7 Best Bakeries near Orange Park

The Lab Bakery & Coffee Bar Bakery • $
Wells Crossing, 1580 Wells Rd STE 7, Orange Park

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Raspberry Gourmet Brownies
Peanut Butter Chocolate Cake
Rum Balls and Fudge Squares
Caramel Frozen Latte
Mocha Frozen Latte
Coconut Raspberry
Cherry Vanilla
Cookie Brownie
Bread Pudding
Gift Basket

“Easily one of the best coffee and bakery spots in the Orange Park and Jacksonville area.

Rummies Yummies Bakery & Coffee Bar is a local favorite that deserves way more attention. The space is bright, tropical, and spotless with big windows, colorful décor, and a clean, modern layout. It’s larger than most local cafés, with two cozy lounge areas featuring leather couches for groups and plenty of tables for relaxing, studying, or working using the free WiFi.

Everything is made fresh in their full commercial kitchen, and you can taste the difference. Their signature rum cakes are incredible, available by the slice, full cake, or custom order. They also serve cheesecakes, cookies, milkshakes, sundaes, and boozy desserts. The coffee bar is top-tier with a modern espresso machine, nitro cold brew, and all the milk options including oat, almond, and coconut.

The owner runs the shop herself along with several other employees, which keeps the quality and service consistently excellent. It’s the perfect blend of local charm and professional polish. If you’re anywhere near Orange Park or Jacksonville, this place is a must-visit for coffee and desserts.“

4.7 Superb80 Reviews
Avila Bakery & Cafe Venezuelan • $
922 Blanding Blvd unit 4, Orange Park

Customers` Favorites

Cachapas Demasiado Buenas Y Rellenas de Mucho Queso Y Jamon
Empanada Pabellon Pollo Chicken
Sweet Bomba Filled with Cream
Arepa with Shredded Beef
Sandwich De Pernil
California Burrito
Especial Cachapas
Empanada De Carne
Cachito with Ham
Pastelito Andino

“Tried the sampler and some Dulce de leche pastries. Everything was delicious.“

4.8 Superb197 Reviews
Tough Guys Cookies and Sweets Caterers • $
518 Hollyberry Ln Suite 104, Orange Park

Customers` Favorites

Cookie & Scoop of Ice Cream w 1 Topping
Strawberry
Half Dozen
One Dozen

“Amazing cookies! A little crunch on the outside but soft and chewy on the inside, i love it!! 10/10 recommend!“

4.5 Superb108 Reviews
Habana Mariel cuban bakery Bakery • $
195 Blanding Blvd Suite 6, Orange Park

“I come here two to three times a month since they opened the Fleming Island location. The food is fantastic every time and our server is kind and gracious. I love this place and bring everyone I can to enjoy the wonderful food!!“

4.5 Superb66 Reviews
N' Sweet Delights Cake Decorating Supplies and Classes Bakery • $
1279 Kingsley Ave Suite 120, Orange Park

Customers` Favorites

NY Style Cookie
Bottled Water
Birthday Cake
Red Velvet
Cheesecake
Malta

“My mom and I had the pleasure of stopping by N’ Sweet Delights today and WOW! As true Boricuas we were so unbelievably blown away by how incredibly delicious every item we tried was! You can tell the owner/baker has taken the time to perfect each baked good. We will definitely be coming again and recommend her to everyone. AMAZING!“

4.5 Superb38 Reviews
Rummies & Yummies, LLC. Bakery • $
1580 Wells Rd Unit 8, Orange Park

Customers` Favorites

Caramel Frozen Latte
Pound Cake
Iced Latte
Rum Balls
Cupcakes
Brownies
Cookies
Carrot

“SO MANY AMAZING CHOICES!!!! CINN ROLL CAKE IS A MUST!!!! Different cheesecake flavors, different rum cake and rum balls, and flavorful cakes. The Cookie Brownie is so DELICIOUS. The desserts fill the container, so today should be your cheat day. ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️🍰🥮🥧“

4.3 Superb30 Reviews
Great American Cookies Bakery • $
1910 Wells Rd, Orange Park

Customers` Favorites

16 Cookie Cake Covered in Icing

“Great customer service. I’m blown away. We use them for all our birthday parties and every year I’m more impressed. Delicious cookie. Creative designs with attention to detail. Very reasonably priced. They saved the day! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

3.4 Good17 Reviews

Taste More In Orange Park