50 Best Italian Restaurants near Brookhaven

“What can I say other than it’s amazing 🤩! The food is delicious and fresh always hot and done to perfection. Love the four cheese ravioli with the San Remo sauce or highly recommend the Salmon or Grouper.. the potatoes melt in your mouth and the Grouper… Oh don’t leave without dessert 🍮 Cheesecake or the absolute hands down best tiramisu on the planet!!“

“es un lugar muy bonito y callado“

“I would highly recommend BoccaLupo. We thoroughly enjoyed everything from the drinks, appetizers, entrees, veggies, and desserts. Very different drink and food menu adds to this top notch restaurant. All servers are very knowledgeable in the menu and daily taste specials. Also, they make excellent recommendations if u ask. I was impressed when they changed silverware after each course. Classy! Top it off with homemade pasta and your tastebuds will thank you. We will be back!!!“

“We had an incredible anniversary dinner this past weekend. The wagyu truffle ravioli is to die for! The service was fantastic.“

“Italiano vero 🥰🇮🇹“

“I enjoyed a most delicious lunch at Baronda
The service was attentive suggesting several dishes which were divine. I am a trained cook and appreciated the flavors, freshness and how light all the dishes were just to my liking. Best calamari I’ve ever had.“

“The sachetti (little purses) are to die for. The Marsala crème sauce is delicious“

“So many great options. I like sandwiches and order Meatball Parm, White Stripes or Muffalleta often. Fig salad and eggplant parm are special treats. Snickerdoodles can solve world problems.“

“Tiramisu is worth the hype. Steak was cooked really well although they didn't ask for preference. Not a full bar so limited drinks for cocktails. The polenta cakes were fine, crispy potatoes were surprisingly good. Biggest complaint is service - just didn't feel very attentive in general. You would expect better service with the vibe being intimate and cozy.“

“Love all the Storico restaurants...food and service is great... great vibe at Forza!“

“Ex New Yorker here. By far the best Italian food I've ever had. Great service and atmosphere, too. I can't wait to go back. DELICIOUS!!!“

“We will definitely come again! I had visited with my partner and a friend for my birthday. The atmosphere was very pretty! To make it better, the food was amazing also (and reasonably priced!). Our server was attentive and excellent. Definitely an unforgettable and pleasant experience! One of my favorite restaurants now!“

“Absolutely love this place!“

“Absolutely amazing food, service,and atmosphere!“

“This restaurant has been delicious and I love it because it’s having a great taste and I love the restaurant because it has 2 floors and has a staircase and an elevator so that I can sit down on the table and eat.“

“Very nice staff & great food!“

“This was my first visit. I called to ask about parking. I didn't get explicit instructions and when I found parking I wasn't sure how to get to the restaurant. There was a long delay in getting drinks. As a matter of fact, another table was sat after my party and they received beverages while we continued to wait. I would say we waited about 20 minutes. We reminded the waiter twice. The water glasses are small and in 90 degree weather you tend to want more water. I had to request a carafe of water because of the small glasses and we all drank lots of water due to the weather. The prosciutto and fruit was tasty. Meatballs were ok. I had the Cache de pepe. My pasta was undercooked, chewy and was warm not hot when it arrived. Nice lively atmosphere but missed the mark.“

“We tried this a couple of weeks ago. We came early and got lucky to get a table because after us there was always a wait. Friendly service and the food a solid 10. We had the Cesar and Arugula salads. Both phenomenal. Then lemon pepper wing’s. Very moist and delicious. Then he had their version of a meat lover and I had black olives with sausage. It was a Wed and they have half off the wine by glass or bottle. We can’t wait to go back!“

“My family has been going here for decades! The whole staff treats you like family. If you go in, prepare to fill your car with food, cheeses, breads and treats! Quality food, A+ Service, and will always come back for more!“

“Fantastic! A different Italian experience!“

“The entire experience was amazing. The food is so delicious that it will make you dance in your seat with joy. Coming from out of state, valet parking was much appreciated. Our waiter Tyler was so helpful and fun. A perfect date day trip and meal. ❣️“

“We stopped in very early on the way home, around 3:30 pm. The hostess was very kind to the only server working at that time & asked us to wait for 10-15 minutes, to allow her to catch up and supper staff to arrive. After a short wait that was no issue at all, our server, Daijah came to the table & proceeded to give amazing attention to my wife & I for the next hour. She offered excellent food suggestions which we partially used. My wife's lobster spaghetti and my choice of dessert, their butter cake. We began with the tomato bruschetta & it was perfect. My wife ordered a bottle of wine with the meal, handled perfectly by Daijah. Angelo came by & checked on the meal and service during the entrees. All of which were incredible. I had the wagyu stuffed shells, in spicy red sauce, which was phenomenal! Our desserts of butter cake & creme brulee, were also superb. Kris came by at the end & we were happy to congratulate him on a perfect meal & experience. We will definitely be back soon!!!!“

“Food and service was very good!!!“

“Our waiter was fabulous! Sadly, we did not get his name but we absolutely loved him. Friendly, happy and got our orders correct! The food was delicious. If we come back up here again, we'll most definitely make it a point to stop in for a meal.“

“Food was great and the staff very attentive!“

“A bit of a mixed experience. The pasta and sausage entree was very good. The stuffed chicken was just ok, not nearly as flavorful as expected. Service was solid but nothing exceptional. The bruschetta app was excellent. Prices are reasonable for the quality of the food“

