49 Best American Restaurants in Fort Myers

“Miller's Ale House offers a lively dining experience with great service and delectable dishes. The BBQ ribs, chicken quesadillas, and zinger mac and cheese are customer favorites, while the new burgers and Captain Jack dessert are also highly recommended. The attentive staff, such as Kelli and Mason, ensure a welcoming atmosphere, whether dining inside or enjoying the patio.“

“Miller's Ale House provides a pleasant dining experience with friendly and attentive servers, including Alainna and Gen. The food is good, although seasoning may vary. The atmosphere is fantastic, and the staff goes the extra mile, even signing a birthday card with a brownie ice cream treat.“

“Harold's is a hidden gem in Fort Myers, offering an exceptional dining experience. From the stellar and knowledgeable table service to the delicious dishes crafted from a well-thought-out menu, this restaurant is a hit with both locals and visitors. The menu features a variety of offerings, including foie gras, falafel, duck, black grouper, and prime rib, all prepared with care and creativity. The elegant atmosphere and well-trained staff create an enjoyable ambiance, making Harold's a must-try for any foodie. Despite its unassuming strip-mall setting, the restaurant provides valet parking and encourages reservations, even during the summer months, to ensure a memorable dining experience.“

“Motor City Coney Island is a clean, comfortable restaurant with great food and wonderful service. Known for their delicious sandwiches and burgers, they also offer classics like Coneys, chili, and grilled chicken wraps. Visitors praise the owner's friendliness and the spotless Michigan-themed interior. A gem for Detroit natives and a must-visit for anyone in Fort Myers, it's a top choice for a tasty meal with a touch of home.“

“Mel's Diner is a retro-style diner with a modern twist, offering a huge menu selection and excellent food. The service is friendly, efficient, and smile-filled, reminiscent of a classic roadside diner from the 50s or 60s. The staff, including the general manager and servers, are personable and welcoming, making guests feel at ease. The diner also features a bar and serves exceptional milkshakes. The ribs are a highlight, with tender meat falling off the bone. Overall, Mel's Diner provides a wonderful dining experience, suitable for families with kids, and is highly recommended.“

“The Roadhouse Cafe offers a delightful dining experience with its cozy, cruise ship-like atmosphere and live jazz music that sets a lovely mood. The menu features a variety of options, catering to different dietary needs, including a beet salad, pork chops, chicken with rice, and scrod, all of which are reported to be delicious. The service is attentive, though it may take some time for the food to arrive. Customers praise the overall presentation and ambiance, creating a romantic and friendly environment, making it a place worth revisiting. The restaurant also has ample parking, making it easily accessible.“

“Ford's Garage Ft. Myers is a unique and fascinating restaurant with a car mechanic theme, showcasing attention to detail and creating an attractive environment. The food is delicious, with excellent burgers and an impressive appetizer selection. The service is exceptional, with friendly and knowledgeable staff, including servers like Denise and Gina, who go above and beyond to ensure a delightful dining experience. With great recommendations and a warm atmosphere, Ford's Garage Ft. Myers stands out among other franchise restaurants in Southwest Florida.“

“Mango Rita's Rhythm House is a vibrant restaurant that offers an exceptional dining and entertainment experience. The staff are praised for their friendliness and attentiveness, ensuring customers feel right at home. The food is consistently delicious, and the drinks are served promptly and cold. The highlight of the evening is often the live music, with the Alter Ego band and Timeline Rock Band creating a lively atmosphere for dancing. Customers appreciate the owners' personal touch, as they make a point to check on everyone and ensure a great experience. With ample free parking available, Mango Rita's Rhythm House is a popular destination for a fun night out.“

“ARTISAN EATERY offers a cozy dining experience with a variety of delicious meals for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. The menu features specials like Elote Hash, Eggs Benedict, and Philly Cheesesteak, along with vegetarian options like Avocado Toast. The warm, freshly made donuts are a must-try. The small restaurant has counter seating, an open kitchen, and a welcoming atmosphere that keeps customers coming back for more.“

