24 Best Pizza Restaurants near Sharpsburg

“We've been to this place only twice but we will definitely be back. My family has quite diverse taste, so it is hard to find a place we all agree on. My husband is not a pizza fan but there are salads, wings, pasta and sandwich options, so he was able to find dishes to try. He is very grudging with praise when we eat out. He reviews the menu like he's studying for the SATs, asks the waitstaff a bunch of questions they usually don't have a ready answer for, and tries to get something new every time. His most common reviews are: he's "not a fan", or the portions weren't right, or they cooked it wrong. He's had the veggie lasagna and the sassy steak and he had no complaints for either. My oldest is 23 and has food allergies, so veggie options are big for us. Usually there are few options for them, sometimes just one! Not a problem here! More on that below. My 17 year old ate the best Philly cheesesteak sandwich years ago and had been chasing that high ever since. The sassy steak is the new king! We all love the cheesy bread- so good!Vegetarian options: There are several veggie options. Of course, being a pizza place, there is veggie pizza but you can also get veggie calzones, stromboli, lasagna, the BEST cheesy bread, veggie rolls and they have bell pepper bowls - a bell pepper stuffed with your choice of pizza toppings. So far, we've tried the cheesy bread, the veggie pizza and veggie lasagna. My husband is notoriously hard to please when we go out to eat but he had grudging praise for the veggie lasagna. That's big, coming from him. ?“

“The people are Awesome. They don't short on customer service..and the food here...??‍♀️ it's just beautiful. I LOVE their ROCKY MARCIANO ❤️ ? ? ♥️ ? ?It's truly good without this change...but I always get it without ground beef and Canadian Bacon and sub it with EXTRA Italian sausage (the BEST!) and I'll put garlic and spinach on it instead. I'd be lying if I said there is another pizza spot just as good as them...there Isn't... That's the TRUTH. I was here the other day and there was a couple here to eat that came from a good distance.. Just because of their ? pizza???.If you have Not tried it yet..do yourself this Justice, you'll LOVE them.I LOVE YOU LEPOMAS!!!!!!!“

“Came in on a Thursday evening with a large party. We were seated on the heated patio! It was my first time there, so I wasn't sure what to expect!After looking over the menu.. I discovered that the pizzas are unique and hand crafted ( see what I did there).. Yes, you can get a plain pepperoni pizza , but why do that when you can live on the edge!! The one that stood out to me the most was the spaghetti and meatball pizza! There was also a Greek gyro, French dip, backyard taco, chicken Alfredo, bacon chicken ranch..etc...The pizza is about a 12 inch so plenty to share with others! I did get the spaghetti and meatballs! It was pretty good! The noodles weren't crunchy, they were soft noodles, it also came with a side of marinara ! Perfect for dipping! The meatballs we in small bite size pieces! Had plenty of cheese, tasted delicious.I also had a Greek salad which was also pretty tasty!Overall I enjoyed my meal and would come again to try the different pizzas.Service was fine, atmosphere was nice! No issues there!“

“Always excellent pizza but DO NOT use doordash for delivery.... Eat in or pick up yourself. Pick it up, they open the box for you to confirm a nice pie and drooling commences... Use door dash and you will end up with a dropped pizza delivered and then attempt to fold it into a calzone... Tears commence...“

“They serve the best gluten-free pizzas in the Fayetteville/ Newnan/ Senoia area. You can custom order your pizza with your favorite toppings. The friendly, welcoming host and waitresses makes you feel like coming home, where everyone is glad you came to have a meal with them! A real small town feeling, true to their name! They offer a large variety of pizzas with regular & G-F crusts, Italian dishes, wings, sandwiches, and salads. They also have an ice cream freezer to pick your favorite dessert!“

