50 Best Seafood Restaurants in Fort Myers

“Deep Lagoon Seafood and Oyster House is a top-notch restaurant with incredible food and a beautiful sunset view. Valet parking is a must, and reservations are recommended for weekends. The grouper sandwich, fries, artichoke dip, and Crab Rangoon appetizer are all highly recommended. The atmosphere is relaxing and waterfront, perfect for bringing friends and family. The attentive service and Florida-centric menu make it a great neighborhood spot for a delicious meal.“

“Coldwater Oyster Market offers an exceptional dining experience. The staff is incredible, and the food is amazing, with dishes like clams in pepper broth with chorizo and potato, Brussels sprouts, and fish and chips receiving high praise. While service can be hit-or-miss, with some experiencing slow refills and long waits, the restaurant's relaxed atmosphere and great food make it a fantastic spot for a meal with friends or family. With a large parking lot and accommodating staff, Coldwater Oyster Market is a great choice for a memorable dining experience.“

“Peruvian food Ceviches by Divino Fort Myers offers fantastic Peruvian flavors with a modern touch. The ceviche is fresh and close to perfect, a must-try. The crispy cilantro rice with salmon and picarones con helado are also highly recommended. The service is great, especially thanks to Ezekiel, who made the experience even more enjoyable. The restaurant is clean, with quick service, making it a perfect choice for anyone looking to try Peruvian cuisine for the first time.“

“Nestled in the heart of Fort Myers, Izzy's Fish & Oyster is a seafood lover's paradise. The restaurant has recently updated its menu, offering a delectable array of dishes that have impressed diners. From the tantalizing ceviche and succulent oysters to the mouthwatering buffalo shrimp and crispy brussels sprouts, the food at Izzy's is consistently praised for its exceptional quality and flavor. The service at Izzy's is equally impressive, with attentive and knowledgeable staff who go above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience. Customers have raved about the friendly and accommodating servers, as well as the skilled bartenders who craft exquisite cocktails. Whether you're looking for a special night out or a casual dinner with friends, Izzy's Fish & Oyster delivers an unforgettable culinary experience. With its welcoming ambiance, delicious seafood dishes, and top-notch service, it's no wonder this restaurant has become a beloved destination for seafood enthusiasts in the Fort Myers area.“

“Cape Cod Fish Co is a popular spot for fried fish, with reviewers raving about the fish and chips, which are crispy and golden, reminiscent of those found in London. The restaurant also serves delicious crab rangoon deviled eggs and clam chowder soup, bursting with freshness and flavor. The service is top-notch, with attentive and friendly staff, and the prices are reasonable. The outdoor seating area is a bonus, allowing diners to enjoy their meals in the fresh air, and pets are welcome too. Reviewers have praised the seafood, with one calling it the best they've had since moving to the area over 25 years ago.“

“Bonefish Grill offers top-notch service with friendly staff serving in a timely manner. The crab fries make a delightful appetizer, while the scallops over street corn are described as yummy. The bang bang shrimp is a delicious choice, along with perfectly cooked broccoli and tasty shrimp and Mahi Mahi. The coleslaw is particularly noteworthy. The key lime cake is dense and frozen, but overall Bonefish Grill is a consistent, nice-looking restaurant near Fort Myers.“

“Salty Papas Shrimp House offers delicious seafood dishes in a casual setting. The blackened grouper is a standout, and the fried oysters are among the best. The grilled gulf shrimp with cheese grits is also outstanding. With generous portions and great value, it's a great spot for lunch. The laid-back vibe and top-notch service make it a welcoming atmosphere. Whether you're a local or just visiting, Salty Papas Shrimp House is a great choice.“

“Pinchers offers great food and 2 for 1 drinks all day, every day. The restaurant boasts a fantastic atmosphere, overlooking the water, and exceptional staff. Bar staff, including Joy, provide a joyful experience. The menu features delicious options like Fried Grouper sandwiches and Key Lime Pie, while the crab cakes are fresh and amazing. With accommodating service for large parties, Pinchers is a great spot in downtown Fort Myers, offering a wonderful atmosphere on its deck.“

“Shrimp Shack is a popular restaurant known for its great food, excellent service, and pleasant atmosphere. The menu offers delicious dishes, including piping hot entrees and tasty shrimp. The hand-made onion rings are a standout favorite. While some noise from the main road may be audible when dining outside, it doesn't detract from the overall experience. Despite some changes to the signature tartar sauce, the restaurant remains a beloved destination for many, serving a loyal customer base.“

