43 Best Pizza Restaurants near Matlacha

“St. Pattys day we listened to live music, ate spicy seafood next to the busy channel watching boat parties go by or pull up to party. We shared breadsticks, fresh drinks, and respite from the sun under a canopy right at the rivers edge. Always fun to watch the boats go by. Servers are fast, knowledgeable, and great. Food portions are big and we couldn't finish everything but took it home for later. Great time.“

“"Cara, the waitress at Backstreets Sports Bar, deserves every bit of praise for her exceptional service. She's attentive, friendly, and goes above and beyond to make sure every customer feels valued and satisfied. Her knowledge of the menu is impressive, and she's always ready with recommendations that never disappoint. Whether it's a busy night or a slow one, Cara's professionalism and warmth shine through. A definite five-star experience thanks to Cara!"“

“From the moment you walk into CiCi's Pizza, you're greeted not just by the inviting aroma of freshly baked pizzas but also by the warm, infectious smile of Jesse. In an environment where the buffet-style dining can feel impersonal, Jesse's professionalism and contagious enthusiasm for customer service transform the experience into something memorable.Jesse, an exemplary staff member, goes above and beyond to ensure every guest feels welcome and valued. His attention to detail, from maintaining the cleanliness of the dining area to ensuring the buffet is always stocked with a variety of piping hot, delicious pizza options, showcases his commitment to excellence.But what truly sets Jesse apart is his ability to make every interaction feel personal. Whether he's recommending his favorite pizza combination or simply sharing a laugh with guests, his genuine kindness and upbeat attitude create a dining atmosphere that's as enjoyable as the food itself.It's rare to find someone who not only excels in their role but also elevates the overall ambiance of a restaurant. Jesse's professionalism, paired with his uniquely positive and engaging demeanor, makes CiCi's Pizza a place you look forward to visiting again and again. It's not just the variety of the pizza that brings you back, but the chance to be greeted by Jesse's smile, a reminder that exceptional service is the heart of a great dining experience.Kid-friendliness: good“

“Best Pizza in Cape Coral! HANDS DOWN! If you haven't tried their pizza, you just don't kbow! We love going there on the regular!Parking: Parking can be difficult during peak lunch 12-1 pm. Lisa can be seen multi-taasking and works really hard to get everyone taken care of, including phone orders. Great experience for a late lunch, as the parking, and wait lines are not as bad. But who can blame them. Their food is that delicious and many flock there for lunch.“

“this place is top tier! i called ahead to see how bad the wait was, the hostess replied “by the time you get here we should have a table ready for you, looking forward to seeing you!” i instantly loved this place. upon our arrival we were immediately seated and everyone was very accommodating to our needs. Janice was our waitress and she was incredible! energetic, friendly, welcoming, made you feel right at home. i just kept saying to myself, why can’t everyone be like this? this quality of service is hard to come by nowadays in the food industry. you could tell she enjoyed her job and loved seeing people’s reaction to how delicious their food is. the home made sangria is authentic! the garlic bread that came out with our salads was life changing! met all my expectations and more! Papa Joe’s is definitely being added to the top of our list for favorite restaurants in Cape Coral!“

“Sunday night, late.... this is the place to go. Very eclectic spot with some excellent off the wall pizza. Walked in and staff was so cool and inviting. Full bar, great artwork, cool lighting, neon wall scapes. Can't wait to go back and listen to live music.We had pizza, but have to highly recommend the fried pizza dough covered in powdered sugar, and served with the best homemade raspberry jam known to man. Can't wait to try the jam on the peanut butter and jelly pizza. BRING YOUR THIRST AND APPETITES! Thanks Alex!!!!“

“Love this place. Grouper sandwich is fantastic... love the crispy batter and generous fish portion! We've been here several times and everything has been delicious. We love the atmosphere here, and the service is great. If you haven't been to this gem of a restaurant, what are you waiting for?!“

“I went to Grado’s for a slice, after seeing great reviews on different sites. I ordered a slice of their Bronx pizza. It had sausage, meatballs and ricotta cheese. It was so good. The flavors were wonderful and the thin crisp crust was outstanding. I will be back!“

