50 Best Italian Restaurants near Oldsmar

“Review: Casa Cosenza - Oldsmar, FL Casa Cosenza – Oldsmar has become my go-to Italian restaurant, and each visit is nothing short of a culinary journey through the diverse flavors of Italy. From the moment you step through the door, the warm ambiance and friendly staff make you feel like you've been transported to the heart of Italy. The owner is what I call fresh off the boat, and many of his staff reflect the flavor and ambiance you would expect in Italy The menu offers a delightful array of authentic Italian dishes that cater to all tastes, and all the pasta is made in house! Michael Glinter has traveled to 68 countries and 36 states to get the flavor of some amazing foods. His view on reviews is simple – Taste, Presentation, and Service. He believes it's important to tell the reader both a positive and negative unbiased look at the restaurant. Let's take a look and see how Casa Consenza scored in these 3 categories. Taste and Presentation We started with a special appetizer for the night which was a Homemade Tortellini stuff with Italian cheese and white truffle in a white cream sauce. Then for entrees we had Filetto al Barolo a 8oz Filet Mignon in red wine sauce, served with mushrooms, vegetables, and house potatoes, and the night special which was a Branzino filet with mussels and clams topped with a red sauce. The filet was cooked to absolute perfection, the Barolo wine reduction is a symphony of flavors and truly complemented the meat, The presentation was equally impressive, with an artful arrangement that highlighted the dish's elegance and with a side of perfectly cooked mushrooms, zucchini, and potatoes. and a choice of potato accompaniment The Branzino was a true celebration of the sea, a dish that impeccably combines freshness, flavor, and culinary artistry. It was grilled to perfection, showcasing the pristine quality of the fish. Each forkful revealed a subtle sweetness that spoke of the sea, and the expert seasoning allowed the natural flavors to shine. The inclusion of mussels and clams added a dynamic layer to the dish. The shellfish were impeccably cooked, tender and brimming with the essence of the ocean. The savory broth, infused with garlic, white wine, and herbs, was a symphony of complementary flavors that elevated the entire dish to a new level of indulgence. The presentation was a work of art, with the vibrant colors of the seafood and the aromatic broth creating an enticing visual appeal. The dish was accompanied by a medley of seasonal vegetables, adding a refreshing balance to the richness of the seafood. Service What can I say. Max. Dear Max. He was amazing. He exhibited a genuine passion for the cuisine, providing insightful descriptions of each dish and its preparation. His enthusiasm not only enhanced our dining experience but also reflected a true dedication to the art of hospitality. He was constantly attentive to our table, always asking us how things were doing, tasting, and making sure we were well taken care of. I observed him around the restaurant and his passion for people and really creating an amazing guest experience was top notch. The Italian décor, soft lighting, and the piano truly created an intimate atmosphere, making it an ideal spot for a romantic dinner or a celebration with friends and family. In conclusion, Casa Cosenza is a gem among Italian restaurants. The dedication to authenticity, the quality of ingredients, and the overall dining experience make it a must-visit for anyone craving a taste of Italy in the heart of Tampa Bay. Every visit has always been a celebration of the rich culinary heritage that Italy has to offer. Buon Appetito! If you do go to visit and Max is working, tell him “Uncle Mike” sent you there and he will make sure you have an unbelievable experience.“

“From the moment we walked into Mandolzas Italian Kitchen, we were greeted with a warm smile and genuine hospitality. The restaurant was spotless, with an inviting atmosphere that made us feel instantly comfortable. The staff was incredibly friendly, and ordering was an absolute breeze with their full menu of mouthwatering options. Portions were perfect. Satisfying without being over the top and the service was impressively efficient. Plates were served and cleared so quickly without ever feeling rushed. I loved the thoughtful touches, like the to-go station for leftovers and to-go cups for drinks. A huge thank you to Jessica, the manager, for the wonderful conversation and the sweet surprise of dessert. The food was absolutely delicious, and then there’s dessert… oh my goodness! From the beautiful selection of gelato to the tempting baked goods, it was impossible to resist. We left with full bellies, happy hearts, and the excitement of knowing we’ll definitely be back soon. Thank you, Mandolzas, for an incredible dining experience!“

“I had a great experience with Colton! He was friendly, professional, and went above and beyond to make sure everything was taken care of. He answered all of my questions, was attentive to my needs, and made the entire experience great and I will definitely return. Request Colton if u can.“