“We had lunch here today and highly recommend! Great cocktails and atmosphere. The food was delicious and fresh! Definitely will be back!“

“The service was awesome. Pierre was very engaging. It's better to buy a bottle of 🍷. You get more for the cost. My meal was very good. I loved the bread.“

“Delicious Italian cuisine. Great atmosphere and the service was perfect.“

“Highly recommend. Great food, great wine, great service.“

“Awesome Food we wanted Pizza and they were Perfect 👍we will definitely go back! Service was great too!!!“

“Had a great time here last night celebrating my wife's birthday. Food was so good, and our server was knowledgeable and attentive. The interior looks and feels great! We brought our 3 teenagers here and all loved it.
I had the shrimp pasta, which was really tasty and had a little kick to it. Great addition to the neighborhood, thank you!“

“We went to celebrate my daughters 21st Birthday! The greeters were attentive as soon as we entered. Our waiter was phenomenal- Daniel from Italy, and the food was delish. This restaurant sits right on the Beltline, so we were able to take a relaxing after dinner stroll. Would go back again! Thumbs up!“

“Where I like to go to celebrate birthdays.“

“I’ve gone in the last decade or so, I’ve tried a different cake/cheesecake slice. And every single time, I’m left feeling perfectly satisfied. The ambiance exudes “European decadence”, from the intricate bathroom detailing to the delicate cursive script written inside the coffee cups. Moreover, I always love how many people are also here near midnight with a slice and coffee in-hand, especially on those random weeknights. Absolutely one of my favorite spots in the city, and it checks all the boxes to be considered a must-visit spot for anyone.“

“Just tried this restaurant with my family. Highly recommend. Food was fresh. Pasta is made in house. The salad was fresh. Service was consistent. Place is beautiful. We will definitely be back.“

“EVERYTHING WAS NICE FROM EMPLOYEES TO FOOD! My new favorite place!“

“Let me start off by saying that this is a staple restaurant for me to dine at every time I'm visiting Atlanta. I recently dined at St. Cecilia in Atlanta while visiting to celebrate my daughter's 28th birthday. The restaurant itself is stunning—the ambience is warm and inviting, and the food was absolutely delicious. Everything about the atmosphere set the stage for a memorable evening. However, the service did not reflect the same quality. Our server, Richard, unfortunately made us feel rushed and did not accommodate my request to acknowledge my daughter's birthday, which was very disappointing given the occasion. Since I was in town to celebrate her all week, I had hoped this dinner would be a highlight, but his lack of attentiveness put a damper on it. To the restaurant's credit, the manager did step in as we were leaving and made an effort to address the situation once she saw how upset I was. I truly appreciated her professionalism and concern—it helped end the evening on a more positive note. Overall, I would still recommend St. Cecilia for its outstanding food and ambience, but I would caution others about the service experience. I will return in the future, but I'll be sure to request a different server.“

“We were here on our way to North Carolina. Definitely worth the stop!“

“Love Campagnolo! Great food, drinks and atmosphere. A midtown gem. 💎“

“Had the bbq chicken pizza and a slice of the chocolate cake. Pizza was awesome and the cake was great and so big I had leftovers even with two of us eating it. The servers were also really friendly.

Parking: shopping center parking“

“This is our go-to brunch spot for Virginia Highlands. Love love love the veggie benedict, french toast and bottomless mimosas! Osteria is a neighborhood establishment and we've been going here for over 20 years. Our kids were raised going to weekly dinner here and still obsess over the kids mac and cheese even though they're grown. The brunch is a great addition. The owner does a lot for the neighborhood.“

“We celebrated our 3rd wedding anniversary at Il Premio — and it was truly unforgettable. From the moment we walked in, we felt genuinely special. The ambiance is elegant and warm, the service was thoughtful and kind, and every dish was a work of art.

The staff made us feel welcomed and celebrated, and the food… absolutely exquisite. The lighting, the interior, the overall atmosphere — everything came together so beautifully. It felt like the restaurant itself was part of our celebration.

Thank you for making our special day feel magical. We’ll definitely be back!“

“Great food great service ? really enjoyed“

“Are you kidding me? 10’s across the board. Worth every penny. I got the cornbread bowl and it was delicious, hot, and flavorful. Portion size is great. I couldn’t finish it all. Food came out a little after the ETA but it was well worth it! Highly recommended.“

“I think they changed chiefs, food isn't as good this time around. Also told us they ran out of bread, which was very strange to me. The restaurant on a weekend was dead. My drink also was not the best. Bar is beautiful though, lots of space for bigger parties.“

“Just had the most delicious sausage and banana pepper pizza (got it to go and added our own calabrian peppers and fresh basil) ! The dough and crust were just right. The manager works his butt off to make sure that the customers are happy.“

“My wife and I enjoyed our lunch even more because of the wonderful service by Dayanna, Daija, Aiden and Cassandra. The food came fast and hot. All in all, a great experience. Olive Garden should be proud to have such a talented young staff representing them. Well done. G-d bless you and your business.“

“I’m so happy I ate Good food, great staff, and nice customer service. So glad to have such incredible food and I will always visit il Giallo Osteria & Bar“

“Crispina Ristorante & Pizzeria is a must try restaurant in Cumberland Atlanta. We ordered fettuccini Alfredo and Primavera pasta. Pepperoni & Home run pizza and the Calamari. Everything was spot on. Our server is Forest. Thank you so much for the fast and great service. Anyone craving for Italian Cuisine. We highly recommend this place. You guys deserves a 5 ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ rating..“