“Oasis Restaurant is a hidden gem in downtown Fort Myers with ample parking. The staff is friendly and welcoming, treating guests like family. The menu offers delicious options like ham n Swiss omelette and corned beef Benedict. The service is fantastic, with employees willing to accommodate dietary needs without hesitation. The atmosphere is clean and open, creating a pleasant dining experience. Whether you're a regular or a first-time visitor, Oasis Restaurant promises great food and a warm reception.“

“Cooper's Hawk Winery & Restaurant offers a fun wine tasting experience with fantastic food and service. The atmosphere can be a little crowded and noisy, but overall a great place for a night out. The staff, like Rose, go above and beyond to make special occasions memorable. The food is delicious, with quick service even during less busy times. However, there might be some instances where the service could be improved, like refilling water or checking in after the meal. Despite these minor hiccups, Cooper's Hawk Winery & Restaurant continues to deliver wonderful dining experiences.“

“GatorBites Tail & Ale is a cool little bar spot with live entertainment on certain days. The seafood platter number 3 with mahi, shrimp, and gator was delicious. Happy hour croctails and wonderful service make for a great experience. The "Perfect Burger" with fries and onion rings was very tasty, complemented by delicious cocktails. Hand-pressed burgers with a toasted bun are a highlight, served by an excellent staff. The atmosphere is typical bar style, loud and busy, but the overall experience makes it a must-visit spot.“

“Buddha LIVE is a vibrant spot with a great atmosphere for music lovers. The band plays awesome rock music, including AC/DC hits, making it a perfect place to enjoy drinks and live music. The house band, THE BOOTS, gives stellar performances, blending old and new country tunes that keep the crowd dancing and singing along. Lead singer Kenny Cox's stage presence adds to the fantastic experience that keeps customers coming back for more.“

“Whiskey Creek Station is a hidden gem not to be judged by its exterior. Despite Hurricane Ian's damage, the food is amazing. The prime rib special and chicken fajitas are delicious, and the homemade salted caramel flan is a must-try dessert. The grouper bites are also highly recommended. The service is exceptional, even with a single bartender/server managing multiple tables. The environment is relaxed and affordable, perfect for a quick bite or a full meal. Don't overlook this place for lunch or dinner, the prices are reasonable and the flavors are excellent.“

“Matt's Red Hots offers a delightful dining experience with its wonderful food and friendly staff. The cheeseburger and fries are a hit, while the Chicago dog and fries are also praised. The restaurant has a limited indoor seating, but ample outdoor seating is available unless it's raining. Customers recommend taking the food to go or dining outside to beat the heat.“

“The Cove, located at Sanibel Marriott, offers exceptional service with a friendly and dedicated team, including standout staff members Nick, Kader, and Carl. The spacious and comfortable rooms, along with delicious food and drinks, contribute to a memorable stay. Despite some ongoing repairs from past hurricane damage, the resort maintains cleanliness and offers a pool area that creates a beach-like atmosphere. Guests can enjoy a delightful couples' or family getaway at this resort.“

“The Crystal offers an exceptional dining experience. The restaurant serves a wonderful Thanksgiving meal with attention to detail, a spread of amazing desserts, and a warm atmosphere. The staff is friendly and treats guests like family, going above and beyond to ensure a pleasant experience. The Sunday brunch features excellent food, including a salad bar, prime rib, and custom omelettes, in a beautiful setting with comfortable seating options.“

“Burntwood Tavern offers excellent service from accommodating staff, including Jamie and Ashley, who provide great care to customers. The food is delicious, and the atmosphere is awesome. With a playground for kids to play, it's a great spot for families to dine and enjoy their meals.“

“Burntwood Tavern offers a consistent and reasonably priced menu, with enjoyable additions like live violin music and $8 martinis. The female bartender and server, named Melinda, provide attentive and pleasant service. However, there have been reports of occasional delays in service. Despite this, the restaurant is recommended for a nice evening out.“