“Bimini Bait Shack is a must-visit spot on Fort Myers Beach, offering fresh seafood and unique drinks like the blue Long Island Ice Tea. The atmosphere is one-of-a-kind with fish swimming under your plate. Enjoy friendly service and delicious meals like the brisket with a great smoky flavor. The view of the water adds to the experience, making it a perfect lunch date location. The aquarium bar adds to the lively and fun atmosphere, making it a place you'll want to visit more than once.“

“Prawnbroker Restaurant and Fish Market offers a delightful dining experience. The early dining menu provides excellent taste, portion sizes, and value. The restaurant has been incredible for over a decade, and the happy hour at the bar is a must-visit, with great drinks and appetizers. The service is exceptional, making it a perfect choice to impress someone or celebrate a special occasion.“

“Mason's Famous Lobster Rolls is a downtown spot in Fort Myers that offers delicious lobster rolls, including the popular Connecticut roll. The potato salad is amazing, and their bisque is flavorful, although some wished for more lobster in it. While parking can be tricky, the overall dining experience is delightful, with the only downside being the absence of wine on the menu.“

“The Clam Bake is a welcoming New England bar in Florida, serving top-notch seafood staples like chowder, seafood platter, and fried clams with bellies. The atmosphere is cozy with Boston sports memorabilia. The seafood is small but sweet and delicious, with generous portions. The broiled haddock is perfectly cooked, and the homemade desserts like the strawberry rhubarb pie are a must-try. Despite occasional service hiccups, the excellent food keeps customers coming back.“

“The Pirate Seafood & Chicken is a restaurant that offers fresh and hot meals, known for its delicious and high-quality catfish, shrimp, and wings. The wings are a popular choice, known to be the best in town with a perfect marinade and breading. The restaurant is a clean and friendly environment, where the staff is outgoing and remembers regular customers. The location, a former Wendy's, may seem unassuming, but it offers a greasy spoon experience with tasty food and good service. The restaurant is located on Fowler St. between Colonial Blvd & Winkler Av. It is a recommended spot for those looking for something new and delicious.“

“Hook Fish & Chicken is a restaurant known for its delicious food and fast, efficient service. The menu offers a wide variety of items, and the restaurant is popular among locals, as evidenced by the constant flow of customers and full drive-thru. The halal wings are a standout, with customers praising their taste and the friendly service they receive from staff members like Ayoub and Mohamed. Customers appreciate the quick and easy customer service and the timely delivery of their orders. Overall, the restaurant is highly recommended for its delicious food and excellent service.“

“Mariscos Jalisco is a seafood lover's paradise, offering an impressive array of fresh and high-quality seafood at competitive prices. The restaurant, located behind a gas station, boasts a cozy seating area with a few tables. The menu features a variety of seafood options, including a delicious ceviche that rivals more expensive establishments. The staff provides exceptional service, and the atmosphere is welcoming and relaxed. Vegetarians and those with dietary restrictions are also well catered for, with a range of gluten-free and organic options available. Overall, Mariscos Jalisco is a must-visit destination for seafood enthusiasts and those seeking great value and quality.“

“Blue Pointe Oyster Bar & Seafood Grill is a hospitable and professionally-run establishment with a tastefully decorated atmosphere. The staff, including waiters and bartenders, are friendly and attentive. The food is delicious, with dishes like crab guacamole, fish tacos, and grouper berry salad receiving high praise. The bread is also amazing, and reservations can be made in advance to ensure a smooth dining experience.“

“LYNQ is a gem in South Fort Myers, offering an elaborate and incredible menu with diverse options to suit any diet and cuisine style. The atmosphere is inviting, and the service is excellent. The food is delicious, with dishes like ribeye, braised beef, and wedge salad with filet perfectly cooked and seasoned.“

“The Lazy Flamingo is an amazing little gem that offers a fantastic seafood dining experience. The service is consistently great, with friendly and attentive staff. The menu features a variety of fresh and delicious options, including perfectly cooked calamari, huge oysters, and tasty mussels. Customers who bring in their own catch can have it expertly prepared, and the prices are very reasonable. While the service can sometimes be slow due to the restaurant's popularity, the food is generally excellent. However, on one recent visit, the Conch Chowder and Grouper Nuggets were disappointing, with the latter tasting frozen and lacking in flavor. Overall, the Lazy Flamingo is a great spot for a simple yet satisfying seafood meal.“

