Johnny's New York Style Pizza
$ • Pizza, Italian, Vegetarian
Hours:
24 Old Jackson Rd, McDonough
(770) 954-4225
About Johnny's New York Style Pizza
Customers' Favorites
Johnny's New York Style Pizza Reviews
Share your opinion about Johnny's New York Style Pizza
By far the worst experience with the employees and the food I’ve been coming to Johnny’s pizza for years and my wife is pregnant right now. She tried one of the pizzas did not like it so we told the waitress to take it off my (wife only ate a half a slice of pizza) So we ate our large Greek salad together instead and when it came down to paying the bill, they still made me pay for my pizza that nobody ate. I’ve never been to a restaurant where they don’t accommodate to...read full review
Received pizza with no meat when requested extra meat.
Unfortunately every time I order pizza the dough is undercooked and raw. I don’t care if it takes more than 20 minutes to cook one slice, I would rather wait then be given raw pizza dough. It’s unacceptable to serve food like that.
Also the dinner entrees I’ve tried are served and soaked in water. There is always a puddle of water in the bottom of the dish.
I don’t know if they aren’t straining the water from the pasta or what the problem is but it seems like...read full review
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Sunday | 12 - 8PM |
Johnny's New York Style Pizza offers a welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff. Their menu features a variety of options, including slices, garlic bites, meat lover calzon, and Philly steak stromboli, all made with crispy and greasy New York-style pizza crust. The restaurant provides convenient parking spots, with extra parking available in the back on busy nights, and offers curbside pickup. It is a family-friendly restaurant with a kids menu, and the space is accessible for wheelchair users despite no stairs. Customers can enjoy a good pie that is ready quickly, though sometimes food may take around 20 minutes to arrive. The owner makes meatballs using a recipe from his Italian mother, adding a special touch to the menu. Guests often praise the food as very good and delicious, with some noting that the calzone and marinara are excellent. The cinnamon garlic knots are popular, though some find them bread balls with little cinnamon or garlic. The service is fast and friendly, with servers making customers feel at home. The restaurant offers reasonable prices and generous portions, allowing guests to enjoy a meal and sometimes take leftovers home. Its small-town New York atmosphere makes it a popular spot for families and pizza lovers alike.