“The Standard Restaurant Downtown offers a delightful experience with delicious dishes like veggie lovers, accompanied by refreshing drinks like mimosa and mango mojito. The restaurant features exceptional service, with staff going above and beyond to ensure a fantastic time, including drag karaoke and magic tricks. The friendly and attentive staff make this a favorite spot in town.“

“Fowler Street Grill is a popular spot for delicious breakfast and more. With a large, varied menu, the restaurant serves up amazing dishes, including the highly-recommended breakfast quesadilla. The service is always attentive and friendly, with a hometown feel inside the cozy, low-key space. While the space is small, the clean and well-kept bathrooms are located just outside. With great parking options and a relaxed atmosphere, Fowler Street Grill is a great choice for a satisfying meal.“

“Cristof's on McGregor offers exceptional quality and flavor in a great ambience both inside and outside. The service is friendly, and the atmosphere is quaint with an upscale touch. Guests praise the delicious food choices and excellent drinks like the bloody Mary. Although there might be occasional delays during busy times, the overall dining experience is worth the price for a fine dining experience by the river.“

“Culver’s offers the best hamburgers at reasonable prices, along with frozen yogurt that tastes like creamy ice cream. The staff creates a fun atmosphere, ensuring great service, and food is always hot and fresh. From burgers to cheese curds and fish platters, Culver’s offers a wide variety of delicious options for a satisfying meal.“

“The Blend is a casual breakfast & lunch dining venue in the Shell Point retirement community. A nice menu and friendly prices. Dine in or out on the covered patio to enjoy the lake view. When your order is ready they call out your name...so a bit like Cheers, everyone knows your name.“

“The Hut at the Peace Tropical Gardens offers old Florida charm with spot-on service and a variety of delicious food options. Favorites include the Bread pudding and steak, paired with great Rum drinks and margaritas. With wheelchair accessibility and accommodating dietary restrictions, this restaurant is a must-visit, with reasonable prices and a promise of a great experience.“

“The Helm Club is a charming private club, offering an impressive atmosphere and exceptional service. The restaurant serves delicious food, with highlights including roast beef and pork medallions in a cranberry reduction. The attentive waitstaff and friendly greeters ensure a welcoming experience. The venue is also wheelchair accessible, with handicapped parking spots and accessible facilities. Overall, Helm Club is a great choice for a meeting or social gathering.“

“Our 20 person group had lunch in their small banquet room. Service is always great and the lunch menu has a nice variety for selection. Desserts were also great. Prices and quality highly competitive. Other than a "dry campus", very enjoyable.“

“Culver's offers excellent service and delicious food. Their fish sandwich and dinner are standouts, with flaky, hot, and crispy fish. The restaurant is a lovely place for families and is kid-friendly. Their menu items, such as the thick-cut bacon on the deluxe burger, are hot, fresh, and tasty.“

“Philly Junction offers the best Philly Cheesesteak sandwich, reminiscent of the original ones from Philadelphia. The Steak Bomb sandwich is also highly recommended. The staff is friendly, the food is great, and the atmosphere is welcoming, with Philly-themed decor. Even for those with dietary restrictions, the meals are perfect. Although located a bit far for some, it is considered a hidden treasure in Fort Myers. The place feels like home, and the service is top-notch. It is a family-friendly spot, with a kids menu available. For those craving authentic Philly sandwiches, Philly Junction is a must-visit, with many customers planning to return frequently to enjoy the delicious food and welcoming environment.“

“The Colonial Country Club Restaurant & Sunset Grille offers a fully renovated club and dining area with beautiful grounds. The restaurant provides great staff, delicious food, and enjoyable social events with live entertainment. While some visitors have experienced noisy conditions and service issues, the majority of reviews praise the restaurant's overall quality and the comfortable feeling it provides to the community.“

