41 Best Pizza Restaurants in Fort Myers

“Lombardough's Pizza & Beer is a family-friendly restaurant offering quick and friendly service, with a comfortable outdoor patio and games for kids. The menu boasts a variety of tasty pizzas with high-quality toppings, including vegetarian options and gluten-free crust. Outdoor enthusiasts will enjoy the delicious, light, and flavorful pizzas.“

“Uncle Rico's Pizza Fort Myers is a highly-rated pizza restaurant near the Edison Mall. Customers praise the fresh and flavorful garlic knots, square pizza, and meatball hero. The thin, crisp crust and perfect cheese pull are highlights, with one reviewer noting it's "excellent" even by New York standards. The staff is commended for their hard work and ability to handle busy crowds.“

“Fine Folk Pizza is a local favorite in Fort Myers, known for its amazing pizza, friendly staff, and fun atmosphere. The pizza crust is a standout, and customers love that they can customize their pies with unique combinations. The menu offers a variety of options, including a delicious BBQ chicken pizza and a mouthwatering white pizza. The arugula salad is also a hit, and vegan options like garlic bread are available. With great service from welcoming staff, Fine Folk Pizza is a must-visit for pizza lovers in the area.“

“3 City Pizzeria is a welcoming spot that serves delicious pizzas and offers a friendly atmosphere. The owners, who run the place, make awesome pies. With its impeccable service and mouthwatering options, it's a favorite among locals and visitors. Whether you're looking for a casual dinner or a special night out, 3 City is the perfect choice.“

“Downtown House of Pizza offers the best NY style pizza in SW Florida, worth the 30-minute drive for a slice of their white pie. The place is a little greasy but overall cheap and quick for a meal. Customers are welcomed by attentive staff like Jeremy and Selene, who provide friendly service and even accommodate dietary needs like vegan cheese. The self-service spot in downtown Fort Myers has a cozy square at the back for dining.“

“McGregor Pizza & Deli serves consistently great pizzas and calzones that are always a hit with families. Their Summerlin Supreme is a popular choice, while calzones are a personal favorite. The restaurant offers various vegetarian options, including plant-based cheese. They also serve delicious sandwiches, such as the Chicago Beef, and tasty chicken salad. The staff is great, and customers can join their text club for exclusive specials. The restaurant is kid-friendly and offers plenty of options to suit all tastes.“

“Little Sicily is a restaurant known for its authentic Sicilian cuisine, using high-quality and delicious ingredients. The menu features standout dishes that are hot, tasty, and satisfying. Vegetarian options like Eggplant Parmesan and veggie pizza are highly recommended. The 'rice ball' appetizer is a customer favorite. The staff, including owner Pete, are dedicated to providing excellent service, making it a must-try dining experience.“

“Pizza D-LUX offers a taste of New York in Florida, serving excellent NY-style pizza with well-balanced sauce, generous cheese, and crispy crust. The indoor seating area features a unique law enforcement decor, while one outdoor table is also available. Menu options include plain slices, whole pies, and customizations like mushrooms and black olives. Prices are reasonable, making it a great spot for both lunch and dinner. The staff, including Marybeth, are friendly and attentive, providing a welcoming atmosphere.“

“Vincenzo's Pastaria is a hidden gem offering a delightful dining experience. The casual and calm environment, combined with the friendly staff, creates a welcoming atmosphere. The food is consistently praised, with amazing pizzas, fresh homemade crusts, and delicious blue cheese dressing. Customers highlight the affordable prices and the owner's evident passion, which shines through the high-quality dishes. Whether you're craving pizza or exploring the other entrees, Vincenzo's Pastaria is a must-try destination for an enjoyable and satisfying meal.“

“The McGregor Pizza Company San Carlos offers a delightful dining experience with its delicious pizza and garlic knots. Customers praise the great crust, tasty marinara sauce, and friendly, quick service. The restaurant also offers a variety of weekly specials, including popular calzones. Reviewers, even those with high standards from the Northeast, consider this one of the best pizza places in the area, with the Stromboli being a standout dish. The staff's exceptional service and quick response add to the overall positive experience.“

