Goodfella's Pizzeria

$$ • Italian, Pizza, Sandwich Shops

11873 E Colonial Dr, Orlando
(407) 658-6615


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Goodfella's Pizzeria

I ordered my pizza at 5:30. Called at 7:45 for an update as 2 hours had already passed. Was told they “got backed up with deliveries and my order was just then going into the oven” at the time I called and that I would receive pizza within 30 minutes. It now 8:30pm, 15 minutes past 30 minute quote so I called again. This time was told it would be there within and 15-20 more minutes and got an extreme attitude from person answering phone. She then proceeded to hang up on full review
Ordered my food for pick up and got to the restaurant and our food was not ready. Girl at the register just let me stand there while looking for our food, then they decide to make the sub without even saying a word to me. I had to ask her what was going on, all the while my calzone just sitting on the counter getting cold,, got home and my food was cold and the meatball sandwich was a mess, worst customer service I got without even a freaking thank you or sorry for the full review

Had a slice of pizza which is all I can vouch for. But you can taste the freshness of the ingredients, and it's true to New York style pizza. Which for the price is more than acceptable, 2.67 for a plain slice after taxes, 12 for a large 16 inch pizza. Will be going here more often, will update if needed.

More Reviews(253)


Monday Closed
Tuesday 11AM - 9PM
Wednesday 11AM - 9PM
Thursday 11AM - 9PM
Friday 11AM - 9PM
Saturday 11AM - 9PM
Sunday 11AM - 9PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.