“On a whim we tried Ciao and it did not disappoint. Hudson was a friendly server who understood his menu and all options. The dinner started off right with fresh authentic Italian garlic bread. Our party got the veal Parm with and prosciutto arugula pizza. Both were phenomenal with the pizza winning the gold star for the perfectly cooked crust and flavor. The Veal could have been from a high end NY restaurant served with Angel hair pasta. Great atmosphere and gentleman playing the guitar created a wonderful atmosphere. Hope everyone can go as it was not very busy so people are missing out .“

“#1 Pizza so far, My Mom and I try a new pizza place every week trying to find the Best Pizza. No one has come close to RonDaos.We have tried pizza from Port Charlotte to Bonita so far. They serve you Garlic Aioli with the pizza and its amazing. The staff is so friendly. We love this place. We have sent several people there it truly has the Best Pizza!“

“Wow, excellent pizza, the best pizza in the area.Small restaurant with an atmosphere that reminds us of the small pizzerias in the Italian neighborhoods of New York.Easy to get to and plenty of street parking.The staff is very kind and courteous.The prices are reasonable.You can order to bring or eat on site.“

“el local está limpio y organizado burno desde luego es un lugar nuevo ,pero realmente la expectativa que se ve en las redes a la realidad de la calidad de la pizzas no es lo qur se dice la masa está seca es como si estuviera comiendo pan ,muy quemada en los bordes y el queso muy salado ,eso sí los batidos muy buenos ,no es por criticar ,pero realmente no fue de gusto al paladar, lo siento al igual qur mi opinión, es la .misma de las personas qur fuimos sorry ,pero bueno para conocer y degustarnos ,tenemos qur probar para asi saber ,“

“1st time customer, I ordered the calzone and canolis...Lord Jesus above help me, this was absolutely delicious!!!! The calzone was crappy and hot, the toppings were hot and blended deliciously well. The marinara sauce was sweet, tangy with a bit of bite and amazing. The canolis, from the crispy shell to the light delicious creame was the highlight of my meal. Definitely will order again, definitely will tell everyone about this place. Can't wait to go back, even my mom liked it!!!!!“

“Love they have bands here. The one playing rocked the cranberry song. If u kno u kno.Drinks were great price. One of the bartenders was kinda crabby, kept yelling a lil bit.The moz. Sticks and onion rings were cooked perfectly and the oil was clean.The pizza we had was great.Double cheese. Pepperoni. Onions and mushrooms.Was a lil short on the mushrooms but the extra cheese made it worth it.Great place to hang out if u are from out of town for sure..“

“I loved the pizza soooooooooo much just like I do every time I am here and the people are so nice and listen so well to what you have to say to themKid-friendliness: They are soooooo kind and they like I said earlier they listen to you and your kids soooo well and the lady did not believe I could wats 4 silica’s because I was 9 and she was sooo surprised when I proved her wrong“

“A lovely place to get a delicious pizzal in the Cape Coral areaThis restaurant is located in a line of stores on the north side of Cape Coral Parkway East to the west of Del Prado Blvd and just about a block south of where the farmers market is held on the weekends. Parking is available in the lots to the north of the site, adjacent to the restaurant. We ordered and picked up some pizzas. The restaurant has a very open look to it with glass on 3 sides tile floor, wood chairs, a bar area, seating inside, Christmas lights along the ceiling and a clear view into the kitchen and oven. Inside seating is a mixture of counter seats and table seats. There are 2 entrances with one from the parking lot to the north and one to the street along the south. The area was clean and the staff was very friendly. The food is an assortment of Italian dishes. We got 2 pizzas. A 16” pizza runs between $13 and $20. They were hot and ready on time. Both were delicious. Overall, it is a good place to get a delicious pizza from friendly people in the Cape Coral area. Enjoy!“

