22 Best Cocktail Bars in Key West

“Bartender alone ! She made an Outstanding Old Fashion and grapefruit Martini.“

“This is a must stop of you are a Jimmy Buffett fan! Very small place and seating is very limited. They offer free popcorn, peanuts and hot dogs for food. Great drinks and domestic beers with at least one craft choice on bottles.
The place is a shrine to the characters of old Key West and of course where Jimmy got his start in 1971. Talk to the bartenders and they'll tell you great stories of the old days.“

“Had a blast! You exceeded all of my expectations with your tequila selection last night. From your single barrel Fortaleza “Horse Play” to the G4 6 barrel and the other extensive selection. Killer atmosphere def sets you apart from everywhere else. The DJ out back was sick and we will be back.Keep up the good work!“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Absolutely Amazing Experience! From start to finish, everything was exceptional! The food was fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented — truly some of the best we’ve had in a long time. The drinks were perfectly crafted and delicious, and the service was outstanding — friendly, attentive, and made us feel so welcome. Every detail was spot-on, and we can’t wait to come back. Highly recommend to anyone looking for great food, great service, and a great atmosphere!“

“Wonderful time. Great happy hour!“

“great food, good prices. beautiful view“

“Perfect location on Duval! Easy walk to beach, bars, and restaurants. Extremely friendly and helpful staff. Rooms have everything you need, refrigerator, microwave, toaster, beach chairs, beach towels, information on local attractions, I could go on and on… Oh and the fact that the rum bar is right downstairs is very convenient, maybe too convenient, lol! 🍹🥴“

“I love this bar! Very laid back, staff is awesome, and a great place to just hang out.“

“Lolita’s nails fresh, flavorful coastal dishes with a relaxed, bright atmosphere. From perfectly seasoned seafood to crisp, refreshing sides, every bite feels thoughtful.

The staff are friendly and helpful, and the setting makes it ideal for a casual lunch and dinner.“

“If you’ve ever wondered what it’s like to mainline gasoline in slushy form, welcome to Fat Tuesday Key West. The 190 Octane (153 proof grain alcohol + orange punch) is basically jet fuel with a citrus twist — I’m 90% sure my rental scooter ran better after I spilled some on it.

The flavors here range from “fun beach vacation” (Piña Colada) to “pray for my liver” (Cat 5 Hurricane) to “this is how Florida Man is born” (Mardi Gras Mash with bourbon + triple sec). You can even get a 128oz gallon to go — because nothing says “responsible tourist” like walking down Duval Street with a jug of neon alcohol that could double as antifreeze.

I got the Souvenir Squeeze Bottle thinking it was cute. Turns out, it’s basically a lifetime commitment — you’ll be refilling it until your doctor writes you a letter.

Also, big respect to the Skinny Watermelon Daiquiri: same 153-proof grain alcohol, just “half the calories.” Because obviously the calories were the dangerous part.

By the time I mixed 190 Octane Blue Raspberry with Mango Tango and topped it with Spicy Margarita, I’m pretty sure I accidentally discovered the cure for jet lag — or possibly astral projected into Jimmy Buffett’s backyard.

Pro tip: Hydrate, wear sunglasses, and maybe text your mom before your third refill, because after that it’s anybody’s guess what your night (or your Instagram stories) will look like.

Would I come back? Yes. Should you? Only if your insurance is paid up.

🍹🌴 #FrozenDecisions #DuvalStreetScience“

“My husband and I have been coming here for years. It’s exceptional. We never have any problems with dietary restrictions and the service is 10/10“

“Great cuisine and great drinks . Always the best live entertainment on the Island !“

“Best place in Key West for dinner and cocktails“

“I love this bar! Very laid back, staff is awesome, and a great place to just hang out.“

“This place is incredible!“

“The food was excellent; my wife had the hog fish special and I had the chicken parmigiana. We split chocolate mousse for dessert. The service was excellent. Highly recommended!!“

“Romantic dining with the most creative entrees . Such a memorable experience“

“Oh my gosh! Best place ever! Amazing oysters and amazing buffalo shrimp. But most of all the service! Wells was our waitress and she was AMAZING!!! Thank you for making our experience wonderful!!!“

“First Flight Island Restaurant & Brewery was one of the highlights of my Key West trip! The atmosphere is fun and relaxed, with a perfect island vibe. The food was fresh and flavorful, the drinks were amazing, and the service was friendly and attentive. It’s the kind of place where you can sit back, enjoy great food, and soak in the Key West charm. Definitely a must-visit! 🍹🌴✨“

“The cutest Tiki Bar Restaurant of all the hotels in KW! Best drinks and snacks when hanging around the pool! Jennifer and Milly are absolute Queens ?? with making drinks! They can help you with anything you need! I even tried taking them home with me ??‍♀️ I can't wait to come back! ?“

“Southernmost Beach Café has the view, the vibe, and the beachside location — but what really stands out are the people behind the bar, especially Doina and Saunders.\n\nThey’re the kind of bartenders who make you feel welcome the moment you sit down. Friendly, upbeat, and always in a good mood, they bring the kind of energy that turns a simple breakfast or drink into a great experience.\n\nThey’re also more than happy to put on whatever game you’re hoping to catch, and the nachos make a perfect snack during football. It’s become a regular stop for me, and it’s because of the way they treat their guests — with genuine hospitality and great conversation.\n\nHighly recommend grabbing a seat at the bar and letting Doina and Saunders take care of you.“

“Best fresh seafood restaurant in Key West, or anywhere in the keys. Consistently fresh consistently good. Pleasant staff“