Papa John's Pizza - 2504 N Roosevelt Blvd

Pizza, Take Out

2504 N Roosevelt Blvd, Key West
(305) 294-1111


Google Google: 2.5
Yelp Yelp: 2
Tripadvisor Tripadvisor: 3.5


Reviews for Papa John's

Gina R.
I don't even know where to start! I tried ordering over the phone someone would pick up then hang up. You'd call back and the phone would be off the more
Tried the gluten free crust from Papa John's. It not only looked horrible it was burnt and tasted like cardboard. Other pizza restaurants do a very respectable more
Paige B.
This place is bad, just bad. The lady at the counter was screaming at another customer and as I stood there for about 5 minutes she finally looked at me then more

More Reviews(45)


Monday 11AM - 12AM
Tuesday 11AM - 12AM
Wednesday 11AM - 12AM
Thursday 11AM - 12AM
Friday 11AM - 1AM
Saturday 11AM - 1AM
Sunday 11AM - 12AM


#Create Your Own | #Specialty Pizzas

Create Your Own

Available Options:
Small Original Crust
Medium Original Crust
Large Original Crust
Extra Large Original Crust
Large Thin Crust
Toppings- Meats and Cheese:
Mild Italian Sausage
Spicy Italian Sausage
Grilled Chicken
Extra Cheese
Parmesan Romano
Canadian Bacon
3-Cheese Blend
Toppings- Fresh-Cut Veggies:
Green Peppers
Baby Portabello Mushroom
Roma Tomatoes
Jalapeno Peppers
Black Olives
Banana Peppers

Specialty Pizzas

Double Bacon 6-Cheese
View Entire Menu

About Papa John's

Papa John's crust is famous for being soft and flavorful. There are a variety of pizza choices from basic cheese pizza to pepperoni to choose from. You can also create your own pizza by choosing the toppings you want the most. Others prefer ordering something classic, like John's Favorite, a six-cheese blend topped with pepperoni, sausage and Italian seasonings. Papa John's also offers vegetarian alternatives like the Spinach Alfredo, Tuscan Six Cheese, and Garden Fresh. And for those that want pizza but don't want to derail all their healthy efforts at the gym, Papa's Lighter Choices offer a slice of the good stuff without guilt. The Mediterranean Veggie is a fantastically flavorful option with 300 or fewer calories per slice. With a lighter portion of real cheese made from mozzarella, Roma tomatoes, onions, banana peppers, mushrooms, and ripe black olives, it will satisfy your pizza cravings. Make tonight a pizza night and order a Papa John's pizza to enjoy with your family or friends. With Papa John's, you'll see why better ingredients really do make a better pizza.

Papa John's Pizza
Papa John's Pizza

Papa John's Pizza

2504 N Roosevelt Blvd, Key West, FL 33040