13 Best Bakeries near Saint Simons Island

“The food is delicious, the environment is unique and the staff is amazing!! The moment you walk in the door you are hit with the aroma of fresh baked goods. It was so nice to see all the Christmas decorations and music playing in the background. It’s apparent this is a hot spot for the locals, as the staff knew 99% of the folks walking through the door by first name, you don’t see that often nowadays. 100% recommendation.“

“Absolutely the best cupcakes and sandwich cookies I've ever had! We can't go to St. Simon's Island without going to SmallCakes. The cupcakes are so moist and flavorable. The minis are a perfect bite size. I tried the snickerdoodle sandwich cookie and it was the size of my hand; so so good, I couldn't stop eating it. Lol This place is WELL Worth the money. I promise you won't be disappointed. They also have brownies & ice cream which I'll be trying on my next visit. They even offer pupcakes for your furry friend. The service was awesome. I didn't catch her name but she was so polite and sweet. I recommend the mini cupcakes and sandwich cookies.“

“Not BS, these CRAPES are the BEST! If you are a fan of crapes, I recommend it to everyone who visited the island, if not, you must try!“

“The absolute best bacon egg and cheese muffin and you MUST try the pork poppers- melt in your mouth! No lattes or crossiants here but the chocolate chip muffin was also delicious and the sweetest lady checked us out and realized we weren’t local and got us some of the poppers to try“

“Thank you SO much for the wonderful food, delicious wedding cake, cupcakes and service you provided for our wedding at Villas by the Sea, Jekyll Island on Saturday 25th June. Because we came over from England, we didn’t have the opportunity for a tasting session and decided to trust the reviews - we’re so glad we did as everything was perfect and exceeded our expectations. We are especially grateful to the chef and serving staff for their outstanding service. - Sophie & Kerry“

“Worth every penny out of 50 flavors so far I've tried one disliked (not hated) one

Dietary restrictions: Milk, sugar and peanuts are definitely used

Parking: In small plaza but descent parking

Kid-friendliness: Glass windows and open floor plan allows kids to watch the start to finish cookies section by section.“

“Greatly service and Great red velvet cake and other items. Great job Sugarbakers!! Will definitely be back!“

“Any and all occasions! Never disappoint!!!! the have even bailed me out at the last minute more times than I deserve, still smiling! God bless them with many more years in His sevice and this community“

“The crab cakes did not disappoint. My husband is from Annapolis and is very picky about crab cakes. Linda's were exceptional. Can't wait to have some of Brunswick stew.“

“Truly the best sandwich shop in the golden isles. I was staying on Jekyll island and wanted a sandwich to eat on the beach no found this shop and let me tell you it did not disappoint. Truly one of the best sandwiches I have ever eaten. The people are very nice and the sandwiches came out very quick. Do yourself a favor and go here!!“

“Ms. Betty made a birthday cake for my husband surprise birthday party. She was so wonderful and professional as I described to her the type of cake that I wanted. Ms. Betty delivered the cake on time and set it up for us. The cake was not only beautiful to look at but so delicate and tasty. I highly recommend her and will always refer to her for any special occasions or events. Her professionalism and quality are unmatched!“

“Our wedding rehearsal and wedding reception food was amazing! Mrs. Becky was quick to respond and worked out a perfect menu for us. Our guests raved about how good the food was. Highly recommend!“