Fatty's Pizza

Name: Fatty's Pizza
Address: 587 Cherry St, Macon, Georgia, 31201, US
Telephone: (478) 744-9880
Price range: $
Rating: 3.6

$ • Pizza, Chicken Wings, Salad

Hours:
587 Cherry St, Macon
(478) 744-9880

Menu Order Online

About Fatty's Pizza

Fatty's Pizza provides attentive service with friendly staff, making it a great place to satisfy hunger after exploring Macon's downtown. The standard pizzas are good, though some customers feel they don’t put enough sauce on them, even with special requests. The cheese and spinach pizza remains a standout, and the calzones, filled with mozzarella, ricotta cheese, and pepperoni, are highly recommended, especially the large size which tastes even better reheated. The garlic parmesan wings are small and tender, offering a variety of flavors, and many customers praise the cheesebread, describing it as the best ever and like a mini-pizza.

Despite arriving close to closing time, the welcoming staff and delicious, well-priced food left a positive impression. However, there have been concerns about customer service, particularly with management changes affecting how complaints are handled. On busy nights, such as Fridays and Saturdays, the restaurant sees a lot of takeout business, and long wait times can occur, so calling ahead is recommended to avoid delays.

Fatty's Pizza also features great deals, such as two slices of pizza with one topping and a soft drink for only $5, which many find to be a fantastic value. The interior has a cool, old-school Italian pizza vibe, with funny sayings posted on the walls that add to the atmosphere. While the pizza may not be the best some have ever had, it remains a popular choice for a casual meal in Macon. The limited outdoor seating with live music across the street adds to the fun experience.