Horrible experience! Ordered a cake for Father's Day June 14, 2025. Order was placed June 12, 2025, with a delivery date June 13, 2025. It was never delivered, nor I received a notification about an issue. June 16, 2025 contacted customer service and was told that orders cannot be cancelled if it's less than 3 days notice! Shelby M from Goldbelly finally confirmed that the order was cancelled, but 3 hours later I received an email with UPS tracking number.
Marcos Gonzalez
Excellent cakes
Chelsea Tomasso
We ordered their famous chocolate cake and a coconut cake that were both delicious! Probably the best chocolate cake I’ve ever had. The cakes also looked great!! It seems like a lot of their lower reviews are due to 3rd party deliver services which isn’t always the bakery’s fault. Will definitely be ordering from here again!
Candace Hillier
I bought a white cake with chocolate frosting for my husband‘s birthday. I had an Uber out to Coral Springs. It ended up being a $90 investment, but I wanted something special . We had been a Customer of theirs for some time in the past but this cake unfortunately ended up in the garbage. It was so sweet, we couldn’t eat it. It was the day before Mother’s Day, I don’t know if they doubled up on the icing sugar by mistake or what but we couldn’t eat it.. This weekend we bought a cake from Whole Foods for my granddaughter that was fabulous, Lesson learned.
Holly Dulgerian
I’m obsessed with these cakes they are the best in the whole world. Strawberry and lemon are my two faves!
Alyssa Ramos
I walked in and tried a vanilla cupcake right from the bakery. The cake’s flavor was good but it was on the dry side. Not a fan of the frosting at all :/
Brenda Ford, Ph.D.
The pink roses chocolate cake ordered through Goldbelly was pretty but it was the most flavorless cake we’ve ever had to endure. We couldn’t even enhance the flavor with a glass of champagne! Not only was it a relatively expensive item—90.00—but it was a colossal disappointment. To add insult to injury, it was not delivered in time for the party, which is not the “ We Take The Cake” company's fault, but it was still awful. I’m glad we had a stand-in for the party from a local bakery, and it was far more delicious than what arrived. I will never order this cake again!
Lena Hilton
The most amazing gluten free chocolate cake ever. Ever!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
M W marty
Most excellent, yummy 😋🥰
Jodie Moran
I ordered on Goldbelly for my own birthday. I LOVE cake. I LOVE a good buttercream. After spending that much on a 6” cake, I REALLY wanted to love this cake. I anticipated cutting into this celebratory dessert. Delivery: delivery was on time and perfectly packaged. Good instructions on thawing and serving. Presentation: beautiful cake. Colorful. No complaints! Taste: this is where it all went wrong. I was sorely disappointed. The cake was dense but not too dense. That part was fine. It was moist. But there was ZERO TASTE. It kind of reminded me of pound cake. But since it was a butter cake I guess that is a fair comparison, but even pound cake has either a vanilla or almond taste/ essence to it. It didn’t even smell good. The buttercream: gross. It was so greasy and tasteless. I felt like I was eating whipped crisco. After 1 bite I had a film of oily fat all over my lips. No. Just no. I was sorely disappointed sad. No vanilla taste at all. There were 4 of us eating this cake and everyone threw theirs away after 3-4 bites. Nobody liked it. I will be throwing away the rest of this cake.
Food: 1
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Celebration Golden Butter Vanilla
We ordered the cake through Goldbelly.it was the chocolate cake with the red rosettes for my husband. This was by far the best chocolate cake we have ever had,from the frosting to the moist cake and filling. Great job to all.
Iki Bennani
Just stopped by to place an order. The front customer-facing older brunette lady is your key to bankruptcy. Enough said. Good luck in the future.
Ordered through Goldbelly arrived 1 day late and not packed with enough dry ice. As a result the cake was trashed. It was a birthday cake for my daughter 14th. She was crushed as she picked it herself. Publix had to save the day.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Latasha Gorman
Excellent customer service! The chocolate cover cheese cake with brownie is so good. That is my favorite.
