feature cheese that stretches impressively, offering a true New York experience. The crust is crispy and fresh, with some reviewers noting it as especially amazing. While the sauce is sometimes described as mild or bland, the overall flavor balances well with the cheese and toppings.

The restaurant is a lively, bustling place where everyone speaks Italian, creating an authentic auditory scene filled with chatter, clanging pizza pans, and ringing phones. The staff, especially Wally, Rafa, and Ralph, are highly praised for their kindness, respect, and craftmanship, making customers feel welcome and valued.

Apart from pizza, the meatball sandwich stands out as a highlight, often described as one of the best in the country. It features tender, hand-butchered beef albóndigas wrapped in mozzarella and served on fresh toasted Italian bread, with a red sauce that adds spice and tang.

Overall, Time Square Pizza & Subs offers a genuine, heartfelt New York–style pizza experience, appreciated for its flavor, authenticity, and warm community atmosphere. Visitors often leave satisfied, praising it as one of the best pizza spots in the region.