20 Best American Restaurants near Captiva

The Shipyard Bar & Grill • $$
15951 Captiva Dr, Captiva

Customers` Favorites

Caprese Omelet
Fish Sandwich
Key Lime Pie
Carrot Cake
Shrimp Tacos

“We sat at the bar for 5 minutes before the bar tender, Chasity, even walked by us. She didn't even acknowledge us so my husband waved and said we were new to get some kind of acknowledgement, which she ignored. Once she decided to greet us, she said she was only one person and was very short.
Food was good, but our experience with her ruined our meal. We dine out quite a lot and have never had such a rude server. I hope staff is trained on how customer service should be handled.“

4.2 Good227 Reviews
Old Captiva House Seafood • $$$
15951 Captiva Dr, Captiva

Customers` Favorites

Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail with Classic Cocktail Sauce
Lobster and Crab Crusted Scallops
Prosciutto Wrapped Jumbo Prawns
Pomegranate Glazed Lamb Chops
Orange Mango Glazed Duck
Blackened Snapper
Blue Crab Bisque
Caprese Salad
Key Lime Pie
Carrot Cake

“Everything from food to drinks to ambiance to service was first class. Lovely restaurant, we sat out on the patio and it was a perfect evening. The food was delicious and our server Hannah was very attentive, but not hovering. We certainly will make a point of going there again and a new spot to take visitors that I am certain they will enjoy.“

4.1 Good532 Reviews
Mainstay and Barnacles Bar Seafood • $$
4401 Point House Trail, Captiva

Customers` Favorites

Mainstay Fries
Fish Sandwich
Shrimp Tacos

“Love this place!!!!!! Great food and service , feels like your private island🌴🌴🌴🌴🌴🌴🌴“

3.9 Good266 Reviews
Harborside Bar & Grill • $$$
5400 Plantation Rd, Captiva

Customers` Favorites

Brussels Sprouts

“We were South Seas Resort guests enjoying a date night while our two boys were at Kids Camptiva night out. The food was beyond exceptional as well as the service. Our server, Knox, was amazing with well rounded knowledge on the dishes and his recommendations. And kudos to him for serving us in the heat outside…he didn’t mind a bit and served us with joy. We got the fried Brussel sprouts (so crispy and light) and risotto (rich and flavorful) as the side. My husband had the scrumptious short ribbed ravioli and I had the fresh local snapper with a scampi of seafood from scallops, shrimp and clams - all so light and full of flavor. The atmosphere was a perfect setting for our evening date and followed with a walk on the beach. Knox thought ahead and offered us refreshing ice cold water for the walk. We highly recommended for a low key, romantic evening out—with exceptional service and food all in one place while staying at South Seas!“

3.8 Good144 Reviews
Mango's Bar & Grill Bar & Grill • $$
Bartlett Pkwy, Captiva

Customers` Favorites

Taco Taco Chicken 10 Grouper
Flame Mango's House Nachos
Sierra Nevada Torpedo
Peel and Eat Shrimp
Fresh Baked Pizza
Blue Crab Burrito
Grilled Burrito
Chicken Fingers
Cheeseburger
Fish Tacos

“Love Mango’s and all their people! Captiva Sunrise & Silver King Margaritas are too delicious!“

3.8 Good145 Reviews
Cielo Restaurant American
1244 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel - 10.28 miles

Customers` Favorites

Raspberry White Chocolate Cheesecake
Scallops and Risotto
Octopus Carpaccio
Antarctic Salmon
Grilled Octopus
Chocolate Torte
Calamari Fritti
Seafood Pot Pie
Caprese Salad
Crab Ravioli

“Everything was great!!! Food and service awesome!!“

4.6 Superb120 Reviews
Tarpon Lodge Restaurant American • $$
13771 Waterfront Dr Building 1, Ground Floor, Bokeelia - 9.86 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bronzed Key West Pink Shrimp Seasonal Fruit Feta Cheese Mint & Balsamic Glaze
Blue Crab & Roasted Corn Chowder - Our House Specialty
Gulf Pink Shrimp & Scallop Pappardelle
Coconut Crusted Triple Tail
Crab \u0026 Corn Chowder
Tarpon Lodge House Salad
Deconstructed Bruschetta
Fresh Catch of the Day
Pan Seared Triple Tail
Crab & Corn Chowder

“Spent a wonderful weekend with my husband, staying at the lodge, enjoying the pool and dining on some of the best food in SWFl. Everyone was kind and helpful. Will definitely be back for a peaceful stay.“

4.6 Superb350 Reviews
Tarpon Lodge American • $$$
13771 Waterfront Dr, Bokeelia - 10.33 miles

“Spent a wonderful weekend with my husband, staying at the lodge, enjoying the pool and dining on some of the best food in SWFl. Everyone was kind and helpful. Will definitely be back for a peaceful stay.“

4.6 Superb329 Reviews
American Legion Post 123 American • $
4249 Sanibel Captiva Rd, Sanibel - 6.27 miles

“Great burgers & hot dogs, even better people. Inside now open with great a/c.“

4.8 Superb21 Reviews
Miceli's Restaurant American • $$
3930 Pine Island Rd, Matlacha - 11.46 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Wrapped Scallops
Fried Calamari Fritti
Miceli's Clam Chowder
Stuffed Mushrooms
Brownie Explosion
Seafood Platter
Stuffed Flounder
Coconut Shrimp
Grouper Bites
Fried Shrimp

“The Thanksgiving buffet was absolutely the best! Delicious turkey, prime rib, ham, and all the amazing sides. Every employee who worked that day gave their all, creating a warm, festive atmosphere and making sure everyone felt cared for! Their dedication turned a holiday meal into an unforgettable celebration. We will definitely go back!!!“

