New American Restaurants in Key West, FL

Hot Tin Roof Restaurant Seafood • $$$
0 Duval St, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Whole Crispy 1 5 Yellowtail Snapper
Heirloom Tomato and Burrata Salad
Whole Crispy Yellowtail Snapper
Blackened Shrimp Mac & Cheese
Plantain Crusted Swordfish
Island Grouper Ceviche
Crispy Brussel Sprouts
Lobster Mac and Cheese
Jumbo Lump Crab Cake
Seared Black Grouper

“Lovely anniversary dinner. Excellent service and meal. They had a sign on our table wishing us a happy Anniversary and we had the best view of the sunset!!“

4.7 Superb335 Reviews
Cafe Marquesa Cafe
600 Fleming St, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Pan Seared Scallops and Key West Pink Shrimp
Seared and Chilled Yellow Fin Tuna
Prime Center Cut Filet Oscar
Crispy Yellowtail Snapper
Miso Glazed Black Grouper
Crispy Pork Osso Bucco
Prime Beef Carpaccio
Shrimp and Grits
Crispy Oysters
She Crab Soup

“One of the best hotel and cafe restaurants in key west“

4.5 Superb586 Reviews
Little Pearl Seafood
632 Olivia St, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Seared U-10 Diver Scallops
Oysters on the Half Shell
Wagyu Beef Cheek Ramen
Ceviche Du Jour
Famous Octopus
Day Boat Fresh
Cheese Plate
Lobster Bao
Stone Crab
Caviar

“Awesome restaurant and menu. Very, very friendly service!“

4.5 Superb233 Reviews
Latitudes Seafood • $$$
245 Front St, Key West

Customers` Favorites

1 Key Lime Pie in Key West Seriously We Tried Them All
Maine Lobster Roll with Homemade Chips
Maine Lobster & Jump Lump Crab Cakes
Wagyu Beef Skirt Steak
Yellowtail Snapper
Crab Lobster Cake
Tenderloin Steak
Lobster Benedict
Lobster Bisque
Surf and Turf

“Spectacular from start to finish, 3 hour fine dining experience with amazing menu options, beautiful wine list, and top quality service! A must if you’re in Key West!!!“

4.2 Good731 Reviews
Nine One Five American • $$$
915 Duval St #5, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Prime Filet Green Peppercorn Sauce Cone of Fries
Butternut Squash Ravioli
Whole Yellowtail Snapper
Fried Fresh Calamari
Shrimp Fettuccine
Seafood Fettuccine
Shishito Peppers
Ahi Tuna Gravlax
Grass Fed Burger
Grilled Octopus

“My husband and I were there tonight. We were at your restaurant 12 years ago and we had the Soul Mama soup then and I had to go back while in Key West to have it again. Even in 100 degree weather I had to order me some soul mama soup. The lobster special was very tempting, but I couldn’t pass up my favorite. Thank you for keeping Soul Mama on the menu ❤️🎉“

4.1 Good369 Reviews
The Flaming Buoy Filet Co. New American • $$
424 Eaton St, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Duck Confit Flat Bread with Cherry Port Sauce & Manchego Cheese
Filet Mignon with Lobster Mac \u0026 Cheese
Fresh Catch Pan-Seared with Banana Salsa
Lobster Macaroni & Cheese
Grilled Corn - - He-Cob
Bacon Wrapped Scallops
Surf and Turf Special
Grilled Black Grouper
Lobster Mac & Cheese
Lobster Thermidor

“All I can say is check this place out! The food is amazing!“

4.7 Superb128 Reviews
Tempt at The Saint Hotel New American • $$$
417 Eaton St, Key West

“One of my favorite places“

4.8 Superb11 Reviews
Harpoon Harry's American • $
832 Caroline St, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Key Lime French Toast Special
Harry's Breakfast Platter
Key Lime Pie French Toast
Cuban Breakfast Sandwich
Lobster Eggs Benedict
Harry's Fried Chicken
Biscuits and Gravy
Country Fried Steak
Lobster Benedict
Western Omelet

“Our favorite breakfast spot in Key West. Great service and super food.“

4.7 Superb359 Reviews
Azur Restaurant Mediterranean • $$$
425 Grinnell St, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Gnocchi with Butter and Cheese
Pan Roasted Local Grouper
Key Lime Pie French Toast
Steamed Clams and Chorizo
Braised Beef Rib Gnocchi
Key Lime French Toast
Classic Benedict
Grilled Octopus
Seafood Risotto
Eggs Benedict ll

“Thank you for making my wife's birthday dinner enjoyable. Everything was first class. We have been here many times and Azur is one of our favorites in town.“