“We picked up our first pizza from Rosati’s last night and it was amazing ! We did double crust and it did not disappoint. Crust was amazing & toppings fresh. This will be our new favorite pizza spot !“

“Love the folks who work there, and the pies are always great. That said....don't get rid of the chicken waffle pizza!! Something different and amazing. We added honey and it just bumped it up a level. Great job staff/friends. See you soon!“

“I used to go to hungry Howie's and thank God and Marco's Pizza moved close to me. If I were the CEO I will put a Marco's Pizza within the vicinity of the hungry Howie's and take them out of the market because you guys' Pizza it's way better. The service is way better and are hands down the best!“

“Great food! All of the staff were super friendly — specifically Jose! Highly recommend the pizza.“

“This restaurant is like a scene out of Moonstruck. Great Italian cuisine and the desserts were so yummy. Chef Masse came and sat with us. It was a nice personal touch. I would definitely go back. Thanks for the wonderful experience. Carrie“

“Love the wine dinners each month!!!!!“

“When is your next monthly dinner special. My wife and I enjoy your monthly $50.00 each full course dinner special. Please let us know the next date.“

“we were driving by this pizzeria frequently and never stopped in. we finally did last night and were pleasantly surprised at the quality and taste of the pies. highly recommended to all. nice young couple from Long island trying to get established. we are recommending this place to all. it was delicious and super fresh ingredients...“

“We celebrated my daughter birthday with a great meal. The staff made it so special for her. The owner and the Chef are amazing and food is fantastic.“

“omg delicious and owner Anthony was so kind and wanted us to try his pizzs.. so yummy. we actually had dinners which were beyond delicious. you need to go and try ..“

“We love sitting upstairs and listening to the live music.“

“Excellent food with great service and a lovely atmosphere! Highly recommend the lobster ravioli! The Dolce Vita cocktail was lovely, too. Everything was absolutely perfect. We’ll be back!“

“I don’t see what some of the low ratings are all about, Order from here all the time and all the pizza is so good, even his calzones, if your from NY then this place is the closet thing to NY pizza the owner told me he is also from NJ, not only is the pizza good like from NY but the establishment is clean too!“

“The pizza is phenominal. they put on more toppings than any other pizzeria..“

“Delicious Homemade Food, Outstanding Service. Never a disappointment here!“

“First time at this shop today, picked up some ravioli and meatballs for dinner, some olive oil, and chestnuts. The ravioli and meatballs were so delicious. We will be back. Sal, you’re a darling! Thanks again.“

“That’s what I’m talking about!!! Great food! What a great menu!!! Looking forward to many great meals to come. Town and Country needed a legit Pizza spot and Tomato Joe’s delivers!!! 🙌🏼“

“Stopped in yesterday on the way home. First time there. Everyone was very friendly. The food was amazing. We had the white pizza and a pepperoni pizza. Both were very delicious. My wife is from Chicago, she definitely said it reminded her of home. It has been difficult for her to find a good place even after being here for 14 years, she believes she has finally found her pizza home.“

“Always great service and awesome food! Don’t forget to get a brownie 😃“

“Went here last night, the food was so so good. Will be returning!! Kind of sad I live so far because I’d love to come back more often lol was very cozy and everyone was very nice.“

“Incredibly average, not disappointed, just not overwhelmed either.“

“If you love Italian food that is delicious and wonderful staff taking care of you while you enjoy a peaceful meal , then I highly recommend this lovely heaven sent place 😃“

“Great food, clean restaurant and wonderful service

We had a really great experience at Olive Garden. The restaurant was very clean, cozy, and had such a pleasant atmosphere.

The food was delicious, fresh, and exactly what we wanted for a nice family meal. The service was excellent — our server was very friendly, attentive, and made sure we had everything we needed.

Everything was comfortable and enjoyable from start to finish. We had a wonderful time and will definitely come back again!“

“Delisioso! From our wonderful and attentive server, Gabriella, to all 4 of our mains and apps which were so authentically delicious, it was quite the night out We will be back!“

“Brandon is my server and has been providing the best service I've had at a restaurant in YEARS! Cocktails.. ON POINT!
Soup.. ON POINT!
Pasta.. ON POINT!
Brandon's customer service... ON FIRE 🔥
The food came out at a perfect pace.
Best experience I've had anywhere in so long ❤️
🤌🤌🤌“

“The food and service were excellent! Everyone was very friendly! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“This is a 'where the locals' go spot. Located just outside of downtown Dunedin still in the golf cart zone. If you want authentic, good Italian you don't want to miss this spot!“