“City Fish in Fort Myers, Florida offers freshly cooked food at very good prices, with a must-have Pangas fish sandwich. It is a hidden gem known to locals. The restaurant is kid-friendly with delicious burgers. The hush puppies and okra are some of the best around. Despite being located in an industrial area, it is wheelchair accessible.“

“Skip One 41 is a seafood restaurant that offers authentic and great seafood dishes. The restaurant is known for its friendly and knowledgeable servers, who are helpful in navigating the menu. The menu features a variety of fresh seafood options, including clam strips and Florida bullnose lobster tails, which are described as "heaven." The restaurant also offers a lemon blueberry pie as a perfect end to the meal. While the atmosphere is not fancy, it is exactly what one would expect from a fish market. The restaurant is a go-to spot for fresh, homemade seafood.“

“King's Crab Sushi Seafood & Steakhouse is a hidden gem offering a delightful combination of steak, seafood, and sushi. The portions are generous and beautifully presented, exceeding expectations. The Lava Drop Roll and hibachi dishes like Steak and Chicken are highly recommended. The homemade ginger dressing and clear soup with mushrooms are fantastic. The King Crab boil is a must-try with delicious sausage. The ambiance is wonderful, staff friendly, and a great selection of spirits, wine, and beer available at reasonable prices. A place worth revisiting for a delightful dining experience.“

“Carrabba's Italian Grill offers an amazing dining experience with outstanding food and wine options, including the Director's Cut menu. The staff, including servers and management, provide exceptional service, accommodating dietary restrictions and ensuring a pleasant atmosphere. With a nice decor and plenty of booths, this restaurant is perfect for groups and individuals alike, guaranteeing a memorable experience that will leave you wanting to return.“

“Best Seafood in the area. Wholesale only.“

“The Silver King Ocean Brasserie offers an impressive dining experience. The menu boasts dishes like tender octopus and super tender lamb, paired with exceptional wine. The chef's attention to detail in seasoning and pairing is notable. The tasting menu is impressive, with fresh vegetables and spot-on flavors, rivaling those of a Michelin-starred restaurant. However, some tables may not offer the best views, despite reservations for special occasions.“

“Doña Juana Guatemalan Restaurant serves authentic and flavorful Guatemalan cuisine, including traditional dishes like fajitas mixto and grilled chicken with plantains, beans, and rice. The restaurant has a good atmosphere, friendly and attentive wait staff, and a large parking lot. It's a must-visit for those craving delicious Latin flavors.“

“Hooked Island Grill is a popular restaurant that offers excellent food and service. It is recommended to make reservations due to its high demand. The restaurant is famous for its Ahi Tuna and the Monster Bloody Mary. The staff, including servers such as Irvin, Nick, Joy, and Hope, are known for their great customer service. The Pow Pow Shrimp Tacos, Lobster/Shrimp Bisque, and Shrimp Wrap are popular menu items. The portions are large, and the food is delicious. The restaurant has a friendly and pleasant ambiance, making it an excellent spot for lunch or dinner. The restaurant's owner, Eric, is often present and takes the time to speak with customers, providing insight into the restaurant's history and future plans. Hooked Island Grill is an excellent find, and it is highly recommended to visit, whether for a casual lunch or a special occasion.“

“The Twisted Crab is a restaurant known for its amazing food and cozy atmosphere, though it can be a bit tricky to locate as it's situated within a mall. The establishment is particularly welcoming to larger groups, with an automatic gratuity added for parties of 6 or more. Customers consistently praise the excellent service and vibrant ambiance.“

“Pinchers is a hidden gem with gorgeous decor and a welcoming owner. The fresh ingredients and homemade sauces make the menu absolutely delicious with generous portions. The black grouper was okay, but the honey spicy shrimp was very good. The coleslaw lacked flavor, but overall, the place is perfect with friendly service from Ashley and Nick. With ample parking available, it's a must-visit spot with a variety of menu items to try again and again.“

“Joe's Crab Shack offers a delightful dining experience. Fresh and hot food is served with excellent service, with orders delivered promptly. The restaurant provides a magnificent view of the boats while guests enjoy their meals. Wheelchair accessibility is also available with a ramp and wide entrances. The menu features tasty options like succulent crab legs and lobster tails, accompanied by refreshing drinks like the TKO. Overall, a wonderful experience that is sure to be repeated.“