4.5 Superb558 Reviews
Grand Cafe Key West New American • $$$
314 Duval St, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Carpaccio of Beef Tenderloin
Grand Cafe Surf and Turf
Tartare of Yellowfin Tuna
Grand Cafe Crab Cakes
Flash Fried Calamari
Conch Fritters
Baked Branzino
Crème Brûlée
Grand Lobster
Seafood Pasta

“Had dinner here for Fantasy Fest 2023. Maria was very helpful in giving us a fantastic table for the parade. Had a great time and the food and drinks were so good. Will definitely go back again the next time we're in Key West. Would highly recommend going!!“

3.8 Good364 Reviews
La Te Da New American • $$
1125 Duval St, Key West

“I had an exceptional dining experience at La Te Da! The food was absolutely incredible. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, making it the perfect spot for a memorable dining. What truly set this place apart was the owner, Christopher, who went above and beyond to ensure every guest in my group felt welcomed and cared for. Their passion for both the food and the community was evident in every detail. I can’t recommend this gem enough—it’s a must-visit!“

4.5 Superb260 Reviews
Seven Fish Seafood • $$$
921 Truman Ave, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Curry Cream Sauce over Sushi Rice with Steamed Broccoli & Carrots
Fresh Yellow Tail Snapper Curry
Strawberry Whipped Cream Pie
Yellowtail Snapper Curry
Local Grilled Mahi Mahi
Sautéed Grouper Roll
Key Lime Cheesecake
Thai Curry Snapper
Housemade Gnocchi
Catch of the Day

“Compared to Fort Lauderdale ( where we reside) which has many top rated seafood restaurants, this establishment has absolutely fantastic gourmet seafood dishes. Just had their Curry snapper, was blown away! Fresh caught fish, curry sauce outstanding, just the right amount, fresh steamed vegetables. Cool little bar too. Excellent decor, cool vibes, great service. 10/10 for me . We will definitely be back.“

4.4 Superb559 Reviews
Sunset Pier Seafood • $$
0 Duval St, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Oysters on the Half Shell
Grilled Mahi Mahi Tacos
The Original Rum Runner
Peel and Eat Shrimp
Frozen Margarita
Pork Belly Tacos
Cuban Sandwich
Shrimp Tostada
Conch Fritters
Key Lime Pie

“Best coconut margaritas 🍹“

4.4 Superb288 Reviews
Louie's Backyard Bar • $$$
700 Waddell Ave, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Sauteed Key West Pink Shrimp with Bacon Mushrooms and Stoneground Grits
Florida Lobster Braised in Truffle Butter with Spinach and Prosciutto
Bahamian Conch Chowder with Bird Pepper Hot Sauce
Chocolate Brownie Crème Brûlée
Elevated Shrimp and Grits
Bacon Wrapped Scallops
Bacon Wrapped Shrimp
Skirt Steak Tacos
Swordfish Steak
Grouper Special

“Great experience during lunch. Go straight to the bar. It’s on the water. Beat the dinner crowd and enjoy a great view during a lunch visit. Much more relaxing! No reason to fight the crowds at night.“

4.3 Superb266 Reviews
One Duval Seafood • $$
1 Duval St, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Lobster & Shrimp Linguini
Lobster blt Sliders
Mahi Caesar Salad
Shrimp Cocktail
Mashed Potatoes
Seafood Pasta
Caprese Salad
Key Lime Pie
Eggs Benedict

“tasty brunch followed by relaxing on the beach. Kids loved it here“

4.3 Superb228 Reviews
Blue Mojito Bar & Grill Bar • $$
601 Front St, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Tropical Fruit Plate
Chicken Tenders
Centric Burger
Shrimp Tacos
Chicken Wings
Street Tacos
Cobb Salad
Tuna Bowl

“Grateful for the chill, refreshing vibe of this bar and grill. The food was great and I just loved the laughter and great time everyone here was having together. 🍟🌮

The view is phenomenal! Keep your eyes open and you may even spot some dolphins! 🐬

Praying laughter, joy, peace, and hope continue fill this lovely place! God bless! You are loved! Jn 3:16 🙏☀️“

4.1 Good23 Reviews
McKee's Tiki Bar - The Capitana Key West American • $$
2401 N Roosevelt Blvd, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Key Lime Pie – Florida’S Favorite
Grilled Half- Pound Burger
Local Catch of the Day
Cheddar Cheese Melt
Spicy Chicken Wrap
Key Lime Koolada
Chicken Fingers

“Great atmosphere, the employees excellent! Recommended 150%“

3.7 Good7 Reviews
Afterdeck Bar at Louie’s Bar • $$
700 Waddell Ave, Key West

“Great experience during lunch. Go straight to the bar. It’s on the water. Beat the dinner crowd and enjoy a great view during a lunch visit. Much more relaxing! No reason to fight the crowds at night.“

