13 Best Pizza Restaurants in Peachtree City

“We went there last night and had an amazing time. The food was real Italian (not Italian American like many chains), I had the Carbonara Roma style (no cream, just egg, cheese, and pancetta). But everything was amazing, Italian style eating so don't be in a rush, sit, talk, enjoy as delicious they bring out delicious plates with no running around. I've lived in several parts of Italy, and hadn't found real un-Americanized Italian till now. I would highly recommend it. The hosts/owners a brother and sister and friendly an ensuring everyone has an amazing time.“

“We went last night for both my daughters birthdays.. (11 and 5) we had a pretty big group, there were 13 of us but 6 were kids.. we had the most amazing server! She was extremely sweet, really went out her way to make sure we were completely happy along with serving other tables! She was extremely patient with all the kids and had a constant smile! Not to mention the food was absolutely amazing!!! She truly made my daughters birthday dinner amazing!! Thank you mellow mushroom ptc for the great experience!! We will definitely be back!“

“Wonderful as always!!!“

“This place is amazing. Had the lunch special. 10.00 for pizza and salad. The salad was fantastic. Lots of croutons, fresh cheese best balsamic dressing I've ever had. The pizza is so good. Fire stone wonderful crust did not skimp on toppings. This by far is the best pizza l've ever had and the waitress Kate was outstanding very tentative.“

“Newk's is a fantastic spot that never disappoints! Their pizzas are simply awesome—perfectly crispy crusts, fresh toppings, and packed with flavor. The salads are equally impressive, with a great variety of fresh ingredients and generous portions. However, what really sets Newk's apart is the exceptional service. The employees are incredibly patient, attentive, and truly go above and beyond to make sure every guest feels welcomed and satisfied. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite or enjoying a sit-down meal, Newk's always delivers on both food and hospitality. Highly recommend!“

“Kacey was awesome with our large party last night! She was very attentive and made sure we all had what we needed and managed the whole table to perfection. She is amazing!“

“I ordered delivery 12/11/2021 I was told by the manager they were short staffed for deliveries and it would take a while to make my 2 belly busters and cheese sticks for a holiday party. no biggie I understood. pizza showed up on time. we tipped the delivery dude extra because I know what that's like having to rush for deliveries. this was our 7th or 8th time ordering and the quality was amazing as always. very satisfied as a customer. support this shop. worth it every time. can't recommend there pizza enough!“

“Their food is great, and customer service even better. This restaurant is very intentional about their operation. I'm impressed!“

“If you want a Dominos takeout deal, this isn't your place for this meal. BUT...if you want the best pizza, salad, atmosphere, and overall experience...it doesn't get better than YourPie in Peachtree City. It was our first time to eat there. We will be back again...SOON!!!“

“We usually go to another pizza place for our weekly pizza night, but tonight we ended up at Marco's. I have to day, they giu working there tonight, I believe his name was Brandon, took the time to explain the menu, and he prepared the food in a very timely manner. The food was fantastic, and we will definitely be back next week to see Brandon.“

“The food and service are great“

“The crust is the best! Sauce good too.“

“Great food and service, will make them a regular when in town .“