9 Best Ice Cream Shops near Sumterville

“New Find! And we’re in love!! You can’t beat the taste of rich creamy custard. They have a great assortment and now my 10 year old loves the coffee flavor 😅. The owners and staff seem very knowledgeable and helpful. It’s super clean and the action is great!! We will definitely be back“

“Mystic Ice Cream is amazing! owned by Darrell and Lisa. Lisa makes all the ice cream by hand! They have 15 classic flavors and 15+ adult flavors. The adult flavors are very unique and include alcohol. So yummy! Darrell and Lisa are so friendly; it is nice to have these business owners in our neighborhood.“

“The ice cream mixture is sooo good!“

“Ice cream after the show . breakfast before departure. Great food and the friendliest Staff we’ve had on our visit to the villages.“

“Darlin’s Sweet Shoppe in The Villages is a charming spot to satisfy your sweet tooth. Located at Sawgrass Grove, it offers creamy, flavorful ice cream along with a tempting selection of cakes, pies, and cookies. Favorites like their rich chocolate desserts and specialty ice cream flavors keep locals coming back. The atmosphere is welcoming, and the staff is friendly and helpful.“

“I love the variety of flavors and toppings.“

“went tonight to get ice cream for me and my 2 grandkids. it was already getting dark so I went through the drive thru. when I got home the order was completely wrong. I called immediately so I could get it corrected but I was told all sales are final and it was my job to make sure it was right. I specifically asked for vanilla soft serve with whip cream and toppings. when I got home it was all chocolate ice cream and one did not have all the toppings on it. it cost over $12 plus tip for 2 kids ice cream and 1 small. they don't give you a receipt to see what all your being charged for and you pay before they make your order so when it's wrong your stuck with it regardless. the girls working were extremely rude when I called them and didn't even apologize, instead they told me it was my fault for not checking it. TERRIBLE SERVICE AND WILL NEVER RETURN.“

“I’m from Texas here for work. When I was driving by, I noticed your store I had to stop. I am a chocolate fan. Thank you for putting a smile on my face..“

“Twice there has been an issue with my order but the manager on duty Eli, was very polite as he corrected my order. This place is busy! Expect a wait to order even though staff is moving efficiently. If there is a problem, Eli will fix it. But should he be the only manager on duty?
The food is great! the staff is young and inexperience shows. If I were Culver's, I would provide more supervision but I still recommend this place for families, friends or solo dining.“