“Good pizza, it's worth stopping here for sure.I worked at Neapolitan inspired American pizzerias for several years and have high standards for this type of pizza. Some darker spotting on pizza bottom, crisp across bottom with soft top crust, and a folded slice should have only about 1.5 inches of the tip "droop" when held. Definitely crisper than traditional Neapolitan style, but that's the way most Neapolitan inspired places in the US do it. This place nailed it. I like a bit more char bubbles on the top crust, which you get by increasing oven air temp and doing a long, cold-ferment of your dough, but it's really hard to balance that with oven deck temp through a whole service. This place made sure the crust bottom was perfect, which is the most important part. Really well done.Their seating area is a casual family-style open seating vibe. Perfect for large groups or casual meet-ups with friends. Open service kitchen so you can watch the pizzaiolo working the ovens. Highly recommend“

“Casual dining, individually-made pizzas to order. The menu has a nice selection of their signature combinations, but you can customize them as you like, including choice of crust (white, wheat, gluten-free) and sauce (7 options). My go-to is the 10" personal size Hot Honey Pepperoni. Although, it's a chain/franchise restaurant, between the food and the atmosphere, we'll choose this over a national delivery chain every time, and this particular location is great.Dietary restrictions: Pie doughs are all vegan according to their web site, and they offer vegan cheese. They also have gluten-free crust and toppings.“

“Peachtree city Mellow Mushroom is a wonderful place! The service was excellent, the food was perfect and the atmosphere a delight! Our server Katie was very personable and very professional. The manager came over just to ask us how we were doing and if we were enjoying ourselves. Truly what a manager is supposed to be. My wife and I will definitely go back when we are in the area!“

“My wife and I love the It’s Greek to me pizza. The service has always been outstanding and it’s a fun spot since they have trivia nights and other fun things going on, but they’re also great for takeout. Also, the broccoli bites are amazing.“

“Pizza54 truly exceeded our expectations! The meats pizza, meatball app, fried mozzarella and Italian chicken sandwich were out of this world. Each dish was packed with flavor and cooked to perfection. What made our experience even more memorable was the warm hospitality of the owners. They welcomed us like long-time friends, making us feel right at home. Their attentive service and genuine care for their customers added an extra layer of enjoyment to our visit. Pizza 54 turned out to be the perfect setting for our date night, thanks to the cozy atmosphere and delicious food. We'll definitely be returning for more fantastic meals and friendly vibes!“

“We’ve loved Borgo since they were back in Peachtree City. This is such an amazing spot in every way.The food is top notch, really genuinely Italian food made fresh and with care. We’ve never had a bad dish there, but the bruschetta, the lasagna, and every single filled pasta on the menu are to die for. The wine list is compelling as well! They also have an unbelievably well priced “Italian experience” where everybody at the table gets full portions of 2 appetizer, 2 entrees, and a dessert, and it’s incredible.It’s a family spot, and you can tell. Alessandro is the owner, and he always makes sure to come over and say hello and check in with us. Everyone (from Dominic the bartender, to the host of really well-trained and genuinely lovely food runners, to Adriano who we are always lucky enough to have as our waiter) is extremely personable, knowledgeable about the restaurant and menu, attentive without being overbearing, and fun to chat with.My final heaping of praise are for environment they’ve built. The space itself is gorgeous in every position. The front room is elegant, the back bar is intimate, the patio is lovely, and the upstairs space, which we haven’t been to but looks amazing, always seems to be having a brilliant time. The decor is tasteful and comforting.I love Borgo and I think everyone in the surrounding area should be there all the time. They often have live music, an accordion player or last night an opera singer. It’s the best all around and I wish them every success!“

“My wife and I stopped in for a late lunch today and it was fantastic! The pizza and calzone were both pipping hot and fresh, and the crust was absolutely perfect. We haven't been to a Johnny's in a couple of years so we were very impressed at how good it was. And Nikki was a great server, attentive and very friendly. One of the best pizzas we've ever had, (tomato, mushroom, and spinach), and my wife is from Chicago. Nice job all around!“

