Pizza Restaurants near Senoia

“It’s rare that I write reviews, but our experience at Borgo absolutely deserves one — and for context, my wife and I are truly food obsessed. We moved here from Austin, TX and northern New Jersey, both places where excellent Italian food is easy to find. In the three years we’ve lived here, we’ve tried at least 15 restaurants in the area, and every single one has been forgettable, I’ll leave it at that. Borgo changed that instantly. From the moment we walked in, I noticed something unusual: the dining room was full, yet the atmosphere was calm, lively but not loud. When we sat down, we found ourselves next to three older couples speaking Italian. That alone told me we might finally be in the right place. A lot of restaurants claim to be “family owned,” but at Borgo, it’s the real thing. The entire family is from Italy. The owner came over to welcome us personally and took our order with genuine warmth. His wife is the chef. His sister was checking on tables and making sure everything ran smoothly. The whole experience felt like stepping into a small trattoria in a small Italian town and I don’t say that lightly. The food was exceptional. We started with the burrata with prosciutto and an arugula salad. Both were exquisite. The burrata tasted incredibly fresh and was served at the perfect temperature I don’t know if it’s homemade, but it certainly tasted like it. The arugula was vibrant and peppery, as if it had just been picked, and the dressing was beautifully balanced. For mains, we had the trout, the linguine with mushrooms, and the eggplant parm. Every dish was outstanding, but the eggplant parm stopped me in my tracks — I literally closed my eyes after the first bite. It was that good. Dessert was tiramisu and the limoncello cheesecake, and both were flawless. Light, flavorful, and not overly sweet, exactly how they should be. And the service? Flawless. Warm, attentive, personal, the kind of hospitality that makes you feel like you’re eating in someone’s home rather than a restaurant. It took us 45 minutes to drive to Borgo and we cannot wait to go back. After three years of searching, we finally found a place that feels like the real deal. Simply put, our experience was exceptional.“

“I had all but lost hope on restaurants near Fayette County. It seems to have become a who-can-cook -US Foods-and-Sysco-the-best competition and it’s, frankly, boring. Enter Matt’s Smalltown Pizza. I started a new job down the street and popped in for lunch today. I was greeted warmly and immediately seated and served. I was a bit taken aback by the prices on the wings - until they came to my table. Their wings are enormous and I could not finish my order of 10. The food was piping hot (hot enough that I commented to the waitress about it - why does all restaurant food come out almost room temp these days???) and absolutely delicious. The portions are generous and the fries were audibly crispy; my favorite! I can’t wait to come back and bring my family and friends. 5 star experience and food; looking forward to trying more.“

“We had a wonderful lunch at the West Point location! Our waitress Cacey did amazing!“

“I WAS going to give a two star rating, but the customer service team did a good job at trying to make up for the mistakes. I was delivered a pizza over an HOUR after ordering it. It said it would arrive at 6:19, but it kept getting delayed over and over until it eventually arrived right at 7. I ordered it at 5:50, and the location is only 3 miles away, so I found that CRAZY. That being said, I put in my complaint and was given a free pizza coupon for my next visit. I would have settled for a refund, but free pizza is an upgrade in my opinion.

While the delivery was horrible, the actual pizza itself was great! It wasn’t all that hot anymore, but the flavor was wonderful.“

“Wings and pizza were great! Abby was a fantastic server! Food was priced fairly. Highly recommend :)“

“We went last night for both my daughters birthdays.. (11 and 5) we had a pretty big group, there were 13 of us but 6 were kids.. we had the most amazing server! She was extremely sweet, really went out her way to make sure we were completely happy along with serving other tables! She was extremely patient with all the kids and had a constant smile! Not to mention the food was absolutely amazing!!! She truly made my daughters birthday dinner amazing!! Thank you mellow mushroom ptc for the great experience!! We will definitely be back!“

“Had business in Peachtree City today and found ourselves at Pizza54! Had a great lunch of salad and pizza! Wonderful place!“

“This was such a great pizza. My family likes the DIY pizzas more than regular ones anyway, but Your Pie Pizza was one of a kind. The service was excellent... Everyone was extremely friendly and helpful. The wait was short for 4 pizzas and everyone in the family loved them. Highly recommend.“

“Wonderful as always!!!“

“My home away from home!!! GREAT customer service, family environment, and fresh food! Build your pizza the way YOU want it, and pair it with a fresh, delicious salad or wings! I love this place!“