11 Best Steakhouses in Sarasota

“Food was superb. with the dessert being a surprize. Coming from Texas I am highly critical of place. The service was quick and effecient, and also knowledgable of the menu. Food was tremendous, from appetizer to entree. Desert was a surprise, with just the final touch of sweet. Only negstive was the condition of the restroom.“

“We hadn't been to a Longhorn Steakhouse for a long time and were pleasantly surprised with our experience at this one in Sarasota. It is busy but has a nice ambiance, excellent food, and excellent service. Ariel, our waitress, did a fine job. The steaks were cooked as ordered. Entrees came with salads and a side. The Filet and Lobster Tail with sides of Mac and Cheese, the Filet with salad and a sweet potato, and the Salmon and Shrimp with salad and a side of Brussel sprouts were all delicious. I would not hesitate to return.“

“I was very disappointed in my experience at Capital Grille tonight. It has for many years been a favorite of mine and my family for special occasions, family dinners, etc. For work I often bring staff and colleagues to Capital Grille because the food is consistent, service is great, and it's usually a great overall experience. Tonight I brought my mother to honor my father on the anniversary of his death just a year ago... Our meal and the service was fantastic. Unfortunately, at a table adjacent to us two guests were obnoxiously loud and several staff (waiters, manager, etc) were standing by them at the table conversing loudly nearly our entire meal. It was so loud it was difficult to talk, it was distracting, and frankly it ruined the evening altogether. I think the thing I found the most upsetting and off putting was the manager came over and asked how our meal was... and I shared with her very candidly how whatever was going on with the other table affected our experience and her response left me furious. When I mentioned what we had experienced she said “Oh, they are very discriminating guests who frequently visit and eat at Capital Grilles all over”. I even explained why we were at the restaurant (as a family honoring my dad) and she said something to the effect that we will have to make a note to sit them in another area. No attempt to show any real compassion or care for our experience. I've got news for you.... I spend THOUSANDS at your restaurant all over the country, and have frequently visited the Sarasota location and you treated us as though the two incredibly self important guests took president over our satisfaction. Though I wouldn't have accepted it, no concession was offered to do anything to account for our experience. I will say that our waitress was fantastic and the food was delicious as usual, unfortunately the entire experience with the other guests and the lack of actual give a damn from the manager left me irritated and speechless.“

“My husband and I just stopped in on our way home from Alabama and we were absolutely blown away by the food here! My husband’s steak could be cut with a fork it was so tender! Definitely looking forward to stopping in on our next road trip!“

“First time here and in a date..Started with the Calamari and it was the best I have tried. I got T Bone Steak and it was good but not the best I have ever eaten and for $68 it should of been and really and come on Ruth Chris can you not afford bigger plates?“

“This was our first visit. I say first because we will definitely be returning. What a great experience. We went on a random Tuesday, so I knew it wasn’t going to be terribly busy (off season bonus!) Amelia, our server, was so friendly and knowledgeable-and just the right amount of attentive. Gave some good recommendations and both our selections were excellent. Steak was done exactly as requested and was, as my husband puts it… like butter. Au just was off the hook. Basically, if you are looking for a casual place to enjoy a really good steak (or anything on their menu), this place is it. Oh and we also visited their butcher counter and brought some of their selections home with us.“

“We celebrated our 41st anniversary here last night and we were thoroughly impressed. First of all the dining room is beautiful, the staff was amazing and we were served by the manager and general manager. The table was nicely decorated with a card signed by the entire staff and rose pedals were so beautiful spread across the table. The food was delicious and prepared perfectly. From the lobster escargot appetizer to the dry aged ribeye to the huge sides of pancetta corn and Gruyère au gratin potatoes everything was on point. Best steak we have had in our 41 years and best service as well. Forget other steakhouses and come to Hyde Park.“

“We stopped in an hour before closing time this past Sunday after flying in from New York. Ester took care of us and made the experience even better. She made us feel welcomed and didn't rush our stay.

Our food came out within 10 minutes and everything was delicious as expected.“

“Jillian is an amazing waitress, who is very attentive and made the meal an enjoyable experience. The food was incredible as always and I would highly recommend stopping in here for lunch or dinner. If you have a chance to have Julian as a server, you’re in for a treat.“

“We celebrated 2 people's birthday here. When we arrived there was happy birthday confetti all over the table which was super cute! Our servers were wonderful, very informative about the menu and offered their favorite dish choices. They kept our bread and drinks filled. The dishes we ordered were all amazing! We had everything from steaks to sea food and no one complained about a thing! Definitely will be back!“

“Wonderful service and delicious food Friday night. Table of 7. It was perfect.“