“Ordered Large with everything on it. Pizza was ready when I arrived in 15 mins as promised!One of the best pies I have had in awhile ?.Both team members I interacted with were very friendly and genuinely appreciated my business! Kudos to the owner, manager and the motivated staff. It's refreshing to experience this level of service. ?Parking: Parking in rear parking lot is best, there are a few parking spots in front of shop.“

“Great food! Cute little place for small dining in.If you're going to place pick up orders, please be respectful to the restaurant and understand this isn't a huge place with a lot of cooks people, HUMANS are preparing your food and deserve respect just like you and I. If you're going to use a delivery service remember not all of them are polite or have patience! Kudos to the lady behind the counter who sat customers, took orders, checked people out, checked on tables, and dealt with the outside delivery people being impatient. We will definitely be back! Food was great!“

“I don't know how they cook their wings but they are by far the best I've ever had! I highly recommend the garlic parmesean flavor. Their pizza is great too. Staff is always friendly and they have relaxed family friendly atmosphere.Kid-friendliness: This place is very kid friendly. They have a couple arcade games and they always have a kids movie playing on one of their big screen tvs“

“I got a NY style cheese pizza last night and it was really good, I’ll definitely be coming back here again. I’m pretty picky I’d say this is definitely a top spot in Cape for pizza. Possibly the best in Cape Coral for a traditional NY style pizza.“

“If you've ever been to a restaurant in Europe, the atmosphere here is very much like that. It's a great little place, very nicely done. The food was excellent, as well as the tiramisu. The whole experience reminded us of our time living in Germany. We will be back, and definitely recommend if you are looking for a low key place to eat and visit.“

“We had a party today for my son at pi theroy and it was amazing! Amy and her husband are amazing owners and hosts and the rest of the staff outstanding as well! Food is a 10 out of 10..pizza is delicious and wings so crispy and garlic knots are to die for! Ty Amy for being so accommodating and we will definitely spread the word of how awesome this place is!!!“

“We went last night for our first time to have an appetizer and a pizza. The place was really busy! We were seated within a few minutes, though. We ordered the calamari appetizer. Wow, it was an abundant amount and very good! We also ordered a small pizza. The crust was very good and so were the toppings and sauce. We would definitely recommend going here, just for the sake of the delicious food. However, the service was also outstanding! Our server, Kayla, was so awesome. (I apologize if I got your name wrong!) she had a lot of tables, but, she kept up with them all with a smile on her face! In addition to her great service, we had no less than three other managers stop and ask if everything was ok and chat for a minute or two. They have food runners bringing out the food, so, it’s hot out of the oven! What a fun place! We will definitely be back!“

“Last meal on our trip to FMB was good but not great. Where we were sat was close to the POS terminals and I saw the staff bickering about stuff amongst themselves a couple times which really if it's gonna happen should be out of sight from the guests. The waitress kind of complained about her other tables to us which again is a no-no. The food was exceptional in flavor but crust was a bit soggy in the middle of the pie. I'd definitely come back but I hope the management focuses in their lineups about some steps of service tweaking to make for a more enjoyable guest experience.“

“The pizza is what I came for and it was really good.There was an older gentleman there, about 5’ tall who kept loudly proclaiming that he was a celebrity and my table should buy him Coors but, we ignored him like a Mariachi band and he moved to the next table.Fun place, get the pizza!“

“Pizza is good when we dine in and have it delivered. They have an awesome delivery guy, his name is Jerry. They give you an estimated delivery time but when Jerry is your delivery person, he goes above and beyond by calling you and telling you exactly when he will be there! With two large dogs and/or being in the back lanai, this is appreciated more than I can say. I wish all delivery drivers would give that extra attention to their job!“

“Buster’s was amazing! Alec was so friendly and efficient as our waiter. He made us feel welcome and comfortable. The food was incredible! So incredible that I annoyed my husband the entire meal with expressing how delicious everything was. We got mozzarella sticks for the appetizer and they were the biggest I have ever seen. So good with the marinara. My cuban sandwich was made to perfection. The meats were tender and juicy, the roll was soft and even the mustard delighted my tastebuds. The side of coleslaw was so good, too! Usually I don’t like the coleslaw sides that restaurants make because it’s a side and an afterthought. Buster’s had to be homemade and created with care. The crinkle fries were cooked perfectly. The portions were huge. I was disappointed I couldn’t finish everything, but I have leftovers. I wish we would have tried this gem sooner! Highly recommend and can’t wait to go back!“