“J&C Crab - Juicy Seafood offers a great dining experience with fresh seafood and delicious weekend specials. The restaurant's service is commendable, and the chicken is a notable highlight. While some customers have expressed concerns about the treatment of turtles on the premises, the seafood variety is a strong point. The cooking method, which involves cooking in plastic bags, can result in overcooking, particularly with crawfish. Despite some inconsistencies, the restaurant's seasoning and variety of seafood make it a worthwhile visit.“

“Connors Steak & Seafood offers a great lunch menu with a variety of options, including the popular Chopped Angus served with mashed potatoes and creamed spinach. The house wine is also praised for its quality and affordable price. The restaurant has received positive feedback for its outstanding service and engaging staff. However, a comment was made regarding the Caesar salad dressing and the noise level when seated near large groups. Despite this, Connors Steak & Seafood is recommended for its overall quality and dining experience. It is suggested to mention any seating preferences during reservations.“

“The Roadhouse Cafe offers a delightful dining experience with its cozy, cruise ship-like atmosphere and live jazz music that sets a lovely mood. The menu features a variety of options, catering to different dietary needs, including a beet salad, pork chops, chicken with rice, and scrod, all of which are reported to be delicious. The service is attentive, though it may take some time for the food to arrive. Customers praise the overall presentation and ambiance, creating a romantic and friendly environment, making it a place worth revisiting. The restaurant also has ample parking, making it easily accessible.“

“Mango Rita's Rhythm House is a vibrant restaurant that offers an exceptional dining and entertainment experience. The staff are praised for their friendliness and attentiveness, ensuring customers feel right at home. The food is consistently delicious, and the drinks are served promptly and cold. The highlight of the evening is often the live music, with the Alter Ego band and Timeline Rock Band creating a lively atmosphere for dancing. Customers appreciate the owners' personal touch, as they make a point to check on everyone and ensure a great experience. With ample free parking available, Mango Rita's Rhythm House is a popular destination for a fun night out.“

“The Krab Hut in Cape Coral offers super delicious seafood, with hot and ready food like steam bag specials and calamari appetizers. Despite a minor parking lot incident, the overall experience is fantastic. They provide friendly service and a great atmosphere for families, making it a perfect spot to enjoy a delightful meal. Don't be fooled by the exterior - this place has amazing food that will have you coming back for more.“

“Hibachi House, under new management for about 2 years, offers good food, nice atmosphere, and friendly service. The kitchen is clean and functional, with quick, smiling service. Known for great food, quality, and generous portions, it's a gem with a well-decorated, clean interior. A go-to spot for delicious hibachi plates and rolls.“

“De Adriatico Restaurant offers delightful and authentic dishes, with highly recommended entrees including grilled octopus, bronzino, fresh pasta with goulash, and a special Ossobuco. The saffron risotto is a must-try as an accompaniment. Service, provided by servers like Aldo, is professional, kind, and welcoming. An excellent dining experience for any group size.“

“Courtney's Continental Cuisine is a fantastic restaurant with amazing food and attentive staff. The manager, Betty, is accommodating and the owner ensures a great dining experience. The fish special and bread pudding are highly recommended. Chef Dale creates delicious meals, while Liz and Hollywood are charming bartenders. The atmosphere is quaint and welcoming, making every visit a pleasure. Don't miss out on this wonderful dining experience with a variety of options to suit every taste!“

“Terra Nostra Ristorante is a remarkable dining establishment that offers delicious and exquisite dishes. The restaurant's Lamb Chops, Gnocchi with Brie and Portobello, Snapper with Parmesan Risotto and Raspberry Coulee, and Saffron Shrimp Risotto are among the customer favorites. The Maple Cognac Creme Brulee is a must-try for dessert. The restaurant's Meatball appetizer, made with veal and beef, is also a hit. The staff, including Jason and Scott, provide excellent service, making customers feel welcomed and well taken care of. They are friendly, polite, and accommodating, contributing to an outstanding dining experience. The restaurant's food quality is comparable, if not better, than that of famous dining areas such as Boston's North End and Federal Hill in Providence, R.I. However, a more extensive selection of California white wines would be a welcome addition to the menu. Overall, Terra Nostra Ristorante is an excellent dining destination that offers delicious food and top-notch service.“

“El Acajutla Restaurant is a hidden gem that offers great authentic dishes, with a focus on their delicious pupusas and steak tacos. The atmosphere is chill and friendly, with music adding to the enjoyable ambiance. Despite some inconsistencies in menu pricing, it is not overly expensive. The pupusas are a must-try, being fresh, flavorful, and generously sized. Service is attentive and quick, making it a recommended dining spot in the area.“