“This was a great surprise. We didn’t realize it was a senior community but open to the public. My husband wanted breakfast and I wanted a good burger. We were both pleased as our food was cooked to perfection. We were warmly greeted and the place was spotless. Everyone was so nice and friendly as it was obvious we weren’t old enough to live there. They offer a great variety of options including ice cream.“

“Ruby Tuesday is a restaurant known for its extensive salad bar, which is considered one of the best in the area. Despite its potential, the establishment has fallen into disrepair and could benefit from a renovation. The salad bar is available for a fixed price, which can add up with drinks and tips. Staff are friendly and attentive, with some servers going above and beyond to ensure customer satisfaction. The menu offers a variety of options, including fish and chips and chicken tenders, and vegetarian options are also available.“

“Nauti Parrot Oasis is a restaurant with a clean and organized atmosphere, both indoors and outdoors. The staff is friendly, with notable mentions to waiters David and Tyler, who provided excellent service. The menu offers options like the Caribbean Chicken sandwich, which received mixed reviews, and sides like Onion Rings and French Fries, which were well-received. The bar area is large and bustling, and the restaurant has a stage for live music performances, although some events have been known to be cancelled. Despite some issues with food delays and quality, the management has shown a willingness to make amends and provide good customer service. Overall, Nauti Parrot Oasis has potential, but some areas need improvement.“

“The Standard at Page Field Commons offers a mixed experience. While some enjoy the friendly bartender and tasty burgers, others face disappointing service. The seating arrangement can be challenging during busy times, leading to delays in food service. Takeout orders might not meet expectations, with errors and long wait times. Overall, the restaurant seems to struggle with staffing and maintaining consistent service quality.“

“Cracker Barrel Old Country Store is a cozy restaurant that offers a comfortable dining experience. The service is generally good, and the food is delicious, with a wide range of options, including American breakfast served all day. The restaurant is known for its homemade potatoes, grilled chicken, and vegetables. However, some visitors have reported inconsistent service and inconsistent food quality, including undercooked potatoes and a disappointing grilled chicken dish. Despite these issues, the restaurant remains a popular stop for many.“

“Ella Mae's Diner in Fort Myers offers superb quality food at reasonable prices. The staff is attentive, kind, and even accommodating to furry friends with water bowls for dogs. The beautiful water view from the outside seating adds to the dining experience. Specialties like avocado toast, pancakes, and french toast are highly recommended. The diner's historical theme and clean setting make it a nice spot for a meal, despite the slightly higher prices.“

“FK Your Diet Fort Myers is a remarkable restaurant that offers an exceptional dining experience. The food is described as absolutely terrific, with a taste of love and dedication in every bite. The atmosphere is great, and the service is top-notch. The owner, who also happens to be the cook, is super personable and takes the time to chat with customers about the restaurant's outstanding cause or just casual conversation. This restaurant is a must-try, with enormous portions of amazingly yummy food and a heartwarming mission to give back to the community.“

“Not really any option for gluten free at all . Was extremely disappointed in that .. service was just ok....

Parking: Not a lot of spots for being a main pool and housing so many people... And most cars would just park in the golf cart spots ..

Dietary restrictions: They don't really have anything for anyone who has a gluten allergy... Not even french fries.... :/“

“Marti's Family Dining offers a cozy, family-like atmosphere with reasonable prices and portions. The menu features a variety of breakfast items, including popular choices like biscuits and gravy, French toast, and a great cup of coffee. The friendly staff and homestyle cooking make this a local favorite, with regulars praising the quality of the meals. Visitors can expect a welcoming experience and satisfying dining experience at this small but well-liked establishment.“