“Just like the good old days! Everyone is friendly and the food is amazingly good. Stop by and check out the local's hangout and have a draft beer while watching the Rays game.“

“Pizzas, pastas, croquetas, empanadas, flan, el tiramisú la comída todo está delicioso“

“I Love these two wonderful people! My husband and I would go to their restaurant for years and I’m thrilled they have their catering business! Food is authentic and the very best fresh ingredients!“

“I was so very happy after Madison came to Dunedin. I have been eating at Madison for years now and everything I have eaten there has been outstanding. on 11/29/25 we ordered two pizzas for delivery and the total with tip was 70 plus dollars and that's ok for a great product but, it wasn't, the pizza was dry from little sauce and the lite amount cheese on the pizza, but that can happen by mistake. It's now the next day Sunday11/30/25 and getting ready for Bucs football and time to order food so I'm thinking i will order Madison pizza again to fill the craving for a great Madison pizza that didn't get filled by the pizza I had the night before and to confirm that it was just one time thing. I ordered my pizza and picked it up and came home and started eating it right away so it would be hot and fresh and to my disappoint the pizza is the same as last night, dry and little cheese. I'm going to try it again next week and give it another chance and then come back and edit this review and hopefully have a more positive review. I will still continue to eat the many other Great items on the menu and would encourage anyone reading this review to go and try this place out because over all its a great place to eat with a great atmosphere and very clean.“

“Great restaurant. Not like a chain at all. Fantastic staff too!!“

“It’s tough to defeat Olive Garden for a quick easy dinner. I like to sit at the bar. Allison is friendly and attentive. Got salad, soup, bottle of wine, and a to go order. The Calabrian steak and shrimp bucatini was surprisingly excellent. The chicken Parmesan Alfredo was excellent, as was the soup and salad. Breadsticks as always are incredibly delicious, and they’re even better if you get a side of Alfredo sauce to dip them in.“

“Awesome New York Style Pizza“

“Good food, good service, good prices, nice atmosphere. It's all good!“

“Love the atmosphere because when I walked in, I could just start signing and my order be understood in my language! Was at the restaurant for about an hour, we saw several hearing people coming in and they obviously are repeat customers because they knew what they wanted. The wonderful part of our visit today - we were able to chat with Kelly and learn some interesting information about being a business owner. Will be sharing about this place as want to support our Deaf ecosystem! Thank you Kelly for your time chatting with us. I am glad I saw the promotion on Instagram so we could visit as well! Thank you David from Signs of Good Food for sharing this place.“

“Untouchables Pasta & Pizza provides my family with A+ service. Everyone there is very friendly and the food is amazing. Best in the area in my opinion Highly recommend“

“I found a diamond here! Excellent authinic NY style pizza and knots from what I experienced! Pricing was well worth it and the lunch specials alone could draw you in. Also, they looked to have a wide variety of homemade Italian dishes available made to order. They have slices for in and out service or tables for you to enjoy right in house.“

“I would like to thank Olti and Wanda at Bro's Pizza for helping make the food at our Non-profit fundraiser a wonderful success. Between them both, they helped us to select great items and pizza 🍕 toppings that would work to serve our crowd. The pizza was plentiful and delicious. Upon pick-up, the 20" pizzas were hot and ready. We really appreciate the quality of the food and how attentive the owner, Olti and Wanda were to the smallest of details for us. I would not hesitate to use Bro's Pizza for my next event. They were such a pleasure to work with and the food was beyond delicious. Thank you once again. Carol (Cari) Heald S.E. Representative for Pulling For Veterans PTSD Awareness“

“Maria is great!! Service is quick with a smile. Great food awesome specials. Pizza is great and I love the lasagna and salad. Will be back to try some other things soon.“

“beautiful atmosphere, barely felt like a franchise establishment. very welcoming and warm. our server River was very attentive, sweet, and helpful. five star customer service. prices weren’t outrageous and food was delicious. we will be returning!“

“great place good atmosphere“

“Brought my crew in after catering a large group close by for dinner last night. Huge difference from our visit a few years ago. Our server Susan did a great job considering how busy they were. Food was great! One of the owners brought us our drinks, and was very personable- thanks Howie! He was also pitching in doing everything from greeting diners to helping bus tables. Pretty awesome, something I rarely ever see. Old school Italian, cool fish tank- great experience thank you!“

“The Food and beer selection dont miss, along with the ole FL small town feel“

“Legit af!!!! Definitely in my top 3!!“