Plum Tomato Pizzeria

Looking for a good ma and pa pizza place. We are here on vacation and found this place. We got the meat lovers pizza. It was so good! Fresh meat on the pizza is not imitation. Would recommend a thousand times. Wish we had them back home in PA!

Ordered online from their website it did not itemized fees to pay. After paying it had a delivery fee which is fine of $4 plus tip and live 1.1 miles away. Than it also had a non cash fee of $1 (no cash choice offered), a surcharfe fee of $5 dollars. So we called to cancel. Marci answered, she gave us a hard time saying its already being made and it takes 10 days to get a refund. I explained the reason for the cancelation is due to the extra surcharge fees. She made the cancelation process long and annoying. Said Andy the owner is going to cancel in on Tuesday. Asked her for her name 3 different ways before she provided it to me. Had no cancelation confirmation to give and were just suppose to trust they don't forget to process it. Poor service. Also, why am I paying over $10 dollars in non cash, delivery and sur charge fee. Me ordering online is a convince for you, for me its easier to call the order in.

This little restaurant was SO good!! It's a little hole in the wall place that I cannot recommend enough! I had cauliflower pizza. So thin and crispy. We had salad and bruschetta. Alfredo. Lasagna. Everything was delicious!! Parking is limited but worth fighting for. Do it! Go!!

Not very attentive.

Really good wings, but I'm tired of businesses being cheap with the amount of blue cheese dipping sauce they give out. If I order six wings, I want more than just a tiny bit of sauce. Especially when I order 12.

This is the best traditional pizza I've had since moving from NJ to Florida. The place reminds me of the family restaurant I used to go to before I moved.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Great Pizza

Love PTP! Their chicken Alfredo with linguini is one of our favorites and all their soups are really really good!

11/27/24
I formerly enjoyed dining here with friends and ordering pizza, but for the second time, the burnt bottom was disappointing. After calling to request no dry, burnt pizza, I was still given a crispy and burnt one. The girl attributed it to the nature of oven pizza.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Bruschetta

Meh. Nicer places with better food. Toppings are sparse and it's too much money for being so less than average. The manager also verbally abuses her one server which makes my skin crawl.

Again, so so so many other places, don't waste your time and money here. ??‍♀️

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

I’ve been in business for 25 years. I’ve been coming here for a very long time. Pizza is awesome .. Stromboli awesome garlic, chicken wings awesome…. This is a normal business. It has its ups and downs, but overall great little place to eat.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great pizza and outstanding lunch and weekly specials!!!!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Great Pizza

Oh Mamma Mia, Plum Tomato Pizzeria is the Real Deal! ??

If food could sing, the Pasta Pomodoro with shrimp would be serenading us with a love ballad! The sauce was so fresh and natural, I swear I heard it say, "I just came from Nonna's garden!" The shrimp? Perfectly cooked, plump little swimmers that made us want to do the backstroke right into the bowl.

Then came the Veal Francaise with Alfredo Pasta, and oh boy... That veal was so tender it practically apologized as we cut into it. The Alfredo sauce? Creamy enough to make even a lactose-intolerant soul reconsider their life choices. We’re talking liquid gold here, folks. It was so good I almost wrote it into my will.

Oh, and the bread—good Lord, the bread! You could taste the love in every slice, knowing it was made fresh right there in the kitchen. Honestly, everything tasted like it was crafted by a team of culinary angels who start baking at dawn. The portions were massive, too. If you leave without a box of leftovers, either you’re lying, or you have a black hole for a stomach.

Portions? Let's just say you'll leave with leftovers—or a food coma. Either way, it's a win-win. Honestly, if you're not rolling out of Plum Tomato Pizzeria like a stuffed ravioli, did you even eat?

Bottom line: 10/10, will be dreaming about this meal for the foreseeable future. Buon appetito! ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Thank you for opening the day after Milton. We appreciate you and will forever be a patron. Sorry some folks weren’t nice even though you were working off a generator and a ghost staff. Thank you again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sat at the bar and had a great meal. Veggies, salad, and bruschetta.
The service was pleasant and accommodating.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bruschetta, Great Pizza

Amazing pie!
Staff are great too.
Love the Plum.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5