25 Best Pizza Restaurants near Lithia

“Stopped in yesterday while visiting family in Lithia .Had pasta and pizza and they were both delicious. Manger was vey friendly and he came around maku sure everything was to our satisfaction. Will definitely be back anytime I’m over that way!!!!“

“My coworkers and I work at the Hair Cuttery here I’m Fishhawk. We order from Marcos ALL THE TIME! They are ALWAYS polite and they even go above expectation, and bring our pizza down to us, along with plates, cheese etc. They’re always Friendly and the food is great!“

“Pizza came out delicious and the customer service was amazing. Def recommend and will be back!“

“Amazing company to work with, pizza was fantastic!! Thank you!!!“

“The service and atmosphere provided by the polite staff is incredible. The customer service skills provided by Lamar and Lindsay Its excellent. I definitely enjoy coming here to pick up my pizza because of the outstanding service. The young men Lamar as management skills.

Very clean environment as well.“

“5 stars all the way! If you want delicious food, great customer service and a great place to hang with the family, look no further. I've been eating at Amicis since moving to Fishhawk, and they are always on point. I've had their Pizza, Pastas and Sandwiches and they are all 10/10, everytime.“

“A Slice of Home at Willie's Bloomingdale Pizza As a lifelong lover of pizza and Italian food—raised in the suburbs of Philadelphia where great pizza is almost a birthright—I was genuinely surprised by how hard it was to find truly good pizza after moving to Florida. For a while, I had resigned myself to the usual national chains, which, while convenient, just don’t offer that authentic flavor or neighborhood warmth I grew up with. That all changed when I discovered Willie’s Bloomingdale Pizza on Oakfield. From the moment I walked in, I was met with a welcoming atmosphere. The service is both friendly and professional—they treat you like family without ever compromising on quality. You can immediately tell that this is a place run with heart. The owner is a standout—professional, down-to-earth, and clearly passionate about both the food and the people who walk through the door. It's rare to see that kind of genuine care, and it absolutely shows in every bite and every interaction. The pizza? Outstanding. Flavorful, fresh, and made with an attention to detail that rivals what I grew up with back in Philly. For someone who’s picky about their pizza & Italian food, that’s saying a lot. Good pizza is hard to come by in this part of the Sunshine State, so when you find a place like Willie’s, it’s truly cause for celebration. And what better way to celebrate than with a slice in hand? Willie’s Bloomingdale Pizza is hands-down the #1 spot for pizza & Italian food also cheesesteaks in the area. If you’re nearby and craving something real—something that feels like home—I can’t recommend this place enough.“

“Outstanding pies (pizza), salads, bread, garlic knots, and Bake Ziti. True Italian style!! Service was second to none. I would say, "The Best in Tampa Bay."“

“Great pizza restaurant with great food, The service is amazing and Bailey at the front desk had great customer service and quick. The atmosphere is like any old school pizza restaurant with wood table and checkers floor which gives that old school pizza restaurant vibe. I definitely will be going back when I get the urge to have pizza.“

“Very kind and fast work, was ready right when I got there. Clean and comfortable store

Parking: Public lot, but shared with other stores

Kid-friendliness: Smiling workers, hellos and goodbyes. Very understanding and attentive when asking questions

Wheelchair accessibility: Completely wheelchair accessible“

“Rosati’s pizza even down here in Valrico is outstanding and better than any other local or even Chicago based pizza place in the Tampa area!“

“After growing tired of eating chain store pizza with a seemingly decreasing quality, or being just outside of delivery area, our neighbors recommended Formaggios. We tried a meatlover, and a white pizza without spinach. I don’t see myself going back to chain restaurant pizza if I’m near Formaggio’s!“

“The food and beers are always excellent, the only thing better is the staff! Our server, Naomi, is attentive, thorough and a pleasure to chat with. Highly recommend Gasparilla Pizza!“

“Yummy our family have been going here for years! We enjoyed our get together! Great pizza!“

“I LOVE PIZZA ROCK!!!!!!!!“

“Great food and great atmosphere! Wonderful service“

“Great casual Italian spot, highly recommend the Bang Bang chicken sandwich. The chicken parmesan pizza has also been great when I have tried it. My partner’s favorite thing to get is always the Strawberry Walnut salad, she loves that dish as well.

Overall, good for a quick sit down lunch or casual dinner at an Italian place that isn’t too fancy.“

“Called about specials, I was greater with a smile and passion! They asked about the amount of people I was feeding and recommend different menu options. I was very pleased can't wait to devour this New York style pizza“

“I have been a long-time frequent customer and was very disappointed after trying their new online order process. There was no disclaimer the order would be delivered through a meal service rather than their own drivers. I received cold pizza and soggy wings nearly 2 hours later after the new delivery service decided to drive my pizza around the area fulfilling other customer’s orders from other restaurants first, this is after it likely sat at the restaurant for 20-30 minutes after it was ready for delivery. Had I known this, I would have called in my order directly as I have done in the past. We live within 5 minutes of the store and always receive hot pizzas quickly when ordering via phone. I should have noticed the increased menu prices and realized it was to account for a delivery service fee, but I didn’t. There should be a disclaimer on your website that online orders are delivered through a contracted delivery service. When calling to get an update on the delay I was put on hold and hung up on four times before giving up.“

“Y'ALL HAVE THE BEST PIZZA AROUND.. me and my fiance keep coming back and I would definitely give you guys 5 stars.“

“The food was good and the service was great“

“I have no idea how my pizza turned out, but that’s no fault of Domino’s or its employees bc my dumb-butt self ordered a pizza to my in-laws instead of my own home which is an hour away from this location. While this is embarrassing, I wanted to give a shoutout to Ryan, the delivery driver, who went above and beyond. Domino’s is less than 2 minutes from my house and when I became curious of where on Earth my pizza was, I finally realized my mistake and called my in-laws. Despite it being paid for and the tip included, Ryan still refused to drop off my order until he spoke with me as my in-laws told him I do not live there. This location (Douglas) offered to refund my order, despite it being completely my fault. I cannot begin to express my gratitude for the care and honesty these employees put in. I delivered pizzas for years myself and I will admit that I would not have done what Ryan or Douglas did. These guys don’t get paid enough, so why bother with the extra effort? Ryan didn’t care- he called immediately. Douglas didn’t care- he offered before being asked (which I did not accept). This location will forever have my business whenever I am in town. Thank you Ryan for the effort to do right and to Douglas for telling me this review is the best way to appreciate Domino’s staff!!!“

“Marco's is usually great. Got delivery tonight and the pizza was amazing as usual, however the chicken, after me raving to my husband how good they always are, came like this. Tiny crumbles of batter, only two actual nuggets of meat. Very disappointed.“

“Jane was by far fantastic!! Love the pizza! Thank you for the awesome service!“

“I order from this location only. Tonight as I was waiting for my pizza I observed the young man putting the peppers in the pizza boxes. He had no gloves on and kept putting his hands on his face and hair and also putting them in his pockets. I asked to speak to a manager and of course he was busy. They sent this young man over to talk with me who I had this issue with. He told me his hands were clean. He must not realize he needs to keep his hands off his person and out of his pockets to remain clean. Especially if he’s touching food people potentially eat with no gloves on.“