“My son loved the lobster soup.My friend loved the Greek salad. My husband and I both loved the French dip sandwich. The "Q" sandwich was also delicious. The macaroni and cheese is unlike any other, it is fantastic. Be sure to get some while there. It is amazing. It is easy to order. After you order you are given a number to display at your table. The food is brought to you, hot foods are hot, cold foods are cold. You do not clean your table when finished, they take care of that.There are tables and booths. There are booths and tables for big parties. They also have pizza. They do a large "to go" business. It is located on the left side of the building. They also have a grab and go area. It is very clean and well lit.Vegetarian options: Salads and soups.Dietary restrictions: There are many choicesParking: Easy to park.Kid-friendliness: Kid menus, atmosphere is conducive to children, high chairs provided.Wheelchair accessibility: Easy to get into restaurant with wheelchair. Tables allow for eating at table while in a wheelchair.“

“Food quality is consistently good and convenient location. Overall service is good but at times they leave dirty dishes on tables when customers leave for long periods of times ~ could attend to clean dishes a little faster to give more seating at times.“

“Our first time here and we had a great experience. The pretzels with cheese sauce were amazing! We also had mozzarella sticks, pepperoni calzone, and meatball sub. The portions were a great value for the price. Also, our service was fantastic! Definitely going back!“

“Delicious food, great atmosphere. Even when it's packed, the wait is never very long, and food still comes out hot and quick.I'm a big fan of their wraps and Flatbread. The burgers are also really good. The skillet cookie dessert is also a family favorite.They have the ability to accommodate large groups also. They have an outdoor enclosed room and also an ample table space indoors. We have celebrated several birthdays here. In general, seating is very comfortable due to the oversized booths.If you're a sports fan, catching a game here is great as there are TVs everywhere.“

“I'm not supposed to have dairy, but the Detroit style pizza here is worth it. Atmosphere gets a 4/5 only because there really isn't an atmosphere. If you're looking for pizza made quickly and accurately and just all around deliciously... get your booty over to Jets.“

“The ladies were absolutely enjoyable! The conversation, the customer service, the explanation of the menu, and all the options, including Krispy Krunchy chicken, were so top-notch! Oh, and the pizza... ?? Delicious. Fresh, hot, and flavourful!You'd never notice this Hunts Brothers because of the location tucked in the corner, but I am SO GLAD we read the reviews and stopped. ??Great Great job you all‼️“

“Solid pizza place with a lot of variety, even if your gluten free. We had pizza, salad, breadsticks, and cannoiles, all for a reasonable price. Beey quick service and the dudes running the place all very respectful for customers waiting and those on the phone.“

“I had my doubts about this place but when I tasted that marinara sauce that came with the chz garlic bread I was lost for words I'm a cook n I got my own marinera recipe but this one is the best I've tested in my life I used to work in few intalian restaurants this hands down the best I've had in a long time the pizza was good crust is beautiful n crucify just like it should I would recommend this to anyone I live 1 hour away n I'll be coming here more often“

“We usually go to another pizza place for our weekly pizza night, but tonight we ended up at Marco's. I have to day, they giu working there tonight, I believe his name was Brandon, took the time to explain the menu, and he prepared the food in a very timely manner. The food was fantastic, and we will definitely be back next week to see Brandon.“

“I don't usually post reviews, but Hunter at the Newnan Hungry Howie's deserves accolades. The store was extremely busy in the middle of a shift change this afternoon and Hunter (I think was his name) was hustling to get people in and out quickly, in a super professional manner. His customer service skills are, by far, the *BEST* I've seen at this location and he deserves recognition for it. I watched him interact with two customers during the rush that must frequent there often, because he knew what they wanted to order both times.I own another small business in town, so I tend to look for exceptional customer service behaviors from customer-facing employees when I'm out and about. Whatever it is, Hunter's got it. If he's not a shift lead or manager already, he should be.“

“I love that their carnivore is not sodden with grease. Their locally famous potato Pizza is great... think loaded baked potatoe on a crust. Fantastic housemade Bleu cheese dressing. I do miss their lunch buffet that went away during covid. Wish they would bring that back.“

“We ordered a catering meal that we were serving to a high school sports team. We called the day before to place the order and the customer service was excellent. My husband went on the day of to pick up the food and it was ready to go at the specified time, packaged beautifully, and still piping hot! The meal was a hit and we were very impressed with the overall experience. Highly recommend.“