“Mellow Mushroom Fort Myers offers a rewarding dining experience with a wide variety of pizza topping options, although not ideal for the health-conscious. The menu includes a few healthy entrees, and their mushroom soup and Thai chili wings are delicious. The restaurant features a fun and unique decor, a great craft beer selection, and a clean atmosphere. They also offer gluten-free pizza options, making it a great spot for those with dietary restrictions. With great service, it's a place worth returning to.“

“Blaze Pizza provides exceptional service and delicious food, going above and beyond to ensure a great experience. The staff is helpful, and the communication is top-notch. Whether it's a big event or a casual meal, Blaze Pizza is a great choice for groups, families, and pizza lovers alike, serving high-quality food in a quick and friendly atmosphere.“

“RonDao's Pizzeria & Sports Bar is a great restaurant to enjoy delicious pizza and zucchini fries. The garlic aioli served with the pizza is fabulous. Visitors love the friendly staff and the abundance of TVs to watch sports. One reviewer mentioned it was the best pizza place they have tried in the area, with commendations for the service. Another reviewer highlighted the server Bryan C as very polite, helpful, and accommodating. The free parking adds to the convenience of dining at this highly recommended spot for pizza lovers.“

“Jet's Pizza offers a taste of Sicilian New York pizza with a deep-dish style. The Detroit-style pizza is a must-try, and the specialty pizzas are top-notch. The delivery service goes above and beyond, even making special trips for customers. This location stands out for its dine-in options, comfortable seating, and friendly staff. The only downside is that the pizza may take a bit longer to arrive, but the overall experience is worth the wait. Enjoy the biggest sandwiches and great food at Jet's Pizza.“

“Friend's Pizza in Fort Myers is known for its friendly staff and delicious food. The pizza, including options with onions, peppers, sausage, and ricotta, receives high praise, with the only complaint being a desire for it to be more toasted. The garlic knots are a standout, and the dessert pizzas are a must-try. The restaurant also offers loaded fries, which are a popular choice. Overall, Friend's Pizza is a place where customers enjoy great food and excellent service, making it a recommended spot for anyone visiting the area.“

“Rosati's Pizza is a local favorite for authentic Chicago-style pizza in the area. The thin-crust pizza, made fresh daily with imported ingredients, is praised for its generous cheese topping and delicious sausage. Customers enjoy the classic Chicago-style experience, despite the lack of fancy dining atmosphere. The pizza is cooked to perfection, with the crust remaining crispy underneath the toppings. Whether ordering a half-and-half or a full deep-dish, diners consistently leave satisfied and eager to return for more of Rosati's exceptional pizza.“

“Amore Brick Oven Pizza is a restaurant known for its delicious food and exceptional service. The menu offers a variety of options, from pizzas and mozzarella sticks to mussels and Alfredo pasta. A highlight is the penne ala vodka and the supreme pizza. The owner, who is from Yonkers, adds an authentic Italian touch to the dining experience. Prices are very reasonable, making it a great find for anyone looking for a satisfying meal.“

“Blue Moon Pizza is a popular local restaurant known for its homemade, fresh, and delicious pizza. The portions are just the right size, and customers have the option to build their own pizza. The staff is exceptional, with reviewers praising the excellent service and the team's ability to work well together to take care of customers. The food is highly recommended, with great value for the price. The ambiance is also praised, making it one of the top dining spots in the area. The restaurant is also known for its accommodating nature, catering to dietary restrictions and being kid-friendly, with a play area for children.“

“Cafe Flore is a charming gem in Fort Myers that offers a warm and welcoming atmosphere. The restaurant serves made-to-order food, coffee, and smoothies, including delicious bagel and panini sandwiches, gluten-free crepes and sandwiches, and refreshing smoothies like the popular "green touch". Friendly and polite staff ensure a pleasant dining experience.“