“I traveled over 3000 to find the best Italian food in the country! Playing tourist in Cape Coral, a friend and I had an urge for a good, authentic, Italian dinner. We Googled "Italian restaurants near me" and came up with quite a few selections. Looking over the menus on some of them we found them to be quite expensive just for pasta. I found Maria's on my tablet, (as opposed to my partner's phone). It was less than a half mile from where we were staying, and the prices were very reasonable. So off we went. The restaurant is tucked away in a residential area. It is quaint, small and very clean. The staff was wonderful. We ordered our food. I knew mine would take a while to cook as I ordered Linguine with meatballs, so I was not off put when the food did not arrive immediately. But no problem, we were given warm, fresh baked bread cover in melted butter and garlic pieces, and topped with fresh grated parmesan cheese. It was wonderful! We ordered some wine, munched on the bread and talked. Our food arrived and we dug in (but not before I took some pictures of our meals). My partner raved about his ricotta stuffed ravioli. Me, I was blown away by the marinara sauce covering my linguine! Chunk full of garlic and herbs, it was the best marina I have EVER had in a restaurant. The meatballs were scrumptious, and the pasta cooked perfectly. I am glad I live in Washington state, because if I lived in Cape Coral I would eat here every night and get fat as a house! I should also mention that both my partner and I are Italian, so we are quite picky about our pasta and sauces. Maria's did not disappoint. I was only sorry it was our last day in Cape Coral and we could not go back and try other dishes. I can't recommend this restaurant enough. If you love Italian food, you must try Maria's!“

“This is my new favorite pizza place! It is a very cute, clean restaurant and the owner is very nice. Great food and great service. A double win here. I finally found pizza in Florida! They actually use real cheese, not that mushy stuff. They have a butter garlic dipping sauce for the pizza that is amazing! I look forward to going back and trying some of the other things on their menu!“

“This was our first time dining in. My husband popped by one afternoon a couple weeks ago during a shopping trip for a coffee, and came out with a slice of pizza too. We knew we needed stop by for a dine in experience. It was delicious! We ordered a pepperoni pizza and salad (which was bigger than expected), and a coffee on the way out. SO good, all of it - from food to service. Definitely recommend!“

“I have to review this place because im Cuban American from Miami, and I live in Orlando, Fl , and Danny’s packages Cuban pizzas In a pie dish and sends it vacuum sealed to Sedanos for sale $6.99 in Kissimmee, and I swear it is literally so good, the best. I had to thank you for sending some authentic Cuban pizza to sedanos in Kissimmee 10/10 would recommend. I will def make the drive to the new location !“

“Dietary restrictions: I have cauliflower pizza, no sauce ( like cheesy bread and Greek salad). The best un area. My husband does regular pizza with bacon or pepperoni. We are from Boston area and this is best we had here in Fort Myers. We go at least once a week. Patrice is numerous 1“

“(Translated by Google) The restaurant is super, the food is delicious, and the attention is super good, I love going to eat there(Original)Es súper el restaurante,se come riquísimo ,y la atención es súper buena,me encanta ir a comer ahí“

“I've ordered from this location consistently for over 25 years and it's always good! The location is a little difficult to get into but it is a dominos so most people do delivery. Their food is always consistent and the staff is always friendly.“

“Delicious Pizza and subs!!! They had to much so much to choose from so we got a large pizza and 2 subs. The pizza was cooked perfect! The subs were also very delicious. Hot and ready when we got there to pick up. The staff was super friendly. We definitely will be going back to try some of the other items!“

“It’s the same as when I was a kid and now I’m almost 50. It’s pizza lol. I did a pizza challenge for my daughter’s 10th birthday. We got pizza from 3 different places Dominos got first place with the kids. Others got first place with the adults. So in the eye and taste buds of a child you are #1“