“Nestled in the heart of Fort Myers, Buckingham Farms offers a truly unique dining experience that celebrates the best of local, farm-fresh cuisine. This charming restaurant grows its own vegetables on-site, ensuring every dish is packed with authentic and nutritious flavors. In addition to its bountiful garden, the establishment sources a wide variety of local produce, supporting the community and guaranteeing quality. Diners can enjoy delicious, freshly prepared meals in a welcoming and relaxed atmosphere that evokes the warmth of a cozy farmhouse. From the delectable Reuben sandwich to the tantalizing pineapple jam, every item on the menu is a testament to the restaurant's commitment to freshness and sustainability. Whether savoring a hearty breakfast or an energizing lunch, guests leave Buckingham Farms feeling satisfied and rejuvenated.“

“Tarpon House is a restaurant located in a Marriott resort, offering holiday buffets and a la carte dining. The restaurant has a great view, with a lot of glass windows offering a beautiful outlook. The menu is interesting, with options such as a charcuterie section and desserts like traditional holiday pies. However, some reviewers have been disappointed with the quality of the food, with some buffet items appearing to be from a freezer to plate. Additionally, reservations can be challenging to secure, with some guests having to call daily for multiple weeks to get a spot. Despite this, the restaurant has a lovely setting and friendly staff.“

“Edison's Lab Restaurant and Bar offers a unique dining experience with a Thomas Edison-inspired atmosphere. The food is served in generous portions, and the sweet tea with refills is a favorite. The bartender is praised for their exceptional mixology skills, creating delicious cocktails. The restaurant also hosts lively events, creating a friendly and welcoming ambiance.“

“The Boardwalk, located on FGCU's campus, offers a nice atmosphere with various seating options, multiple TVs, music, and an outdoor area. While the food may not be exceptional for its price, it serves as a decent option for students after a long day of classes. However, it is recommended to avoid the Boardwalk burger and fries as they are described as extremely greasy, potentially causing discomfort. Wheelchair accessibility is available via a ramp at the main entrance.“

“41 Bistro is a highly acclaimed restaurant in the Estero/San Carlos area, known for its exceptional food and outstanding service. The owner personally visits each table to ensure a wonderful dining experience. The staff, including the friendly and attentive table hostess Rae, are praised for their professionalism and warmth. While the robot server was a unique addition, it did not entirely impress the diners. Overall, 41 Bistro offers a delightful and upscale dining experience that is highly recommended for those in the area.“

“Charley's Cabana Bar offers great service and good food, with a wonderful outdoor seating area where you can watch dolphins while dining. The menu features a juicy burger, conch soup loaded with vegetables, and a well-presented Pesto chicken wrap. For dessert, the chocolate lava cake pairs well with vanilla ice cream. The bar serves strawberry margaritas and offers happy hour specials. While some appetizers may be hit-or-miss, the shrimp cargot is a standout dish. Enjoy the great view and nice atmosphere, but be prepared for resort hotel prices.“

“Farmer's Market Restaurant serves delicious home-style southern cooking at super fair prices. Daily specials and great desserts are available, including vegetarian options like fresh large sides of vegetables and non-meat dishes. Favorites include fried chicken, pulled pork, and ribs, with generous portions leaving room for leftovers. This classic, historic eatery offers a quaint, laid-back atmosphere, reminiscent of traditional Southern restaurants found along back roads.“

“Biggy's Place is a popular restaurant known for its breakfast and lunch options. AC Pros and many other families enjoy dining here 3-4 times a month due to the fresh, delicious, and filling food at reasonable prices. The staff treats customers like family and offers daily specials for breakfast and lunch, as well as homemade soup. The pecan waffle is a favorite among customers. While the restaurant used to play black and white films, creating a unique atmosphere, it has since switched to updated TVs. Despite this change, Biggy's Place remains a definite "Yes Spot" for breakfast.“

“Twin Peaks is a vibrant restaurant that offers an enjoyable dining experience. The atmosphere is described as "awesome," with the food being "amazing," particularly the "best fried pickles" and a perfectly cooked steak. The service is praised as "excellent" with a "great personality" and a "real asset" to the business. Overall, the restaurant provides a pleasant and satisfying visit for guests.“