“Bada Bing Pizza Co. is a restaurant that offers a taste of New York in Florida. Known for its delicious pizza and friendly staff, the restaurant also receives praise for its superb garlic knots. The clean and cozy atmosphere, along with affordable options like pizza by the slice, make it a must-visit for both locals and tourists. Highly recommended for those seeking a delightful meal off the beaten path.“

“Mastello Ristorante & Steakhouse offers a high-quality dining experience. The steakhouse serves expertly prepared dishes, including the rigatoni, eggplant lasagna, and veal piccata. The Caesar and arugula salads are fresh and crispy. While the shrimp cocktail sauce may lack flavor, the overall dining experience is enjoyable. The service is excellent, with Karrin providing top-notch attention. The desserts, such as the chocolate lava cake and crème brûlée, are also tasty.“

“Leoni's Pizzeria is a popular spot in Bonita with great prices, offering a variety of options, including nachos with beef, which are highly recommended. Their pizzas are also praised for being delicious and reasonably priced. With a cozy atmosphere, including booths, tables, and outdoor seating, this pizzeria is a great choice for a casual dining experience.“

“Mellow Mushroom Estero offers a delightful dining experience with great food, drinks, and service. The restaurant serves a range of tasty options, including the popular bruschetta and holy shiitake pie pizza. The pizza crust is perfect, and the menu features unique combinations like the Mowie Wowie pizza. The mushroom soup, although currently off the menu, was a crowd favorite. Friendly and attentive staff make it a great spot for a family night out or a romantic date.“

“Grimaldi's Pizzeria offers a variety of pizzas, salads, and calzones, with some pricey starters. The staff is friendly and informative, providing a welcoming atmosphere. Customers enjoy the tasty desserts. The pepperoni & hot honey pizza is recommended, along with the dessert trio. Fresh and delicious food makes it the best pizza spot in Florida, prompting visitors to come back for more.“

“Bellacino's Pizza & Grinders in Ft Myers offers delicious Sicilian pizza and grinders. Customers praise the quality of the Sicilian pizza, mentioning it gets better each time. The meat lovers pizza and teriyaki wings are also recommended. Despite some inconsistencies in food preparation and timing, the friendly and professional staff, like Crystal, make the dining experience enjoyable. The prices are reasonable, making it a great value for the tasty food. While some customers have noticed a decline in quality over the years, the overall consensus is positive, with many looking forward to returning for more grinders and pizza.“

“Palm Beach Pizza offers a welcoming atmosphere, with friendly staff serving hot and delicious pizza. Customers can opt for pickup or delivery, with a simple setting featuring tables and chairs. The restaurant serves high-quality food, with flavorful pizza and fresh ingredients. The chef salad is also a highlight, with great quality meats and ingredients. Some dishes, however, may require improvement, such as the garlic knots, which lacked flavor and came with bland Marinara sauce.“

“BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse is a popular dining destination known for its attentive service and delectable menu offerings. Customers have praised the restaurant's knowledgeable staff, who provide recommendations and cater to dietary needs, including a gluten-sensitive menu with a GF pizookie option. The tri-tip is noted as being particularly tender, while the salted caramel pizookie is a must-try dessert. Overall, BJ's offers a consistently positive dining experience, with customers expressing their intent to return and request specific servers.“

“Poppy's Pizza is a favorite among locals and visitors alike. This pizzeria stands out for its excellent food, atmosphere, and staff. The menu caters to various tastes, including cauliflower pizza with no sauce and regular options with bacon or pepperoni. The thin crust pizzas are made with fresh ingredients, and the Meatlovers is a popular choice. With its personal service and great ambiance, Poppy's Pizza has earned a loyal following, with some customers visiting weekly and others making it a must-stop during their annual visits from afar.“

“The Saucy Meatball serves classic Italian dishes, including spaghetti bolognese and veal Parmesan, in a modern and classy atmosphere. The restaurant's staff, including servers like Luz and Kaitlyn, provide exceptional service, ensuring a pleasant dining experience. With generous portion sizes and quick service, customers leave satisfied and often return for more.“

