El Maguey | Mexican Restaurant
$ • Mexican, VegetarianAbout El Maguey | Mexican Restaurant
Customers' Favorites
Burrito Chile Verde or Chile Colorado
Chili Relleno and Chicken Enchilada
Served with Rice Beans & Tortillas
Cheese Enchilada Rice and Beans
Chile Relleno Beans and Rice
Super Nachos with Carnitas
Soft Tacos with Carnitas
One Taco Choice of Meat
El Maguey Guacamole
Carne Asada Burrito
Recent Reviews
210 ratings
Share your opinion about El Maguey | Mexican Restaurant
Best Mexican on the island. I got beef enchiladas and a Medium gauc, if i got the medium I can’t imagine how big the large is 😮. AMAZING chips. Like this place is legit
Small place; don't let the overall look of the restaurant deter you. It was very clean and the food was exceptional!!! They do have gluten free options (I got a meal similar to taco bell's chicken bowl). Pricing was very cheap compared to most places and the food was soooo good and filling.
El Maguey is tucked off in a small plaza but is as authentic as it can get. Fairly decent pricing with large portions. Depending on when you show up, be prepared to wait as there are about 8 or so tables but regulars and visitors pack this space.
Ordered the wet burrito meal and it was delicious. Slight knuckleball compared to other restaurants is they charge even for your first basket of chips and salsa. Salsa is more on watery end and has a little kick for those that...read full review
Ordered the wet burrito meal and it was delicious. Slight knuckleball compared to other restaurants is they charge even for your first basket of chips and salsa. Salsa is more on watery end and has a little kick for those that...read full review
Hours
| Monday | 11:30AM - 3:15AM |
| Tuesday | 11:30AM - 3:15PM 5 - 7:45PM |
| Wednesday | 5 - 7:45PM 11:30AM - 3:15PM |
| Thursday | 5 - 7:45PM 11:30AM - 3:15PM |
| Friday | 11:30AM - 3:15PM 5 - 7:45PM |
| Saturday | 11:30AM - 3:15PM 5 - 7:45PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
El Maguey is a great little hole in the wall with amazing food and large portions. This place gets BUSY, and the staff are friendly, curious, and knowledgeable. Everything is extremely fresh and made to order, so it may take a little longer but is well worth it. The best Mexican food on the island, authentic and flavorful. It is not your average run of the mill quick order restaurant. Customers recommend the beef chimichangas combo plate. The guacamole is so good. The food is always fresh, always CORRECT, and always good. The restaurant has a small local feel with friendly portions and staff.