15 Best Pizza Restaurants in Lutz

“Great food and experience quality!“

“Ordered from catering menu for family lunch celebration.. lasagna , raviolis. Caesar salad.. & garlic knots!! Absolutely delicious.. Tulio & his team .. take a bow!! Definitely recommend supporting our small businesses.. This is a winner!! Thank you !!!“

“SO YUMMY“

“I finally got a chance to check this place out. The food was absolutely amazing and the service was excellent. They really treat you like family here. The pizza was awesome and you gotta check out the meatball appetizer because it was out of this world! Can’t wait for my next visit!“

“MOD pizza is structured like Publixs Pub subs. You go down the line, pick what you want, and then they cook it for you! I'm allergic to wheat so I appreciate that they offer gluten free pizzas. I almost forgot what pizza tasted like... Awesome place for pizza“

“Amici’s was awesome today! We brought around 15 cheerleaders and their parents there for dinner and all the employees were so accommodating, kind and quick. From making the reservation to dinner service and being sweet to our 7-9 year olds, everything was amazing!“

“Had THE best calzone tonight!! I do NOT normally like ricotta. The server suggested that I get it on the side because he said theirs was amazing!! He was not wrong!! It was SO GOOD!! Best service, best food!! Our Cobb salad was also amazing!!! So good!! Everything was fantastic!!“

“I had blaze pizza for the first time a month ago and have literally gone back once or twice a week since then. I ordered the carnivore pizza and the balsamic glaze they put on at the end is a game changer. Highly recommend to at least try it. They have a build your own pizza bar like chipotle and its free to add toppings.“

“Stopped in with my son pretty late, maybe 15–20 minutes before closing, and asked if it was too late to order. The staff was super welcoming and didn’t make us feel like we were a hassle at all. Honestly, I would’ve understood if they said no since it was so close to closing time, but instead they were friendly, professional, and made us feel at home. Pizza came out great too. Really appreciate the attitude and customer service here, it makes all the difference.“

“Love Brick City spaghetti, Stromboli and pizzas! The sauce is delicious. So glad you are just across the street from neighborhood. My weekly favorite restaurant! Much better than Bella Brava!“

“I love the friendly Italian vibe of the owner and family. They make sure whatever you order is exactly how you want it. Always go above and beyond making a pizza or Stromboli and all the items used are fresh. Definitely recommend this restaurant for pizza lovers.“

“I highly recommend Papa John's at the County Line Road location in Lutz..I was really surprised by the store manager Tyler, who went beyond what i was expecting when an order of ours was messed up..He took care of the problem quickly and i was very impressed with his professionalism and customer service! I'll continue to be a loyal Papa John's customer.“

“We order pizza here all the time! Delicious, but tonight must have been a new driver! �“

“Eryk was a great server!“

“The staff and the pizza are great. Just don’t try to use their website to order. It took over twenty (20) minutes and finally I had to switch browsers to order pizza. Then it forgot which location I had set as my favorite, even though I have an account , and defaulted to a store that was miles away, whose street name is almost identical to my favorite, Northdale vs North Dale Mabry.

Even newer information:
I’m adding another star just because the pizza is great.
If you *don’t* use Safari the website seems to work well. I had to use Firefox and now I use the app.
The pizza is tasty either way.
They were about 15 minutes this late last time but they were very apologetic and nice about it. They seemed short staffed and I don’t think it was the fault of the staff that were working that night. They are very busy on Tuesday and there were four people waiting in the store for pickup plus a couple of delivery people walking in and out all the time.
The people in my group love the pizza and I don’t think I could change vendors at this point if I wanted.
We used to order from another chain and the quality was inconsistent.

New information:
Ironically, that website doesn't allow me to complete my survey on my iPhone. I'll try it on my Mac. I like the pizza it's tasty. We buy it for our study group and they absolutely love the pizza.
I like the people at my store, on N. Dale Mabry, they're wonderful. Please make your website just fractionally as good as your pizza and your service, at least good enough for me to use it to order pizza.
I'll still order the pizza even if I have to phone it in. The people in my group would be disappointed if I ordered elsewhere.“