Peytons Pie Company - Gainesville

118 Main St SW Suite E, Gainesville
(678) 943-2900

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

My Honey Is Hotter Than Yours
Homemade Vanilla Creme Brulee
Creamy Tomato Soup
Margherita Pizza
Pigs and Olives
Pepperoni Pizza
Lots of Cheese
Honey Chipotle
Garlic Bread

Featured items
Garlic Bread
Garlic Bread with roasted garlic, smoked gouda, shredded mozzarella, parmesan, and black pepper - add bacon + $2
Greasy New Yorker
With extra fresh mozzarella, and extra pepperoni
My Honey Is Hotter Than Yours
Fresh mozzarella with pepperoni, Calabrian chilies, red onion, local honey, fresh basil, and cilantro
The Godfather
Fresh mozzarella, smoked gouda, meatballs, and pesto
Margherita
Fresh mozzarella with extra virgin olive oil, parmesan, and basil
The Supreme Leader
Fresh mozzarella with pepperoni, Italian sausage, meatballs, roasted garlic, red onion, and wild mushrooms
Classic Peytons
Fresh mozzarella with Italian sausage, peppadew peppers, and fresh basil
Seahorse
Fresh Mozzarella with pepperoni, peppadew peppers, red onion, and fresh basil
Creme Brulee
Homemade creme brûlée
Honey Chipotle BBQ Chicken
Fresh mozzarella with grilled chicken, BBQ sauce, cilantro, and red onions
The Super Billy
Fresh mozzarella, locally made hot sauce, grilled chicken, red onion, cilantro, and buttermilk viniagrette
Pigs and Olives
Fresh mozzarella with pepperoni, roasted garlic, tapenade, and fresh basil
Fanta
Mexican Style Fanta

Sauces
Pizza Sauce
Buttermilk Vinaigrette
Caesar

Beverage
Monster
Fanta
Mexican Style Fanta
Sweet Tea
Powerade
Unsweetened Tea

Dessert
Creme Brulee
Homemade creme brûlée
Cinnamon Sugar Pizza
Cinnamon sugar and homemade icing
Gayle's Italian Cream Cake
with toasted pecans, coconut and cream cheese frosting

Pies
Garlic Bread
Garlic Bread with roasted garlic, smoked gouda, shredded mozzarella, parmesan, and black pepper - add bacon + $2
Greasy New Yorker
With extra fresh mozzarella, and extra pepperoni
The Godfather
Fresh mozzarella, smoked gouda, meatballs, and pesto
My Honey Is Hotter Than Yours
Fresh mozzarella with pepperoni, Calabrian chilies, red onion, local honey, fresh basil, and cilantro
Margherita
Fresh mozzarella with extra virgin olive oil, parmesan, and basil
The Super Billy
Fresh mozzarella, locally made hot sauce, grilled chicken, red onion, cilantro, and buttermilk viniagrette
Seahorse
Fresh Mozzarella with pepperoni, peppadew peppers, red onion, and fresh basil
The Supreme Leader
Fresh mozzarella with pepperoni, Italian sausage, meatballs, roasted garlic, red onion, and wild mushrooms
Classic Peytons
Fresh mozzarella with Italian sausage, peppadew peppers, and fresh basil
Honey Chipotle BBQ Chicken
Fresh mozzarella with grilled chicken, BBQ sauce, cilantro, and red onions
Pigs and Olives
Fresh mozzarella with pepperoni, roasted garlic, tapenade, and fresh basil
Build Your Own Pizza
Choose your toppings
The SFI
Marscapone, roasted garlic, wild mushrooms, black truffle, lemon, prosciutto, basil, and an olive oil rosemary brushed crust
Lots of Cheese
Fresh mozzarella with smoked gouda, shredded mozzarella, parmesan, and basil

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+22 photos
Photo credit: google
+21 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

To get to Peytons, you go into the Sweet Magnolia’s (SM) entrance. The pizza shop is past the SM counter and the art gallery, further into the building. The kitchen, including the large wood-fire oven, is openly visible from the counter, and service was kind. I’ve ordered delivery and pickup. The workers mistook my pizza order for another and had to remake it, but they were very kind and quickly made the correct pizza for me. Both delivery and pickup pizzas were fresh. The...
May 2025
Peyton’s Pie never disappoints! From the moment you walk in, the service is top-notch—friendly, fast, and welcoming. But the real star is the pizza. Perfectly crispy crust, fresh ingredients, and just the right balance of flavors in every bite. Whether you're a classic pepperoni fan or love a creative specialty pie, they’ve got something that hits the spot. Easily one of the best pizza spots around!
March 2025
Peyton’s Pie Co. Is hidden in the back of the Market Place on the square in Gainesville. Tasty wood fired pizza, great service. Traditional and unique topping selections.
“Legalize Marinara”
September 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Sweet Magnolia's Cafe & Bakery - 118 Main St SW
Cafe, Bakery, Vegetarian
The Stag - Chophouse - 110 Main St SW
Steak House
Harold's Honky Tonk Bar & Grill - 212 Spring St SE

Peytons Pie Company - Gainesville

118 Main St SW Suite E, Gainesville, GA 30501
(678) 943-2900