11 Best American Restaurants near Summerland Key

“New nighttime menu if beyond fabulous. Open Thursday,Friday, Saturday until 7:30 pm“

“Very friendly service. Indoor and outdoor seating available. Full bar available. I ordered their fried fresh catch of the day basket. The fish was triple fin, and it came with fries. Delicious. My husband ordered their Cuban Rueben, and said it was outstanding and unique.“

“Family owned & operated Great service & food“

“Was a cute little spot with a different flare on American island food. We brought our fresh caught lobster in to have with our breakfast and they were willing to cook them for us. Although we weren’t impressed with the way our lobster turned out, oddly squishy with a sour flavor. We will absolutely come back to enjoy other dishes on our next trip!“

“variety of Merchandise,something for everyone“

“Passed this place every time we frequented Key West, finally stopped last night. GREAT EXPERIENCE! From the eclectic menu that has virtually something for everyone to the insanely fresh seafood, this is a must do if passing through Cudjoe Key (<30 mins from Key West). Our meal began with joining the waitlist online from the comfort of our vacation home. Upon arriving to a packed lot, we were thrilled that we had a short wait due to the online waitlist. Next, the service. The bartender was extremely vigilant as we waited for our table and kept us well hydrated. Beer, wine, and full bar are a plus. Wine list was VERY good with many higher end half bottles, a joy when only one person drinks wine. Craft cocktails on the menu looked amazing. Our server, Gabby, is a fabulous asset to this place. Knowledgeable about the menu, very attentive to our needs (I drink a lot of water-she kept me full!), and just a pleasant server who represents this establishment very well. The food was hands down some of the best we’ve had in the keys. The tuna bowl was fresh, prepared perfectly and paired with fresh ingredients. The swordfish was so fresh that the taste was perfection. The key lime pie was not to be missed!!! Do yourself a favor and plan a trip to this unique place. The food, the people, and the drinks are each worth the trip!!!“

“We had the most amazing dinner at South of the Seven in the Florida Keys last night 🌴✨ Chef Paul and his wife Kris have been dear family friends for years, and it’s always so special to visit them and enjoy their incredible hospitality. Although we miss them in Safety Harbor, it's always such a treat to visit them here in Sugarloaf💕 The food was, as always, outstanding— our boys devoured the tomahawk steak and chocolate cake 😍 and we loved every bite of our meals. (My fav is the grouper collars in Buffalo sauce! Mitchel got his long awaited duck wings) It’s not just a restaurant; it’s a place to make memories. Something we enjoy each year 🥰 If you’re ever in the Keys, this gem is a must-visit! Thank you, Chef, for another unforgettable evening. 💙“

“Love live music night nights, this last Wednesday with Take 2 band was lots of fun. Hope to see them on stage again soon.“

“Love this place!! Portobello Fries a must!“

“great place to eat! very friendly and prompt service!!!“

“This place is a must visit while in the Keys. A great pub with atmosphere to spare. A classic, can’t miss! Menu is fantastic and you have to leave a dollar or two! -JP“