10 Best Pizza Restaurants near Paia

“On our way back from Hana we got a little hungry and stopped for a bit to eat. We were quickly seated and Travis took our order. The food was great and we really enjoyed the house made hot sauce. It is a nice little restaurant and we would not hesitate to come again when in the area.“

“Marlow is one of the BEST places to eat on the island. I love everything there. They have my favorite salad & favorite pizza there. I like the salad with garbanzo beans & salami. My favorite pizza is the Salcieta. There meatballs are delicious too, but so is EVERYTHING! They also have a great wine selection. The service is great & the atmosphere is too....“

“Looking for the best pizza of your life? Check out Maui Slice! After taking a hopper for explore Maui for the first time, my mom and I were looking to fill the void with some tasty food. Driving the Road to Hana complicates things as there aren't many places to stop for a real meal for sometimes hours at a time. After finally getting some signal again for the first time since Hana, we elected to give Maui Slice a try. The place itself is rather unassuming, but don't let that fool you. We were the only patrons during the time we were there and had a view of the valley to ourselves. The service was top-notch, and pricing was fair especially for Hawaii. There was one employee working serving a variety of 19" pies as well as individual slices. After a short period of time, we received our deluxe pizza. The quality was superb from the crispy-yet-still-doughy crust, to the flavorful sauce, the perfect amount of cheese, and the deliciously cooked premium toppings. It reminded me of one of my favorite shops growing up, and was a perfect way to wrap up an amazing day on the island. Give Maui Slice a try. You won't be disappointed.“

“Cassanova's is definitely the best Upcountry restaurant for any time — date night, quick bite, special occasion. Consistently delicious flavors, a very respectable wine list, a cool bar if that's where you want to be, cozy vibes. We love the Etruscan chicken and the specials like the veal marsala. The mashed potatoes are better than a grandma's. Kids love this restaurant too and the pasta selections are extensive and delicious. The staff is in a nice groove. Thank goodness for this establishment! I wish I could get a monthly meal pass and eat there 2x per week.“

“We enjoyed lunch at Serpico! The eggplant parm sub was delicious! The portions were large, we added the coleslaw and fries! Also added some extra marinara sauce on the side which was excellent! Hubby had a meatball sub, which he enjoyed. The service was friendly and on point!“

“Wow!! This little pizza place was super busy and yet delivered an amazing pizza!! Very friendly service. It was neat to see the brick oven even with a mobile kitchen. The crust was crispy on the outside and chewy delicious on the inside. Lots of flavorful sauce with fresh toppings. The pizza was piping hot and totally hit the spot!“

“We live in Haiku and the Magic Oven is our go-to for date night. The food is amazing, the service is incredible, and the ambiance is great.If you're vegan, they have some great options for you. And a must not miss: the lilikoi mousse.Don't miss this spot! The staff is so friendly, we byob, and enjoy. We love bringing our pups too!“

“Still one of Maui's Hidden Gems.Recently renovated booths make seating even more comfortable! Food is Fresh and delicious! Sandwiches and Wraps and Coffee oh my! Bakery Goodies are top notch!Pizza available in the late afternoon. ? Worth the drive out to Haiku! Highly recommend this great spot with a casual vibe, great food and super friendly service!“

“Great thin crust NY style pizza, homeade moz sticks with amazing marinara! Very friendly down to earth chef from NJ who clearly knows how true Italian should taste as he's owned and operated the place for over 20yrs. Definitely recommend checking this place out of you're in Maui!“

“I’ve been ordering pizza to take home for years it’s always good.If you like a business please tell them give them 5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️it’s very hard to run a small business after covid please take the time to thank them it really goes a long way“