New American Restaurants near Marathon, FL

“We love Sparky's! We usually visit at least 2-3x during our annual trip to the Keys. Their Key Lime Pie is the very best, EVER! Surely this pie has won them awards! Sadly, it will be another 11 mos before we'll be back... Sparky's will be our first stop!“

“Excellent experience at Plaza Grill. From the moment you walk in, the atmosphere is elegant, welcoming, and perfect for a special dinner. The service was outstanding — attentive, friendly, and detail-oriented throughout the entire evening.

The food was exceptional; everything was fresh, perfectly prepared, and beautifully presented. The steaks were cooked exactly as ordered and full of flavor, and the seafood was just as impressive. Their wine and cocktail selection perfectly complements the dining experience.

Definitely one of the best restaurants in Marathon. You can truly see the quality and care they put into every dish and every guest experience. Highly recommended for anyone looking for an excellent dining experience in the Keys.”“

“Had the crab queso again! salmon prepared mazalatán was very good, loved the sauce, huge portions. Husband had the lobster enchiladas. I wasn't a fan of my Thunderbolt margarita, I thought it lacked flavor. Adam was our most attentive and fun server.“

“I would 100% recommend you go and git a cold beer, a burger and the famous french-fries.“

“We are blessed to have eaten here many times when staying at Isla Bella and it's always very enjoyable. Lobster bisque is delicious and I tried the Ahi Tuna and it was excellent. They brought us a flowerless cake to celebrate our 16 year anniversary! It made it very special.“

“FANTASTIC. John and staff made excellent recommendations. Two original signature drinks we fell in love with. The best scallops and swordfish we have ever had. Did not expect the level of service and quality of food - we will be back!“