Horrible experience! Ordered a cake for Father's Day June 14, 2025. Order was placed June 12, 2025, with a delivery date June 13, 2025. It was never delivered, nor I received a notification about an issue. June 16, 2025 contacted customer service and was told that orders cannot be cancelled if it's less than 3 days notice! Shelby M from Goldbelly finally confirmed that the order was cancelled, but 3 hours later I received an email with UPS tracking number.
Excellent cakes
We ordered their famous chocolate cake and a coconut cake that were both delicious! Probably the best chocolate cake I’ve ever had. The cakes also looked great!! It seems like a lot of their lower reviews are due to 3rd party deliver services which isn’t always the bakery’s fault. Will definitely be ordering from here again!
I bought a white cake with chocolate frosting for my husband‘s birthday. I had an Uber out to Coral Springs. It ended up being a $90 investment, but I wanted something special . We had been a Customer of theirs for some time in the past but this cake unfortunately ended up in the garbage. It was so sweet, we couldn’t eat it. It was the day before Mother’s Day, I don’t know if they doubled up on the icing sugar by mistake or what but we couldn’t eat it.. This weekend we bought a cake from Whole Foods for my granddaughter that was fabulous, Lesson learned.
I’m obsessed with these cakes they are the best in the whole world. Strawberry and lemon are my two faves!
I walked in and tried a vanilla cupcake right from the bakery. The cake’s flavor was good but it was on the dry side. Not a fan of the frosting at all :/
The pink roses chocolate cake ordered through Goldbelly was pretty but it was the most flavorless cake we’ve ever had to endure. We couldn’t even enhance the flavor with a glass of champagne!
Not only was it a relatively expensive item—90.00—but it was a colossal disappointment. To add insult to injury, it was not delivered in time for the party, which is not the “ We Take The Cake” company's fault, but it was still awful. I’m glad we had a stand-in for the party from a local bakery, and it was far more delicious than what arrived.
I will never order this cake again!
The most amazing gluten free chocolate cake ever. Ever!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Most excellent, yummy 😋🥰
I ordered on Goldbelly for my own birthday. I LOVE cake. I LOVE a good buttercream. After spending that much on a 6” cake, I REALLY wanted to love this cake. I anticipated cutting into this celebratory dessert. Delivery: delivery was on time and perfectly packaged. Good instructions on thawing and serving. Presentation: beautiful cake. Colorful. No complaints! Taste: this is where it all went wrong. I was sorely disappointed. The cake was dense but not too dense. That part was fine. It was moist. But there was ZERO TASTE. It kind of reminded me of pound cake. But since it was a butter cake I guess that is a fair comparison, but even pound cake has either a vanilla or almond taste/ essence to it. It didn’t even smell good. The buttercream: gross. It was so greasy and tasteless. I felt like I was eating whipped crisco. After 1 bite I had a film of oily fat all over my lips. No. Just no. I was sorely disappointed sad. No vanilla taste at all. There were 4 of us eating this cake and everyone threw theirs away after 3-4 bites. Nobody liked it. I will be throwing away the rest of this cake.
Food: 1
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Celebration Golden Butter Vanilla
Restaurantji Recommends
We ordered the cake through Goldbelly.it was the chocolate cake with the red rosettes for my husband. This was by far the best chocolate cake we have ever had,from the frosting to the moist cake and filling. Great job to all.
Just stopped by to place an order. The front customer-facing older brunette lady is your key to bankruptcy. Enough said. Good luck in the future.
Awesome cake. Delish, moist cake and creamy frosting. Decadent. Lovely staff
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered through Goldbelly arrived 1 day late and not packed with enough dry ice. As a result the cake was trashed. It was a birthday cake for my daughter 14th. She was crushed as she picked it herself. Publix had to save the day.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Excellent customer service! The chocolate cover cheese cake with brownie is so good. That is my favorite.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...