“Great view from the covered outside area and the wait staff were all so friendly and attentive. Food not only looked delicious but it was delicious and fresh tasting.We even had a few food restrictions needed and they handled it perfectly!This was a great spot to dine at.“

“Lelulo’s tops my list for the best pizza in Cape Coral for 2 simple reasons: It’s “sweet” tomato sauce and it’s “hot” sausage, either or both available by asking when placing your order.We’d ordered from Lelulo’s for 2 years without knowing these options existed. In 2015 a friend ordered for us all, asking for Sweet Sauce + Hot Sausage toppings. I thought I’d died and gone to heaven after my first bite. However, to this day, Lelulo’s menu doesn’t make these options easy to find. Phone and Wait staff don’t tell you either. Such a big thing, sweet sauce hot sausage? To me, yep!As a native New Yorker who’s traveled far + often for foods I love and those I’ve wanted to experience, it’s been challenging finding grocery stores, delis, restaurants here … could go on regarding this, but won’t here as I’m talkin pizza and Lelulo’s here.Another frustrating issue - as I give Lelulo’s ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ - regards their pizza crust.100% of the time I want my takeout/delivered pizza 50% baked. Aka Half Baked. Can they do it? Yes. Will they? They say they will when you ask. Do they do it? Yes, but in my experience only after returning many orders for not doing it. My online orders are followed up with phone calls about this request. My takeout orders include checking the pie when picking up (getting side eye for appearing paranoid). I’m still, after 10+ years, not sure how that crust will be until I see it.Best pizza in Cape Coral!I enjoy my weekly pizza from Lelulo’s nights!But they don’t come without micromanaging my orders to death.Finally, to Lelulo’s I say: Please keep notes on frequent customers’ preferences. We say thanks via tips, suggesting friends order from you and coming back. Remembering us would be a nice Back Atcha ♥️“

“Ok we have been wanting to try this pizza when visiting the cape from wisconsin but were a little turned off with it being a chain… we finally decided to try it and i have to say, no regrets. The crust is near perfect- crispy and airy- i got mine ‘well done’ with extra sauce which was perfect. Very pleasantly surprised. Will be spreading the good word around wisconsin as we do have one near my local town. Excellent until the last bite. Ate the whole thing myself with zero ragrats.“

“I brought my daughter to this beautiful place and I really loved it. There are various amusements for children and I think it is a good place to bring your child. I was really impressed with the varieties of gadgets and the food part is also exceptional. Thanks I will be back soon“

“We ordered 4 large carryout pizzas. Ready on time and delicious. Not a sit-down restaurant, so I give 3 stars for atmosphere. But be real: you’re in a beautiful place, probably in a gorgeous home/condo. You’re carrying out.I give good and bad reviews as the situation warrants. This place deserves 4-5 stars, easily.“

“First time ordering from here and I live very close by. Ordered two subs which were prepared very quickly. Very plentiful ingredients and the gentleman taking the order was extremely pleasant. We will be return customers and maybe try your pizza next time. Thank you!Parking: Lots of spaces.“

“MARCO'S IS A GREAT PLACE TO EAT PIZZA, MEATBALL GRINDERS MY FAVORITE, SALDS!!! MY KIDS LOVE IT THERE!!! THE BEST THING ABOUT MARCO'S PIZZA IS, THEY WILL SURPRISE YOU WITH A DISCOUNT ON YOUR NEXT MEAL!!! IT HAPPEN AGAIN YESTERDAY!!! I'VE BEEN LIVING IN CAPE CORAL FOR 14 YEARS. MY WIFE AND KIDS EAT AT ALOT OF RESTAURANTS. MARCO'S PIZZA IS THY ONLY RESTAURANT THAT WILL SURPRISE YOU WITH A GREAT DISCOUNT!!! I BELIEVE THEY DO THAT TO APPRECIATE THERE CUSTOMERS!!! THATS WHY WHEN WE WANNA EAT DELIOUS PIZZA WE GO TO MARCOS PIZZA, THEY ARE THE BEST I GIVE THEM A 5 STAR!!!“