4.5 Superb416 Reviews
Froggy's American • $
3620 Stringfellow Rd, St James City - 6.59 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Bites with Sauce of Your Choice
Philly Cheese Steak
Fries or Pond Chips
Fried Chicken Dinner
1 2 lb Cheeseburger
Fried Shrimp Basket
Fried Fish Basket
Chicken Sandwich
Froggy Burger
Tator Tots

“The servers we had last night at Froggy’s were amazing! We showed up on a busy Friday night with a party of 16, no open tables and they opened the patio for us. We had Tiffany and Audi as our servers and I’ve never had such attentive and fast service. Our party even grew 9 additional people and nothing slowed our service. We tried 5 pizzas-each one was awesome. Everything we ate came out quickly and was delicious. Bonus—the live music for the evening was rocking! Highly recommend!“

4.5 Superb102 Reviews
Blue Dog Bar & Grill Bar • $$
4597 Pine Island Rd, Matlacha - 10.42 miles

Customers` Favorites

Jumbo Scallops over Roasted Garlic Scampi Pasta
Mullet Flip Beer Flights Four
Sesame Seared Ahi Tuna Nachos
Mullet Sampler Platter
Homemade Key Lime Pie
Coconut Shrimp Wrap
Clam Strip Platter
Grouper Sandwich
Blackened Mullet
Smoked Fish Dip

“My favorite restaurant - fresh food and wonderful staff.“

4.8 Superb294 Reviews
Doc Ford's Rum Bar & Grille Seafood • $$
2500 Island Inn Rd, Sanibel - 9.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Doc Ford's Original Lime Panko Crusted Fish Sandwich
Hamburger with Onion and Mushrooms and French Fries
Doc Ford's Famous Fish Fingers
Hurricane Allie's Island Punch
Oysters on the Half Shell
Ford's Famous Clam Chowder
Seared Tuna Appetizer
Bayamo Black Bean Dip
Banana Bread Pudding
Peel and Eat Shrimp

“Huge shoutout to the KIND and HONEST TEAM at Doc Fords in Sanibel! 🙌 We’ve been going there for many years and their food is always delicious-one of our favorite spots for a reason. We had dinner there Sunday and a couple of days later I realized my wallet was missing. I called in hoping for the best, and to my surprise (and relief!) they had it safe and sound- with EVERYTHING still inside! So very grateful for people who do the right thing. Thank you for turning a stressful situation into such a positive experience! 💙 Annette Nilio“

4.7 Superb475 Reviews
Yucatan Waterfront Bar and Grill American • $$
4875 Pine Island Rd, Matlacha - 10 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grouper Platter Market Price Fresh Fried Potato Chips
Caribbean Jerk Quesadillas
Toucan Chicken Sandwich
Ahi Tuna Appetizer
Boom Boom Shrimp
Grouper Sandwich
Ahi Tuna Nachos
Grouper Fingers
Fish and Chips
Sol de Pescado

“Great food. Friendly staff. Even better atmosphere!!!! Check it out if you’re in the area.“

4.3 Superb259 Reviews
Sanibel Café Cafe • $
2007 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel - 9.53 miles

Customers` Favorites

Crab Cake Eggs Benedict with Hashbrowns
Egg Hash Browns and Toast
Grilled Parmesan Tomatoes
Piña Colada French Toast
Fresh Spinach Omelette
Breakfast Quesadilla
Sauteed Gator Bites
Coconut French Toast
Biscuits and Gravy
Tside of Pancakes

“This Cafe was so good that we visited it twice during our week on Sanibel Island! The breakfasts were delicious, and the lunch menus were, too! (Breakfast is available all day…to 2 pm!) Everyone from the servers to the cooks to the checkout people were super-friendly. The servings are generous and the tables are unique objects of art, having designs of shells under glass. I also picked up a beautiful handmade pottery mug from a resident artist at the checkout!“

4.7 Superb147 Reviews
Phuzzy's Boat Shack Bar & Grill • $$
3051 Stringfellow Rd, St James City - 6.71 miles

Customers` Favorites

Margaritas & Sangrias on Tap
Coconut Shrimp Tacos
Reasonable Prices
Blackened Grouper
Shrimp Cocktail
Conch Fritters
Fish and Chips
Grouper Tacos
French Fries
Crab Rangoon

“What a great place. The atmosphere was great along with the food and great staff! Highly recommend and will be back!“

4.6 Superb287 Reviews
Blue Giraffe Island Bar and Grill Seafood • $$
2075 Periwinkle Way #14, Sanibel - 9.44 miles

Customers` Favorites

Eggs Benedict

“Our family was excited to eat at one of our favorite Sanibel restaurants. Maryann was our server and she was awesome. It was great to be back and enjoy some delicious food.“

4.5 Superb245 Reviews
Coconuts Bar • $$
2255 W Gulf Dr, Sanibel - 10.01 miles

“Coconuts is back and so good! We have been coming to Casa Ybel for over 25 years. We were so glad to have Coconuts back after the hurricane. The drinks, food and service were great! We loved how they now come around to you at the pool to see if you’d like any food or drink-very convenient! And so nice that they deliver right to you by the pool!“

4.5 Superb10 Reviews
Sweet Melissa's Cafe Cafe • $$$
1625 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel - 9.9 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fish Stew

“Wow! Had never been until last night, although we frequently visit Sanibel. Can’t say enough about the quality of the food. My new all time favorite. A salad with tomatoes, watermelon, mozzarella, roasted pumpkin seed and a great dressing. Smoked tenderloin was a unique and fantastic dish.“

4.2 Good152 Reviews
Thistle Lodge Beachfront Restaurant Seafood • $$$
2255 W Gulf Dr, Sanibel - 10 miles

“Very very nice. Fine dining. Most certainly will return.“

3.8 Good98 Reviews

You May Also Like