“KJ's Steakhouse is a fantastic place with really great food. The hamburger special is a must-try, served with tasty French fries. The steaks are the best around, so good that customers even tipped the cook. The atmosphere is welcoming, with personalized touches like birthday decorations. The service, especially from server Ricky, is top-notch. Whether you're moving or just looking to relax, this is the perfect spot. The Filet Mignon with loaded mashed potatoes is a standout dish, perfectly cooked and delicious. The staff, like Lucas, make the experience memorable and enjoyable, catering even to families with young children. A definite go-to place for a wonderful dining experience.“

“The Lighthouse Restaurant & Bar is a highly recommended spot for a memorable dining experience. The kitchen and staff provide excellent service even during late hours. Standout dishes include potato croquettes, a fresh watermelon margarita, and grilled Mahi served picatta style. The prime rib and Brussel sprouts also received high praise. Although the prime rib could use a bit more flavor, the generous portion of pork belly in the Brussel sprouts was a delightful surprise. The restaurant offers a fun and friendly bar area, comfortable outside seating with a marina view, and easy, free parking.“

“Carrabba's Italian Grill is a popular restaurant known for its delicious food and lively atmosphere. The menu offers a variety of authentic Italian dishes, and the staff is generally attentive and accommodating. However, some customers have reported inconsistent service, with a few instances of rude and unhelpful staff members. Overall, Carrabba's is a reliable choice for a satisfying Italian meal.“

“Bahama Breeze offers a nice selection of food, including delicious Conch Fritters and well-executed main courses, served by friendly and attentive staff. The restaurant's ambiance could use some refreshing, but it remains a good option for a quick lunch or vacation treat, with a kid-friendly environment and wheelchair accessibility.“

“Whiskey Creek Station is a hidden gem not to be judged by its exterior. Despite Hurricane Ian's damage, the food is amazing. The prime rib special and chicken fajitas are delicious, and the homemade salted caramel flan is a must-try dessert. The grouper bites are also highly recommended. The service is exceptional, even with a single bartender/server managing multiple tables. The environment is relaxed and affordable, perfect for a quick bite or a full meal. Don't overlook this place for lunch or dinner, the prices are reasonable and the flavors are excellent.“

“Capt J's is a renowned seafood destination, offering a wide selection of fresh and high-quality seafood options. Known for their exceptional smoked fish and shrimp, the restaurant has gained a loyal following over the years. Whether you're craving fresh-caught shrimp, succulent lobster tails, or a variety of other seafood delights, Capt J's is well worth the visit. With a focus on supporting local businesses, the restaurant provides a great dining experience and excellent value for money. Customers consistently praise the quality and variety of the seafood, making Capt J's a must-visit for any seafood enthusiast.“

“Buster's Sports Tavern offers a fun and lively atmosphere with reasonable pricing. The food is excellent, particularly their pizza, which is a customer favorite. The restaurant has great daily specials, including an awesome 1/2 price pizza on Mondays. The staff is friendly and informative, providing a welcoming experience. Despite facing challenges, Buster's remains open, and the community is supportive of the establishment. Overall, Buster's Sports Tavern is a local favorite that offers a great dining and social experience.“

“Botanas Vuelve A La Vida offers excellent taste and service in a family-friendly environment. Highly recommended dishes include the shrimp cocktail, jar of raw food, and Menudo on Sundays. The friendly service and delicious offerings are worth the visit, with fair prices for the quality of food provided.“

“Oxbow Bar & Grill is a restaurant that offers a pleasant dining experience. It serves a wide range of drinks, including unique cocktails, and has a friendly staff willing to accommodate special requests. The menu features a variety of dishes, including the swordfish pastrami sandwich, which is a generous and delicious option. The restaurant also offers a comfortable atmosphere, with both indoor and outdoor seating options, including a spot by the water. Overall, it's a great spot to try at least once.“

“The Boathouse Tiki Bar & Grill is a hidden gem with an outstanding view, offering a relaxed, upscale atmosphere without being stuffy. The friendly staff provides good service, although occasional lapses in waitstaff training have been noted. The menu features delicious options, including 10/10 crab legs, and a great cheesecake for dessert. Live music adds to the ambiance, and the outdoor pool is an added bonus. With easy parking and a convenient tram service, this river-side spot is perfect for lunch, dinner, or just a beer and a view.“