“O'Leary's Bar & Grill is a welcoming restaurant and bar with a comfortable atmosphere and friendly staff. It offers a variety of delicious comfort food, with the Reuben and fish & chips being standouts. While it may get busy on St. Patrick's Day, the restaurant strives to provide good service and tasty food. Suitable for both small and large groups, it's a great place for those looking for a satisfying dining experience with an Irish touch.“

“Two Meatballs In The Kitchen is a restaurant that offers an excellent dining experience. The food is described as absolutely delicious, with plump and delicious mussels, and very large portions. The service is excellent, with the staff being attentive and accommodating, especially towards children. The restaurant also serves a variety of drinks, including margaritas and dirty martinis.“

“Baked (Formerly Buddyz) serves top-notch pizzas and Italian-inspired dishes with fresh and delicious ingredients. Their calzone and pan pizza are highly recommended, and their thin-sliced Italian beef sandwich is a favorite. The staff is welcoming and friendly, and they accommodate dietary restrictions with gluten-free crust options.“

“Domino's Pizza is a popular spot for quick and delicious meals. Friendly staff go above and beyond to ensure customer satisfaction. Orders are fulfilled promptly, with hot food delivered within 10-15 minutes. The menu offers a range of options, including meat lovers, thin crust with BBQ sauce and pepperoni, and chicken Alfredo. While some dishes may not meet expectations, attentive service and knowledgeable staff make up for any shortcomings. Overall, Domino's Pizza is a reliable choice for a satisfying dinner.“

“Chuck E. Cheese is a restaurant designed for kids, offering a variety of plans and activities. The atmosphere can be loud, potentially making it challenging to hear when ordering. However, children generally enjoy the experience. For parties, the restaurant provides a clean, organized, and pleasant environment. The food is reported to be good, hot, and fresh, with staff ensuring drinks remain refilled. The host and Chuck E. are described as nice, sweet, and adorable, making it an attractive option for children's birthday parties.“

“Michela's Pizzeria, a new addition to the neighborhood since January, has already gained a reputation for its delicious pizza and fresh salads. The menu offers a gluten-free pizza option with a cauliflower crust, appealing to various dietary preferences. The pizzeria has received praise for its excellent service, providing catering for events with dishes such as pizza and Stromboli, highly appreciated by the community. Originating from the North East, a region known for its pizza, one customer expressed satisfaction with the pizza's fresh ingredients, light crisp texture, and overall great taste. Michela's Pizzeria is highly recommended for pizza lovers.“

“Arjona's Cuban Pizza in Cape Coral offers the best Cuban pizza with a perfect taste. The place is really clean with awesome service and delicious pizza and spaghettis. Prices are unbeatable, and it's a favorite spot for authentic Cuban pizza. The staff is very welcoming, making it a great place for family gatherings.“

“Buster's Sports Tavern offers a fun and lively atmosphere with reasonable pricing. The food is excellent, particularly their pizza, which is a customer favorite. The restaurant has great daily specials, including an awesome 1/2 price pizza on Mondays. The staff is friendly and informative, providing a welcoming experience. Despite facing challenges, Buster's remains open, and the community is supportive of the establishment. Overall, Buster's Sports Tavern is a local favorite that offers a great dining and social experience.“

“Capone's Coal Fired Pizza is a one-of-a-kind dining experience. The food is exceptional, with delicious dishes like Pasta and meatballs, and thin, loaded pizzas. The atmosphere is lively and happy, making it a great place to visit. Friendly and professional service, including attentive waitstaff, adds to the overall experience.“

“Hungry Howie's Pizza & Subs is a popular restaurant known for its delicious food and excellent service. The menu offers a wide variety of options, including pizza, salads, and other great dishes. Customers praise the quick service, friendly staff, and clean environment. The restaurant also accommodates vegetarian requests. With reasonable wait times and convenient parking, Hungry Howie's is a go-to spot for a satisfying meal.“

“This is not a sit down restaurant. It is take out or delivery only but if you are hungry for a very good, tasty pizza this is the place to go. I have gone here for years and have never been disappointed. The people are friendly who wait on you as you go in. Hungry for pizza? Try going here.“