Peytons Pie Company - Gainesville

Best pizza in Gainesville ga hands down. Crispy authentic wood fire pizza full of flavors. 10/10 highly recommend!!!!

To get to Peytons, you go into the Sweet Magnolia’s (SM) entrance. The pizza shop is past the SM counter and the art gallery, further into the building. The kitchen, including the large wood-fire oven, is openly visible from the counter, and service was kind. I’ve ordered delivery and pickup. The workers mistook my pizza order for another and had to remake it, but they were very kind and quickly made the correct pizza for me. Both delivery and pickup pizzas were fresh. The dough is tougher/chewier than my preferred soft crusts, but it’s reminiscent of sourdough pizza crust if you’re into that. The mozzarella is fresh, not pre-shredded. The sauce tastes just slightly sweet, and there’s plenty sauce on the pizza. The pepperoni isn’t very spicy, which could be good to some. The Calabrian chili is also mild but delicious. The pizzas are large, and given the location on the square, pricing makes sense. If you want a thin, glutinous (in texture), and fermented crust, go here instead of, say, Atlas, where you’ll find fluffy crusts.

We ordered on DoorDash. Based on the photos that we saw. The pricing was outrageous, so we expected that we would get some extraordinary food. Not so! Burnt garlic bread.tough as a shoe leather. Very little cheese. The chicken for my Caesar salad looks like it came out of a can. No sign of grilling for sure!

Delicious pizza and great staff. Highly recommend

It’s difficult to find, tucked away behind Sweet Magnolia’s. The pizza was good and the toppings were solid.

Peyton’s Pie never disappoints! From the moment you walk in, the service is top-notch—friendly, fast, and welcoming. But the real star is the pizza. Perfectly crispy crust, fresh ingredients, and just the right balance of flavors in every bite. Whether you're a classic pepperoni fan or love a creative specialty pie, they’ve got something that hits the spot. Easily one of the best pizza spots around!

Very disappointing. Ordered a simple Margherita pizza. I don't mind a little char, but this is ridiculous

This place was awesome. Pizza and atmosphere were very enjoyable. Great service from Wisin, Freddy, Mashall and Hudson!

This is the best pizza in town! Plus there is a wine bar in the space great place to take the fam! Archie and the crew are amazing!

We love supporting local businesses and do often. I wanted to love this place. We excitedly visited the pop-up Christmas side and walked up to the bar to find out how to order. We were greeted with a hand held up and then a very rude greeting. We were told our order would be taken after everyone at the bar was taken care of first. Fair. So, we chose to leave the fun side knowing it was going to be a long wait. We went overto the regular Peyton Pie side to eat. We placed our order only to find out later we could have stayed on the Pop-up side and walked over, placed our order and they would’ve brought our order to us on the pop up side. The bartender failed to tell us that. Would’ve been nice to know! My daughter ordered the $11 tomato soup. I was blown away when it came out. The very small cup wasn’t even full. I expected a bowl of soup for that price…not a cup and not a cup that wasn’t even full. My husband and father’s $30 16” pizza was burnt. My mother and I order the wings that are normally like $16.99 for 8 wings but were a 1/2 price special and don’t come with celery. They were good but definitely would not be worth the regular price. The food is overpriced. We won’t be back.

Peyton’s Pie Co. Is hidden in the back of the Market Place on the square in Gainesville. Tasty wood fired pizza, great service. Traditional and unique topping selections.
“Legalize Marinara”

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: My Honey Is Hotter Than Yours

Every pizza that comes out of the ovens at Peyton's is a work of art. From taste to texture. These guys are truly Picasso's with pepperoni. My favorite pizza is My honeys hotter than yours.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, My Honey Is Hotter, My Honey Is Hotter Than Yours

Had a fantastic lunch! Pizza was perfect but not as good as our server Heather. She was attentive and had great recommendations on the menu. We will be back soon!!

We had an excellent time with exceptional service from Jaden! She answered all questions about menu and food was delicious!! Highly recommend and ask for Jaden! She was a fun server!

@BetterDays at Peyton's Pies Flowery Branch is fantabulous! Great drinks, excellent food from Peyton's, lively and fun atmosphere. Ashley is always on top of things behind the bar and running tables like a pro. She is amazing at keeping up with our, and the crowds, drink orders and wonderful to interact with her smiling and super friendly attitude. ❤️❤️