I Love N.Y Pizza
$ • Pizza, Italian, Pet Friendly
Hours:
2645 SW 91st St #400, Gainesville
(352) 333-6185
About I Love N.Y Pizza
Customers' Favorites
I Love N.Y Pizza Reviews
Share your opinion about I Love N.Y Pizza
Highly recommend this pizzeria! Very kind staff, food is the highest quality and they are very consistent! My goto every time I’m in the area!
One of the best spots in town. I think the reason I choose this over other places so often is because you simply get more bang for your buck, which is increasingly important. I Want to recommend the pasta in particular. Pasta at so many eateries is overpriced. You've got to pay over $20 a person to get something decent. But you can spend $15 here at I Love NY Pizza on something that tastes great and is big enough to feed multiple people. That's tough to beat!
One of the worst pizzas you'll come across
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 10AM - 9PM |
| Tuesday | 10AM - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 10AM - 9PM |
| Thursday | 10AM - 9PM |
| Friday | 10AM - 10PM |
| Saturday | 10AM - 10PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 9PM |
People in Gainesville Also Viewed
I Love N.Y Pizza is a highly regarded restaurant known for its authentic New York-style pizza. Many customers, including those originally from New York and Buffalo, praise the pizza as the closest they have found to genuine NY pizza, with some describing it as thick crust with a crispy bottom. The menu features a variety of options, including veggie toppings like eggplant, which is hard to find elsewhere, and create-your-own calzones that receive high praise. The restaurant also offers large, delicious eggplant subs and a popular Chicago-style pizza that resembles a thick crust, not deep dish, but with a crispy bottom. Wings are another favorite, described as large and tasty.
The food consistently receives positive reviews for its quality and flavor. Desserts like tiramisu are also appreciated. Customers highlight the friendly service, with staff working hard to ensure a great experience, even accommodating large groups with little notice. The restaurant is noted not only for its tasty food but also for its welcoming atmosphere and excellent customer service, making it a favorite spot for celebrations and regular visits alike. Overall, I Love N.Y Pizza is celebrated for providing delicious, authentic pizza and a friendly environment, worth the drive and delivery for many satisfied customers.