4.2 Good125 Reviews
The White Tarpon Bar & Restaurant Cocktail Bar • $$
700 Front St, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Jamaican Jerk Fried Shrimp
Smoked Fish Dip
Conch Fritters
Steamed Mussels
Key Lime Pie
Hummus Plate
Caesar Salad
Raw Oysters
Fish Tacos
Sandwich

“Wonderful time. Great happy hour!“

4.1 Good90 Reviews
Tavern N Town Tapas Bar • $$$
Marriott Beachside Hotel, 3841 N Roosevelt Blvd, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Chef's Seasonal Vegetarian Dish
Chocolate Hazelnut Panna Cotta
Slow Roasted Prime Rib Au Jus
Sausage and Mushroom Pizza
Key West Bang Bang Shrimp
Signature Prime Rib Au Jus
Seared Yellowfin Tuna
Ribeye Steam Buns
Charcuterie Board
French Onion Soup

“This place was so good, we went there twice in just the matter of a couple days while we visited key west! It was within walking distance from our hotel. Everything was top notch, fresh salads, cooked to order lamb chops and delicious homemade desserts! Friendly and attentive waitstaff!! Highly recommended!!“

4.1 Good351 Reviews
Matt’s Stock Island Kitchen & Bar American • $$$
7001 Shrimp Rd Suite 200, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Traditional Breakfast
Fried Green Tomatoes
Oysters Rockefeller
Banana Pancakes
Shrimp & Grits
Key Lime Pie
Fish & Chips
Risotto
Toast

“Tonight was our second time here and it was just as perfect. Being from Charleston SC we have been to some excellent restaurants and this is right up there. The atmosphere, view, service, and food are all 110%“

4 Good143 Reviews
Key West Catering Company Caterers • $$
1075 Duval St C12, Key West

“The two things that people mentioned over and over again about the caterer at our wedding was that the meals were awesome and the bartenders were very friendly! From the first phone call with Chef Lea, I knew I was in good hands. He was very accommodating and quick to respond to emails. As a wedding DJ in Key West, I've had his meals before, but this was the first time I have ever hired him to cater an event. I really appreciated how he handled the planning stage with my wife and I. He listened to our vision, while adding in his own professional expertise, which made the dinner stations about as perfect as anyone could ever ask for. We had two bartenders who everyone felt were part of the family and enjoyed having conversations with. It's moments like these that really help create a nice atmosphere at a wedding reception and Key West Catering really knocked it out of the park 👏 PS: Get the Jamacian hot pot. That was the dish that people kept saying was their favorite and I would have to agree!“

3.7 Good71 Reviews
First Flight Island Restaurant & Brewery American • $$
301 Whitehead St, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Spinach Salad with Diced Mango Sliced Red Onion and Roasted Walnuts in a Balsamic Vinaigrette
Brisket Mac and Cheese
Jerk Chicken Sandwich
Island Chicken Pasta
Seafood Fettuccine
Beer Steamed Clams
Scallop Appetizer
Brisket Panini
Whole Snapper
Deviled Eggs

“We really enjoyed our time at First Flight, from the atmosphere to the food! But we especially enjoyed the service. Lorena was wonderful—attentive, personable and a joy to interact with. The conch fritters were good, as were the steak tacos, tropical salad, and swordfish. A varied menu with reasonable prices.“

4 Good297 Reviews
Alonzo's Oyster Bar Seafood • $$
700 Front St, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Beer Steamed Shrimp 1 2 L B or 1 lb
Key Lime Pie a Must Try in the Keys
Raw Oysters on the Half Shell
Roasted Mussels Diablo
Lobster Mac and Cheese
Coconut Fried Grouper
Florida Lobster Tail
Whole Fried Snapper
Baked Oyster Combo
Sesame Seared Tuna

“Oh my gosh! Best place ever! Amazing oysters and amazing buffalo shrimp. But most of all the service! Wells was our waitress and she was AMAZING!!! Thank you for making our experience wonderful!!!“

4 Good359 Reviews
Mangoes Restaurant Seafood • $$
700 Duval St, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Maine Lobster Mac & Cheese
Key West Loaded Pineapple
Lobster Mac and Cheese
New Conch Fritters
Braised Pork Belly
Tropical Tuna Poke
Local Catch Tacos
Ahi Tuna Nachos
Grouper Sandwich
Baja Fish Tacos

“We stopped for lunch which was amazing! The space was beautiful, especially the back courtyard. If we had more time, I would have stopped again.“

3.8 Good361 Reviews